Showing posts with label task enforcement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label task enforcement. Show all posts

9 April 2014

Taking TASK to task

a PCN bailiff cannot do this
On 25 March 2014, Mr Mustard received a rather nervous phone call from a disabled man in a bit of a panic, who Mr Mustard will call Mr K. He had the following letter.

So Mr Mustard had a mere 3 days to stop the rot. This was a bit of a challenge. Mr K, being disabled, could not afford to lose his car which he needed to get to work.

On 26 March, Mr Mustard made a house call to Mr K. He looked at the site of the supposed offence and it wasn't correct. Mr K had parked in the same place as he had for years in a residents bay and had properly displayed his blue badge. The bay he was accused of parking in was a joint loading bay - free bay. The former had a single yellow line behind it and the joint bay had a double yellow line behind it. Looking at the council's photographs proved the contravention did not occur thanks to the single yellow line. When told that fact, the challenge, handled by an NSL employee on behalf of the council, was rejected. Amazing, awful, but not unusual, Mr Mustard thinks that Notice Processing Officers have money blindness.

In between the PCN being issue in October 13 and the bailiff letter, Mr K had moved. He had told the council early on although was a little slow updating the V5 (vehicle registration details - Mr Mustard advises you to tell DVLA of your new address for your vehicle and for your driving licence on the day after you move as that will save you loads of grief). The bailiff letter was sent to the old address. That meant that the warrant of execution (sounds pretty serious but not fatal) was invalid as it has to be reapplied for at the new address.

Fees claimed of £457 were excessive as although a visit had been made to the old address there was no point in the bailiff attending again as he was told that Mr K had moved and this could be confirmed by a database check or by asking the council. It was completely impossible even with 3 visits for the total amount due to reach that level. If a bailiff demands money you are entitled to a breakdown and to see the warrant. It is more transparent from now on as bailiff charges are being simplified.

Mr Mustard hastened back to his office and emailed the parking manager. They are on good terms and perfectly civil to each other even when they disagree.

Mr Mustard made the following 4 points:

1. Warrant invalid as to address.
2. Excessive fees demanded.
3. Contravention did not occur.
4. Council don't have a vulnerable individuals policy.

Less than 2 hours later the PCN was history and the matter had been added to the agenda for the next meeting with NSL. Of course, TASK are owned by the NSL group and clearly NSL PCN processing are not properly monitoring the behaviour of their in-house bailiff. NSL should be banned from using their own bailiff on the Barnet contract as there is a clear conflict of interest.

It was lucky for Mr K that he knew Helen Michael of Cafe Buzz (do go there when you are at Tally Ho, Finchley, N12 as the food is really rather good) and that she was able to introduce Mr Mustard to Mr K. Mr Mustard could see the stress that the bailiff's letters were causing and if Mr Mustard didn't have the knowledge that he does, and the ability to cut through the system, Mr K would have paid the £457 before that Friday, 28 March.

Instead he is making a donation to the North London Hospice. He is a peaceable law-abiding citizen who had done no wrong and did not deserve to be treated this way. Mr Mustard has yet to see a bailiff case that has been 100% correctly enforced. He doesn't yet see Barnet Council undertaking their duty of care to ensure that bailiffs follow the rules. They are lucky not to have featured on Panorama, the footage was in the can (but is now on the cutting room floor).

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

4 December 2013

Kicking you when you are down

Bailiffs are like the school bully, however, they can be stood up to.
Mr Mustard has so far seen the effects of four bailiffs in action. Their behaviour has not been pretty. They have a difficult job to do and don't do it very well at all. The bailiff who was in the wrong in clamping a Motability car was rude when unclamping when he should have been polite and apologetic.

Here is an example of a badly written bailiff's letter, bullying and a conflict of interest all in one A4 sheet.

click to enlarge
A badly written letter

Now in this case there were three warrants so the "s" of warrant(s) shouldn't be in parentheses. On the second line there is reference to "warrants" in the plural which would be wrong if there was only one warrant and this letter is evidently used in all circumstances. 

There is reference to client(s). Generally there will only be one client being collected for but it should be clear.

It isn't clear why the date of seizure of the vehicle is put in a larger font size or why a continental date format is used when a short form date format is used at the top of the letter.

The amount outstanding "as of today" cannot include an extra £30 a day. What NSL mean is please add £30 on for each extra day after the date of the letter up to the date of payment.

To prevent further enforcement action you could, in this case, file a form N244 for a personal hearing in front of a District Judge in your local County Court. The exhortation that "you must make a full payment" is to try and bully you into paying without considering your other options.

"Please call in to the call centre" must mean by telephone but Mr Mustard expects that when one of his friends says they will "call in" that he can expect a knock on the door not a phone call. A pity that the number of the call centre is not given. We are expected to guess that the telephone number at the top of the page is the one for the call centre? It is impossible to telephone the call centre at least 24 hours before payment unless you delay paying for 24 hours. The normal process would be that you decide, after a lot of thought, to pay and then you do so almost instantly. Thus you couldn't go back 24 hours to warn NSL / TASK that you are going to pay. In addition, the moment that you have paid you are entitled to the return of your vehicle. Councils that clamp and remove cars to a pound are expected to provide a round the clock service for their release.

Bullying

The reason this letter is a bullying one is that an out-of-time witness statement was filed with the Traffic Enforcement Centre ("TEC" - attached to Northampton County Court) and their decision on 7 November 13 was that the PCN would not be put back to the start of the process so that representations could be made. The Order of the TEC (essentially a Court) gave the applicant the option to file a form N244 for a local Court hearing within 14 days of service of the Order. Therefore nothing should have been done before 22 November 13. This bullying letter is 10 days premature, looks like an abuse of process and is the responsibility of Barnet Council who have a duty of care with regards to the behaviour of their bailiffs as it is the Council who are the creditor. The letter is designed to harass the recipient into paying up. 

If Mr Mustard sees another letter like this one, sent before time, he will start a complaint with the view to it reaching the Local Government Ombudsman.

Conflict of Interest

Barnet Council outsource its parking enforcement to NSL. It isn't clear from this letter who gave the instruction to proceed with enforcement but Mr Mustard has all of his money on NSL. So this means that NSL decided if their own bailiff Task Enforcement should proceed down a route which would lead to the car being auctioned off (it was worth something approaching £3,000 although seized cars somehow don't sell for their true value) and at that point Task (part of NSL) would bank their considerable fees. It simply cannot be right that the company that makes the decision profits from it. We are always being told that NSL don't make more money if they issue more PCN, well they do if the PCN end up for enforcement with the bailiff that they own. The Contract with NSL needs to be changed so that either Barnet Council make decisions affecting the bailiff (if they don't already and Mr Mustard hasn't seen that in the NSL contract) or NSL should be barred from giving warrants to Task.

Conclusion

The more closely Mr Mustard looks at parking enforcement the murkier it seems. Over the festive break he will decide what his plan is for 2014. It will probably include, amongst other things, the introduction of a voluntary charitable contribution for his personal assistance with a PCN appeal (but only for the 97% of cases that he wins) and talks for motorists, such as:
  • How to park and not get a parking ticket
  • The appeal process in outline and some standard arguments
  • Dissecting the evidence pack prior to a PATAS hearing
If you have a group which would like Mr Mustard to educate them (for 20 to 30 minutes) do please get in touch at mrmustard@zoho.com

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

25 September 2013

FOI and outsourcing - a buffer to FOI?

An outsourcing contract acts as a buffer against FOI requests

This post is in response to a tweet about the release of the Capita NSCSO One Barnet Contract which, on the face of it to the outside world, appears to be a good thing. The contract is worth £320m over the 10 years.

Right, for non-Barnet people our council have decided to contract out for 10 years to Capita the following services which they obliquely describe as back office:

Customer Services
Estates (Asset Management, Building Services, Property Services)
Finance
Human Resources
Information Systems
Procurement
Revenues and Benefits

Revenues and benefits is council tax and business rates collection to you and me, not what one would exactly describe as back office. The contract for these services is 2,084 pages in length and has been published in multiple pdfs on the council website, here. A classic case of hiding the detail in full view. Rest assured that the Barnet Bloggers will, between them, read the whole thing. Has any ruling councillor read the whole contract, especially one from the Cabinet who committed us to this deal? probably not. None of the Cabinet admitted to reading it, Mr Mustard did ask them all and the silence was deafening.

Mr Mustard thinks that the reason the council published the final contract was that they were going to get multiple FOI requests for it and it was actually quicker to post it online. Mr Reasonable had asked and goodness knows who else (not Mr Mustard as he is in self imposed FOI exile for now.) He wasn't "banned" (questions automatically found to be vexatious) from asking about One Barnet; only on parking, parking tickets and CPZ's which is now history.

Now let us simplify matters to a contract for Parking Enforcement. That was signed with NSL to start on 1 May 2012 and is worth about £2.5m a year and is for an initial 5 year term. Mr Mustard does admit to being very interested in parking and he helps people pro bono (free of charge) to appeal their parking tickets and currently has a 97% success rate after 65 appeals. The council will either just throw in the towel in future on his cases (as they are a flea bite out of the 165,000 PCN issued a year) or they will put extra resource into fighting him. Currently they throw in the towel when faced with reasoned and logical argument and occasionally they are kind to him and exercise their discretion in favour of old folks who have got a bit befuddled with their blue badge.

There was considerable doubt in the mind of Mr Mustard about the status of bailiffs in the year 2012-13. So the first month was managed entirely by the council (there was a one month delay in getting the parking contract off the ground - pension issues caused by NSL Ltd having another firm to do the scanning). As Mr Mustard couldn't ask any FOI questions about parking he took a different approach. Once a year it is possible to interrogate the Accounts of the council. This right is established by Section 15 of the Audit Commission Act 1988. (ACA1988) Mr Mustard asked to see bailiff contracts for 2012-13 (he was given a 200 page expired contract to look at, he didn't bother). It turned out there wasn't a bailiff contract for 2012-13, Mr Mustard was told there was no bailiff derived income for that year. Putting aside the incompetence of not collecting PCN in a timely manner (and they should be cancelled if left moribund for 6 months at any stage) Mr Mustard was a little surprised. The first month could be understood as it was anticipated that the NSL contract would have started on 1 April 12 but not the other 11 months as the contract with NSL included:

"The Service Provider will engage with a suitable number of bailiff companies to enforce County Court Warrants and comply with the Barnet Code of Practice."

Mr Mustard has not requested the Barnet Code of Practice under FOI. He also notes the interesting word "engage" as opposed to contract, appoint, instruct, etc

Now under the ACA 1988 Mr Mustard, as a resident, is entitled to see any contract that the council takes out. They didn't take out the bailiff contracts, NSL Ltd did. Let us have a look at the contract terms, Mr Mustard has a redacted copy of the contract with NSL (sorry about the white on black, a technical issue)


So from that it seems to be up to the council to decide if something is to be disclosed or not.

Did the council hold the bailiff contracts? (they jolly well should as they have a duty of care in respect of bailiff behaviour but that is a fine theory not usually borne out in practice) Here are minutes of meetings between NSL and Barnet Council managements (these were easily obtained by another party and given to Mr Mustard as his questions were, at the relevant time, too vexatious to be answered).

On 5 October 12 the minutes show the following:

Redacted requested copies of SLA and contract made with bailiffs.

Now the minutes only make sense if the redacted initials are those of a Barnet Council employee as it was NSL who signed the contract so they will have a copy. (SLA is Service Level Agreement, by the way). Now, if the SLA and contract had been supplied to Barnet Council then Mr Mustard thinks they are disclosable under FOI.

The plot thickens. Someone else asked for the bailiff contracts, the response was given the reference 293065 but doesn't appear in the published list of FOI responses. Does that make you think that the responses published on the council website are selective? Luckily Mr Mustard has the response, as follows:


I am writing to inform you that we have searched our records and the information you requested is not held by London Borough of Barnet.

  1. These 3rd party sub contracts are held on the council's behalf. They are contracts between the contractors and the 3rd parties and the council has no proprietary rights in them.
  2. There is no statutory obligation on the council to hold copies of these 3rd party sub contracts.

So, copies were requested in October 12 but hadn't been received by July 13 and the parking client side, who are paid to oversee parking enforcement are either utterly hopeless at following up action points in the minutes, or bailiff contracts don't actually exist, or the FOI response is bunkum. The lack of clarity has led Mr Mustard to object to the signing off of Barnet Council's Accounts for the year. The response is due in about 10 days.

Mr Mustard thinks that by now @bainesy1969 might be reviewing his opinion of Barnet Council, we'll see. He'll either tell us in the comment box or email mrmustard@zoho.com to have his view added to this post.

So to get back to the question in hand for all the FOI experts who read this. If NSL take out the contract on behalf of Barnet council but don't give them a copy, is it subject to disclosure under FOI? Mr Mustard thinks not. One possible lever is that only a creditor can instruct a bailiff so Barnet Council can instruct the bailiff and NSL can't (let us avoid, for now, the red herring that NSL also own a bailiff company called Task Enforcement Ltd and have used them to chase unpaid PCN for Barnet Council as that is a conflict of interest blog for another day) so any contract that NSL sign is as agent for Barnet Council and not as the principal? Mr Mustard isn't a lawyer but wonders if that changes the position in terms of the document being subject to FOI?

NSL Ltd aren't subject to FOI as a contractor. This removes any contract they sign on their own behalf but for the benefit of the council out of public scrutiny and on NSCSO that is potentially £320m of contracts we can't see. Doesn't look so open and transparent now does it?

If you think you can get current bailiff contracts please ask for them (foi@barnet.gov.uk). Don't tell Mr Mustard you have done so and it isn't on his behalf. We don't want you accused of being in concert with him.

Now @FOIkid, tell Mr Mustard, is there a solution or should FOI be extended to apply to all contracts funded by the public purse?

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Comment; So it looks like the council got it wrong. It will be up to the original requestor to ask for the review. It also occurs to Mr Mustard that he can go back to the council and suggest that they should have released the bailiff contracts under ACA 1988 on the same grounds that they are held on behalf of the council.