The below cctv is what supports Barnet Council's erroneous belief that a yellow box junction has occurred.
They are misguided in their belief and the person who hit the button to issue a PCN in this case needs more careful training (always assuming it isn't a decision made by AI).
When does a contravention occur?
Mr Mustard set out in the formal representations what was wrong (a response is awaited, this is quite fresh)
This PCN should never have been issued. The problem with legislation for enforcement authorities which gives them huge powers is that according to Lord Mustill in the case of Doody is they are expected to behave properly but what if they don't?
What does fairness require in the present case? My Lords, I think it unnecessary to refer by name or to quote from, any of the often-cited authorities in which the courts have explained what is essentially an intuitive judgment. They are far too well known. From them, I derive that:-
- Where an Act of Parliament confers an administrative power there is a presumption that it will be exercised in a manner which is fair in all the circumstances.
As parking, bus lane and moving traffic PCNs have become such a rich source of revenue for enforcement authorities they have become giddy with power, are abusing it and there is no-one to stop them. The role of adjudicators is to decide on such PCNs as people fight all the way to London Tribunals (or TPT outside London) and no-one is tasked with ensuring is empowered to protect the public from the zealous.
It is no comfort that there is the right to contest a clearly wrongful allegation, which some people are not very well equipped to do, wasting everyone's time and causing worry and there is always the possibility that a new adjudicator or one on a bad day would get the answer wrong.
Many lease companies, wrongly in Mr Mustard's view, simply pay PCNs and unless they transfer liability to the lessee, the PCN is over and the lessee is forced to repay £80 for the PCN and ad admin fee of anything up to £40. That cannot be right.
There is no need for councils to cheat, there are plentiful real contraventions.
For expert yellow box advice, look here.
The end, for now.


























