19 July 2013

Open letter from the Barnet Bloggers

Were Barnet's Tory councillors secretly whipped? 
Barnet bloggers call for an investigation.

At Barnet Council’s full council meeting on 16 July, Councillor Brian Coleman alleged that Barnet’s Conservative members are ‘entirely whipped’ when attending scrutiny and other Council meetings, including those dealing with the highly controversial One Barnet privatisation programme.

According to the Council’s constitution, any whipping arrangements must be declared, but we believe that no such declarations have been made at any of the relevant recent meetings. Such actions would be in breach of the constitution and therefore unlawful.

If Councillor Coleman’s allegations are true, this clearly has very serious implications and casts into doubt the legality of many of the highly significant decisions which have been taken by the current administration, most importantly the decision to grant two massive contracts to Capita and Capita Symonds in the outsourcing of a large number of our local council services.

We therefore call on the Leader of the council, Councillor Richard Cornelius, to instigate an immediate and independent public inquiry into the claims made by his former colleague, and we also ask that the authority’s external auditors at Grant Thornton should as a matter of public interest hold an urgent inquiry into the allegations. Residents need to know whether decisions have been made legally and whether Tory councillors have acted constitutionally.


Derek Dishman
John Dix
Vicki Morris
Theresa Musgrove
Roger Tichborne

19 July 2013

1 comment:

  1. Why would Richard Cornelius need to hold an independent inquiry into the claims? If whipping has occurred, then he already knows about it. I don’t see any benefit in taxpayers money being wasted investigating the bleedin’ obvious.

    There are many ways to whip councillors unofficially and it would be hopelessly naïve for anyone not to realise that all the parties lean on their councillors in some form or other. There will be no paper trail, so an investigation will never find any evidence.

    If you think Brian Coleman is telling the truth, then ask him to explain why he kept silent about these arrangements for so long. To keep quiet about a breach of the constitution is probably a breach of the members code of conduct.


I now moderate comments in the light of the Delfi case. Due to the current high incidence of spam I have had to turn word verification on.