6 June 2012

Booted out of the (Brunswick) Park

What a turnaround. In May 2010 there were 3 candidates of each colour who stood for Brunswick Park ward. The average vote (of the 3) and the percentage to each party was as follows:

 
2010 Votes %
Cons 3,384 49.9
Labour 1,769 26.1
LibDem 1,170 17.2
Green 463 6.8
Total 6,786 100.0

Fast forward to May 2012 and the results were as follows.
 
2012 Votes %
Cons 1,598 46.1
Labour 1,769 51.1
LibDem 97 2.8

n/a
Total 3,464 100.0

The reasons will be many and varied. A new belief by Labour after the ousting of Brian Coleman AM must have been a major factor and lots of bodies on the street. Mr Mustard himself pushed some BAPS leaflets through letterboxes one Saturday and although they weren't election leaflets as such they did highlight many things that are wrong with the Conservative's One Barnet programme. The bloggers played only a small part in this by-election but every vote helps. Mr Mustard has some ideas for the 2014 elections. By then the bloggers will have done their bit to make sure the One Barnet programme is much more widely known and voters will be armed with knowledge about what you have been doing councillors in the name of One Barnet and some very tough questions indeed. Having a candidate who lived locally was not the vote winner it was thought to be.

As you know Mr Mustard was unimpressed by the leaflet that vaunted the local connections of the conservative candidate Shaheen Mahmood. He thought it was a stupid leaflet (the returning officer had also kicked one leaflet into touch for claims about parking that, to say the least, stretched the truth) and he thought it did a dis-service to one of the other existing conservative councillors in that very ward, Lisa Rutter.



Now Mr Mustard first came across Lisa at a Chipping Barnet Residents Forum. He was not impressed with either her chairing of the meeting, her failure to allow debate or questions or to know the answers to many of them. He engaged afterwards in an email exchange with her about the state of the roads which didn't enhance Lisa in his eyes. It also didn't help that Mrs Angry reckoned that if you squinted at a photo of Toyah Wilcox you would see Lisa. Try it for yourself.


There may be some likeness Mrs Angry but Mr Mustard reckons the best fit is Lisa Simpson (and if Lisa Rutter is reading it is a compliment to be compared to Lisa Simpson who is highly intelligent)

she even has the pearls

Whilst we are on the subject of lookalikes, or not, Mr Mustard couldn't help but notice that the failed candidate reminded him of a Little Britain character (but to have blogged it before the election might have been seen as juvenile behaviour, and not improved democracy, so Mr Mustard resisted the temptation)

standard Private Eye lookalike layout





If Andy Hipkin had stood, as he often does when his carer's back is turned, he would have doubtless have had a landslide victory (whoever he stood for).

Anyway Shaheen is, for now, history. We will have to wait two years to see if she fancies another go in the 2014 election.

Back to Lisa who has spent a year wearing gold chains, cutting ribbons, planting trees and talking to community groups, a role at which she seems to have performed perfectly well.

Mr Mustard thought that he would find out what Lisa thought of the leaflet which banged on about the local nature of the candidate as Mr Mustard has seen no evidence that living about 3 miles from the edge of her ward has led to a lack of knowledge or care. So, Mr Mustard emailed as follows:

Dear Cllr Rutter

As you know there is a by-election tomorrow and I have seen the candidate's letter of 25 May in which she makes it a major plank of the argument to vote for her that she is "the only candidate who lives in the ward". 

Now Boris has joined in today and said "she is the only person for the job" because, after the obvious reason that she is a member of the same party as him, the next reason quoted is "she is the only candidate who lives in the ward".

Isn't this arrant nonsense as you don't live in the ward you represent (perhaps you used to?) and no-one has accused you of not being able to represent the ward properly because you don't live in it, have they? (I would not be at all surprised if come 2014 any candidates who are not resident in the ward gets that fact used against them by the other parties).

Surely as the council votes in full council on matters that affect the whole borough it is sufficient to live within the borough? although even that isn't essential. If you lived in, say, Enfield you could still keep well up to date on Barnet's affairs and be at the Town Hall on time.

What do you think? If living in the ward trumps whatever other good points the candidate supposedly has, then there don't seem to be many? 

Best regards

Mr Mustard
30 May 2012

and Mr Mustard was delighted (thank you Lisa) to receive a speedy and thoughtful reply which was sensibly sent after the polls had closed on 31 May:

Dear Mr Mustard,

Thank you for your email; you raise some interesting points which I can't comment on as I don't design the leaflets. I will however pass them on to our central office. You asked for my thoughts - I personally think a Councillor should at least live in the borough where they represent and I suspect a lot of people actually like the fact the Councillor or candidate lives in the Ward they represent. I don't live in Brunswick Park Ward but I feel I have represented, helped and done a good job for the residents in the Ward over the last 6 years and will continue to do so.

Kind regards

Cllr. Lisa Rutter
So if central office have any sense, they will not be using the fact that the candidate lives in the ward as a virtue to try and influence the electorate in 2014. If you do, then Mr Mustard, and doubtless other bloggers, will examine one ward at a time the residential status of all candidates and listing for you the ones who live outside of the ward as a reason to vote against them. It could get messy.
What one would like to see in a leaflet are the skills which the councillor will bring to the job which will make them a good councillor.
Only 2 years to wait unless we have another by-election.
Yours frugally
Mr Mustard

1 June 2012

DRS - Staff view of the bidders

Doesn't really need any great further comment from Mr Mustard, the lack of trust by the staff in their potential new employers is obvious.

DRS - Evaluation of Meet the Bidders Presentation - ALL Questions Final

31 May 2012

NSL: Never a dull moment




The main moments, so far.

14 December 2011 - Cabinet Resources Committee

AWARD OF CONTRACT – PARKING ENFORCEMENT AND RELATED SERVICES
(Report of the Cabinet Member for Environment– Agenda Item 12)
For the reasons set out in the Cabinet Member’s report, the Committee;
RESOLVED –
1. The contract for the provision of Parking Enforcement and Related Services is awarded to NSL Ltd for a period of five years with an option to extend for a further two years.

26 January 2012 - Mr Mustard emailed every councillor as follows:

Dear Councillors

I do not think that NSL are going to enhance the reputation of Barnet Council if they display the sort of behaviour that a tribunal has found they did in Westminster.
http://nutsville.com/?p=3791

Of course you will say that this sort of behaviour will not be allowed in Barnet but leopards don't change their spots and Barnet Council has an ignominious record when it comes to the monitoring of contracts.

 

Yours frugally
 

Mr Mustard

to which absolutely no response was received

13 March 2012

Mr Mustard sends in an FOI request to Barnet Council for a copy of the financial viability study of NSL which should have been carried out at an early stage, the Contract with NSL if signed or the expected date of signature and a copy of the Parent Company Guarantee or Performance Bond as the case may be.

17 April 2012

The Mail Online reports on the case of the NSL traffic warden who was sacked, because he says, he exposed the alleged employment of illegal immigrants. The name of the Operational Support Manager who was alleged to be behind this was Adebowale Onadeko. The case goes against the sacked worker who was the whistleblower.


26 April 2012

The FOI response is overdue so Mr Mustard sends a gentle nudge. Silence continues.

I May 2012

The Ham & High reports that there is to be an appeal in the NSL illegal immigrant case as further evidence has come to light.

1 May 2012

NSL start to provide the parking enforcement for Barnet Council. They put all existing back office staff on gardening leave and they are at risk of redundancy. Parking wardens get new uniforms & machinery and carry on patrolling the streets as their job location has not changed.

28 May 2012

Bedfordshire on Sunday reports that a manager of NSL a traffic warden firm, one Adebowale Onadeko has been ordered to carry out 80 hours of unpaid work (is this the new name for community service?) and pay costs of £85 for trying to buy an iPhone with a fake credit card, an event which goes back to October 2011. If you go back to the 17 April entry one can only imagine that this event won't help NSL contest an appeal by a sacked worker whose boss now has a conviction.


31 May 2012

Mr Mustard asks Barnet Council for a review of his FOI request which is 6 weeks late in being answered.

Mr Mustard discovers that Adebowale Onadeko was on the Barnet contract in May 2012 but suddenly there is now a vacancy for his role. The parking staff are very worried that this individual, so capable of fraudulent activity, has their bank details from their personnel files.

What can we learn from this sorry tale?

Well for a start you need to take a good look at your potential supplier and google them to see if they have any skeletons in the cupboard (have we seen them all yet?).

You need to have the backbone to say "stop, let's take another look at what we are doing".

Maybe that when bloggers ask questions you should stop and think about them and not go into a bunker mentality; bloggers want a better borough too, you know.

That if you outsource you do not outsource risk and problems. What you lose is the ability to check the background of staff and to choose the best people for the job yourself.

That giving information, like credit card details, to third party suppliers (like Verrus Pay-by-Phone) means that you cannot control who sees them or where they go to in the world.

That this was the first outsourcing under the One Barnet umbrella and it has got off to a very bad start. What on earth will go wrong when the much larger & multi-faceted DRS contract is passed to third parties and sub-contractors?

One Barnet is not the panacea for all ills.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Let's play 20 questions in Brunswick Park ward today

Today the residents of Brunswick Park have to choose a new councillor. They might find Shaheen Mahmood on their doorstep (if you see a black Mercedes estate rolling up, it could be her). The prospective councillor will want to tell you how fantastic her team have been and what she is going to do for the ward (not much according to leaflets and letters seen by Mr Mustard). She needs to be tested a little. Here are some questions you could ask.

Please can you explain the One Barnet programme to me.

Do you think public parks should be hired out for private events?

Do you think parking meters should be available so that people can pay with cash or a credit card on the spot (especially the old who may not have a mobile phone)?

What do you think of the MetPro scandal?

What do you think of RM Countryside not having had a contract?

What do you think of Barnet Council being fined £70,000 in May 12 for losing data about vulnerable children?

Do you think Brunswick Park library should remain closed or be opened again? 

Which bus do I have to take to get to Tally Ho?

Why did it take 2 years and 4 months to start rebuilding work on the Brunswick Park Health centre ?

Do you think there are too many highly paid officers?

Is Nick Walkley worth £200,000 a year?

Do you think any Pelican crossings in the borough should be removed?

What would you try to change about the way the council is run?

Do you think you should perhaps walk around the ward rather than drive?

Should Lisa Rutter step down as she doesn't live in the ward?

If you want Brunswick Park ward car parks to be free why not all of them across the borough?

Please send any other questions, and answers you receive, to mrmustard@zoho.com or put them in the comments box.

If the answers are not satisfactory then you will want to vote for Andreas Ioannides, the Labour Party candidate. By all means ask him about what he would like to change but until Labour win more seats they can't achieve much.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

30 May 2012

Boris - your letter is pathetic

Now I know you won't have written the letter Boris but you have enough well paid advisers to do better than this effort. Mr Mustard will be charitable and suggest you have never seen the letter and your digital signature goes on it. You need to keep a better eye on your underlings.

sorry the copy is so poor, so is the content!
Mr Mustard will save your tired eyes. Here is what Boris wrote (it has your name on Boris so you will have to take the flak).

Dear .....

I'm writing to ask you to give Shaheen Mahmood your support tomorrow in the Brunswick Park Ward By-Election. Simples.

This election is not about what the Government is doing or whether or not the Council is popular. Some people will always think about what the government does when they decide which candidate to vote for. If you don't want that then you should campaign to get the party name taken off ballot papers. The by-election will most definitely be decided on whether the council are popular or not. It is telling that you put this remark in as you know that they are not popular; you lost Brian Coleman from Barnet remember. If what the majority conservative administration is doing locally in Barnet is not popular then the message has to be sent by rejecting this candidate that policies need to change.

It's about who is going to represent Brunswick Park Ward most effectively over the next 2 years. If Shaheen Mahmood is elected she will be the new girl and will be whipped into shape and a pound to a penny she will stick her hand in the air and vote every One Barnet stupid decision through with the rest of the flock.

I strongly believe that the only person for the job is Shaheen. Natch.

This is not just because Shaheen is a Conservative; it's because she is the only candidate who lives in the ward. Shaheen is a conservative, I am a conservative. This is about the only sensible line in the whole letter. Boris has been mugged into repeating the she lives in the ward so she is the only person for the job. OK, a hypothesis. Suppose the Brunswick Park village idiot (probably horribly un-PC but never mind, have a go in the comments box) were to join the conservative party, stuff envelopes, deliver leaflets etc etc and somehow get the nomination, would they be the only person for the job. Only in the sense that they are the only conservative candidate. They would still be the village idiot. This nonsense about local is automatically best has got to stop.

This means that she is the only candidate who is in the ward day-in day-out and is therefore in the best position to understand and work towards solving the problems faced by her fellow residents. Doubtless Shaheen goes off to do her work for the Muslim Conservative Forum elsewhere. The phone number for her 0207 984 8248 appears to be located at the conservative party HQ in Millbank, London SW1. One would expect Shaheen to spend a lot of time there. Other candidates could live outside of the ward and still visit it for longer than Shaheen. Just because you live elsewhere doesn't mean you can't understand the problems; maybe you are telling us Boris that when you came to the Peel Centre you didn't understand about Barnet's parking problems because you don't live here? no, I thought not.

Shaheen is also a key member of your local Conservative team who have a proven track record of working for the local community. "Is she?" thought Mr Mustard who hadn't heard of her before. What did he do. Well he googled her of course. He put "Shaheen Mahmood Brunswick Park" into google, then he chose UK only and then he chose dates before 31/12/2011 in order to refine the search and find all of Shaheen early marvels in the ward. What did he get? He got 11 results none of which related to anything Shaheen has been doing locally. Note that the team have a proven track record. You aren't being asked to vote for the team but for the person. Call Mr Mustard picky but you can "work for" a result and not achieve it. Very weak endorsement that from Boris.

The team has been instrumental in delivering results for residents on local issues. For example, as you read this letter, work is underway on rebuilding Brunswick Park Ward's Health Centre. It is true that work has just started, see this article in the reliable local paper. So, the health centre burnt down in January 2010 and it is only just being rebuilt now. Hardly a "result". Besides, the council can't have got involved between the insurer and the NHS as they had to standing in the claim. This late rebuilding is nothing to be proud of.

It has also supported the ward's Safer Neighbourhood Team in their drive to crack down on anti-social behaviour and fly-tipping, as well as fighting to keep parking free at the ward's two car parks in Osidge Lane and Brunswick Park Road. Mrs Angry will probably explain about the loss of a number of sergeants from the SNTs in due course. Mr Mustard put a FOI question in about fly-tipping. The answer seems to be outstanding from January. What Mr Mustard does know from elsewhere was that at that stage there had been no prosecutions for fly-tipping since October 2010. Not much of a crack down! Parking, oh Boris you are a wag. The conservative administration put through new parking charges without any objection from their own councillors and then suddenly all hell breaks loose with the public and councillors in nearby East Barnet are suddenly against them. There was a leaflet about parking that had to be withdrawn. Did no-one tell you?

And for the first time in Barnet Council's history, council tax has been frozen for a record fourth year running, while at the same time safeguarding key local services such as weekly bin collections. Barnet Council does not have all that long a history. Freezing council tax is a mistake and only possible because of funding from central government. When the tax does rise it will rocket. Keeping the weekly main bin collection is a mistake. Recycling rates are poor in Barnet. The plan for the future is to have a green waste collection every 2 weeks. Plants grow when the temperature is above 5° so weekly collections are needed in summer and none in winter. The dry goods recycling will be every two weeks and that is the one that needs to be full so ought to be emptied more often to maximise opportunity. There will also be a food waste bin. The streets will be awash with bins. The people who rely on social services wouldn't agree that key local services have been safeguarded. They now have to pay more for less.

So when you go to the polling station tomorrow, I would urge you to vote for Shaheen Mahmood, who I know is just the kind of person Brunswick Park Ward residents need to represent them over the next two years. What positive reasons has Boris managed to give you that stand up to Mr Mustard's scrutiny? Not one. Don't vote for Shaheen, vote for change, vote for:

Andreas Ioannides, the Labour Party candidate.

Yours sincerely

Boris Johnson
Mayor of London


Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

By-election special - Brunswick Park - Thursday 31 May



Well here we go, fresh from ousting Brian Coleman AM from the London Assembly there is another chance for voters to send a message to our local government that we don't like the way that the borough is run at present. The honour falls to the voters of Brunswick Park ward. 

The candidates are:-

Yahaya Dumba Kiingi (Liberal Democrats)

Shaheen Kauser Mahmood (Conservative Party Candidate)

Andreas Ioannidis (The Labour Party Candidate)

Lots has been written already by other bloggers on this subject and you can catch up with their views on the following pages, and others

Barnet Bugle

The Barnet Eye

Citizen Barnet

Mrs Angry of Broken Barnet

Mr Reasonable

Who would Mr Mustard vote for if he lived in Brunswick Park ward? Not the Liberal Democrat candidate as he can't truly expect to win. It's a great shame as the 3 lib dems we have in Childs Hill ward have done sterling service for years and it would be better for them to have a greater say in things.

Not the conservative candidate either. Why not? Well firstly because she has as the headline on her letter to voters of 25 May 12 that she is the only candidate who lives in the ward. If this is such a great thing why is it that Lisa Rutter doesn't live in the ward; does that make her a lesser councillor? Mr Mustard isn't Lisa's biggest fan although she seemed quite good at planting trees, talking to people and cutting ribbons etc. as mayor, but to say in effect that, if elected, one of your existing fellow councillors is less worthy as a councillor is completely wrong.

She also claims not to be a politician. This is so ridiculous. Why are you standing for a political office if you are not a politician? It doesn't sit very easily either with your position as the contact person for the Conservative Muslim Forum which, presumably, has some interest in politics?

Why do you float round the ward in a large black Mercedes estate car when the ward is not very big and you really should be a bit greener and walk like everyone else including Mr Mustard who was delivering BAPS leaflets which tell residents about the One Barnet mass privatisation programme. By walking you would meet more local people and have had the chance to tell them why they should vote for you. ( BAPS = Barnet Alliance for Public Services )

Now what will you get if you vote for Shaheen Mahmood? Mr Mustard has to surmise from what isn't being said. You will get someone who, coming so late to the game, will be unable to do anything to stop the One Barnet mass privatisation even if she wanted to. She would need to read 3 years of council reports, which does not seem very likely, just to get up to speed. You can just see her hand going up with the flock of lambs at meetings of the whole council.

She isn't going to rock the boat and ask for the nearby Friern Barnet library to be re-opened. People on that edge of Brunswick Park ward used the FB library as could any resident of the borough.

If any governor of St Paul's Church of England School in N11 can quietly tip mrmustard@zoho.com the wink about why Shaheen self-disqualified herself from being a governor in about January 2012, or just before, he would be much obliged.

You won't get free bays back in CPZs.

You will get more remote services provided by BT or Capita or some such conglomerate from whichever country they find cheapest to locate the services.

Parking has already been outsourced by the conservative administration. This candidate won't be able to stop that as it is a fait accompli.

You won't see parking meters put back in every location.

You will still see private parks rented out for private parties (how you can put that councillors have listened to residents in your letter of 25 May 2012 to voters is brass neck indeed. The current administration may have listened but it ignored the 99% who said they didn't want private events in public parks).

You will still see allotment rents being steeply increased.
You will see the continued progress of the One Barnet mass privatisation programme for which Mr Mustard has never seen an intelligent report with a properly detailed cost benefit analysis.

You won't see the existing in-house teams being given the chance to bid to run their services.

You will carry on seeing masses of town hall tax dodging consultants on up to £1,000 a day with their noses in the trough which your council tax is wasted filling.

You will get the massive Brent Cross expansion programme. 

Will Barnet FC fans vote for you? not after the way the club has been treated.

The policies which this current conservative administration have embarked upon, and which most of the non-cabinet councillors almost certainly know very little of the detail, are wrecking the borough. 

The only way to make them listen and change it seems is to take every chance to vote them out of office and Labour in.

So please on Thursday vote for:

Andreas Ioannidis 
(The Labour Party Candidate)

If Mr Mustard could vote in this by-election, he would do so tactically ( he is not a member of the Labour party ) and would vote Labour in order to send the message to the conservative councillors

We do not like what you are doing to our borough and we are going to stop you before you ruin it.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Fight the undermanagement epidemic

 
 
From: Murphy, Bill
Sent: 16 May 2012 10:51
To: Local Taxation Group; Housing Benefit - All Staff; Revenues Control Group
Cc: Gregson, John; Burns, Robert; Burgess, John (Unison)
Subject: Update from Revenues and Benefits Project Board
Dear Colleagues,
 
The Revenues & Benefits Transformation Project Board met yesterday and noted the progress on the consultation process and in the preparations for transfers of work and staff to the contact centre and for the new claims pilot. The board approved the changes to staffing agreed following feedback from staff in the consultation process, i.e. to create two specialist team leader posts for Revenues and Benefits in the contact centre, and discussed the process for filling these posts - this will be announced shortly. i.e. despite 10 consultants sitting at the back of Revenues and Benefits faffing about doing who knows what and Bill Murphy himself the town hall tax dodging AD, who could be off on his bike any day, they knew between them less than the staff do and have had to undo the cutting of 2 manager posts. If the council had let the staff make an in-house bid they would have been able to come up with a plan that provided exactly what is required, as they know more about the job than any consultant, and it would almost certainly have been cheaper. If for some bizarre reason it had turned out more expensive there would not have been dissent from the staff if they had been able to join in the game on a level playing field. Unlike Barnet FC it's downhill first half and then downhill second half at NLBP..
 
The forward work plan was reviewed and some changes made to reflect the need to minimise risks to the service. The key milestones are now:
Management workshop to finalise roles and responsibilities 17 May
Transition Team kickoff 23 May
Service Level Agreement between R&B and Contact Centre signed off: 30 May
Team Leaders and Officers confirmed in the new structure: 1 June
Transfers to contact centre: 18 June
Start of new claims pilot: 18 June
Leadership and Culture Change Workshop for new structure 21 June
New claims rollout: Mid-August
The Transition Team will develop its own work programme from late May onwards, with its first priority being knowledge and skills transfer to people in the new structure. In addition, it will pick up projects including Universal Credit pilot, localisation of Council Tax support and Social Fund, as well as dealing with the majority of activities related to the transfer to the NSCSO.
 
Bill Murphy
Assistant Director, Customer Services
 
London Borough of Barnet, North London Business Park, Oakleigh Road South, London N11 1NP
Tel: 020 8359 2142
Mobile 07847 188 983
 
Save this number and if your council tax is being dealt with badly or your benefits are late then ring it. Bill works for you and needs to know when things are going badly wrong. Don't let him fob you off, politely insist that he takes responsibility.
 
Yours frugally
Mr Mustard