Showing posts with label piss poor performance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label piss poor performance. Show all posts

23 January 2014

Saracens - left hand - right hand - drop the ball

So here is a tweet that the council have just put out:
So Mr Mustard did look at the CPZ page, and here it is:


Has this 25 January fixture been added to the Event Day schedule on the website recently? Probably, if the council are only just tweeting about it. Mr Mustard has found that it was announced back on 9 December, here. Mr Mustard then went to the google cache and found the previous page which was crawled by the googlebot on 16 January. Here it is and it proves that the page change is a recent one:

Then Mr Mustard looked out the fixture list that was distributed by Saracens themselves early on in the season, the front sheet of which was headed

"AVOID GETTING PARKING TICKETS ON MATCH DAYS"

and here it is:

So look at those three lots of information in reverse order to get them in ascending date order.

To start with Saracens say there will be a match this Sunday.
Then Barnet Council somehow put down a match for this Saturday but not Sunday.
Then finally, with only 2 days to go, Barnet Council manage to get both matches onto their website, which no motorist is obliged to look at before they enter the zone. Parking compliantly based upon officially published information on which it ought to be possible to place some reliance, you simply can't.

What should the council do this weekend? They should decide to not issue a single ticket in the Event Day zone as profiting from its own incompetence is most unattractive.

What is the extra Saturday match anyway? It is a friendly against The Sharks (a team from South Africa and not from anywhere near Sale as Mr Mustard wrote previously). Will the crowd be that large that it should count as an Event day? Possibly not. (Mr Mustard got half of this entire blog wrong, the crowd is at least 9,000)

Everyone who gets a PCN in the Saracens ED event day CPZ zone should appeal three times. See the guide to appealing at the top left. The reason for the appeal is that the council have not made you properly aware that it is an Event Day. Simply repeat that appeal all the way to PATAS & you will probably win. Every PATAS appeal costs the council £40, they hate paying those fees. Make their pocket hurt.

Come on Barnet Council. Behave with honour and dignity.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard


Update, Thursday 4pm

Just to show you how little Mr Mustard knows about rugby he has been told that 9,000 tickets have been sold for the friendly fixture. There are only 300 parking spaces at the ground which isn't exactly well served by public transport. Enforcement therefore has to take place as residents complain about bad parking and about getting parking tickets when they shouldn't be there (different residents obviously). The numbers of PCN being issued are apparently slowing, going down from about 500 a day at the peak to under 200 now. Of course if you are one of the chosen 200 it isn't funny. More PCN are being cancelled if appealed (so appeal!) and you probably have a better chance if you live within the zone and then apply for a free permit. The whole size of the zone is again under question as the traffic wardens are wearing their shoe leather out covering it. Some dot matrix signs of a more reasonable price have been identified and they will get used the rest of the year for other purposes, road closures, special events in town centres that sort of thing.

It seem to take forever sometimes but changes are coming apparently. As part of Mr Mustard's deal with the COO to get a reasonable number of FOI questions answered (although he hasn't asked any for months) he agreed to write a bit of good news as well as bad, so when these changes arrive you will read it on this blog.


10 September 2012

"Performance" reports of Chief Exec

We haven't had any performance, or lack of, reports for a while so here we are, two at once, for the 6 months from October 2011 to March 12. The latest quarter has been changed and should be on the website soon. Considering that over £700,000 was spent on the new website and that over 100 people have been trained in the CMS software, it is disappointingly slow in being updated.

Performance report of Chief Executive of Barnet Council for Q3 2011/12

Do you think this is an achievement? "We gave away £200,000?". If that is one of non-stick Nick's top three achievements the bar is not set very high.

Yet more transformation managers being appointed:

The Contact Centre Transformation Manager - Iain Hamilton -  all the way from Cheshire.
Head of Customer Services Transformation manager - Andrew Cox - a rare appointment of an interim who has come from inside the council.
Libraries - interim project manager - Heather Wills - who had her own bog post last week.

The Chief Executive's service is unable to manage the simplest task. They can only manage to pick up the phone within 20 seconds 62.3% of the time. What putrid service.

Channel shift is being pushed faster than people want to go. Of course more payments are being done on-line as opportunities to pay by any other method get removed.

Benchmarking is still utter rubbish. The marks chosen are not challenging ones at the top of the range which is what they are meant to be. It is of no help to know that Bolsover DC are marginally more cr*p than Barnet Council at answering the phone.

Adult Social Services were unable to find temporary recruits for 2 posts. Perhaps word has spread about what a joy it is to work for Barnet Council.

The final sentence of page 5 is very worrying. E-mail is the most useful form of communication for many people and Barnet Council are going to try and straightjacket us into webforms where the subject about which you want to write has to be presented in a certain format and you don't automatically get a copy, you are reliant on the council to send you one afterwards if they choose to. This has already happened with parking ticket appeals where your choices are a letter (snailmail) or a webform. Not email which is an utter disgrace. Anyone would think that the council don't want to make it easy to appeal.

Performance report for Chief Executive of Barnet Council Q4 2011/12

Well done to Friern Barnet library campaigners. You are one of the top 3 issues (issues = problems). Keep on going. The council will crack in the end.

Brian Coleman has been complaining in his blog (you will have to find the rotten thing yourself, it is too turgid for words) about spelling mistakes in the local papers. Well Brian, take a look at the top of page 2 

"4 where on target" that should have been "4 were on target" and then further down

"predominantly by with our face to face service".

Also, the triangles which indicate the DoT, Direction of Travel, have turned into empty rectangles. There is a lack of attention to detail at the council and no-one cares.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

22 May 2012

Mr Mustard likes a good dinner


although he is not quite as gluttonous as Mr Creosote.

How much do you have to pay for a good dinner? Well, one of Mr Mustard's favourite local restaurants is Chez Tonton which has been serving fine French food in Barnet since the late 80s.

don't let the unassuming building put you off. It's the chef that matters.
If you visit mid-week you get the benefit of the fixed price menu which is a bargain £17.95 for 3 courses. Mr Mustard always skips the garlic bread which is offered whilst you choose your dishes as otherwise he finds he doesn't have room for coffee and a wafer thin mint at the end of the meal (glass of port more likely - Ed). Even with a gin and tonic to kick off, a bottle of wine each and a glass of port to finish you will struggle to pass the £50 a head marker. That is as good a dinner as you need of an evening.

Now what does give Mr Mustard indigestion is an average meal at an elevated price. Meals in Park Lane hotels come into this category. As it happens Mr Mustard was one of the team that helped to sort out a Park Lane hotel which the bank foreclosed on. He didn't know until then that rather than there being a whole battery of chefs in the kitchen cooking fresh food for you, the dinner is often bought in with maybe just the pre-prepared vegetables being cooked from raw on-site. Your starter, main and dessert may all come from different suppliers of pre-prepared food. You might as well get a ready meal from Waitrose. Not only that but you pay £120 a head for the privilege. OK that includes a glass or two of champagne in a reception ( a quarter of a bottle which probably cost the hotel £13 or less ) and some wine with the meal but you always end up buying more wine at inflated prices.

Mr Mustard gets double indigestion when Barnet Homes decide to reserve a table for 10 at a total cost of £1,200. Here is what Barnet Homes have told him.

The question:

How many staff (including Board Directors) of Barnet Homes are going to the Housing Awards 2012 at the Hilton Hotel, Park Lane on 27 June 2012?
Who is paying for their tickets and how much do they cost?
Has any hotel accommodation been booked for any of them and if so how many and at what cost?

The answer:

We have arranged a table of 10 to attend the housing awards at a cost of £1,200 (this includes wine and dinner for all 10 guests). This is to recognise that we have been successfully shortlisted in the ‘ALMO of the year category’.

Attending will be:

2 members of Barnet Homes Executive Team
3 Board members
2 London Borough of Barnet senior staff
The Mayor and Mayoress of Barnet (fair enough, it's the job of the mayor to eat for the borough - a gym membership should be included in the mayor's perks )
1 resident (no problem with a resident going)

No accommodation has been booked; all guests will be making their own way to the awards ceremony, (how they get home wasn't mentioned, crawling, naked or otherwise, up the Edgware Road probably, except for the Mayor & Mayoress who will travel home regally in the mayoral limo - do please go round Brian)

Do you think that it's bloody marvellous that Barnet Homes were shortlisted for an award? (they have not won anything yet mind). How did they get to be nominated in the first place? Well, the usual thing seems to be that you nominate yourself. "I would like a good night out in the West End paid for by the public and we do manage a few homes so please enter us in the ALMO category" or words to that effect.

These awards are just a money making machine. They don't exist because the magazine has any particular legal right to dole out awards. They are so that they tie people to their magazines and make everyone feel good about them. Last year 700 people attended the awards and so Inside Housing grossed £84,000 (at this year's prices) from ticket sales alone. These are not their only wards. they also sell sponsorship of the event, sponsors are usually firms who want to gain more business or at least to keep their name in the frame and they get the chance to rub shoulders with 700 possible customers.

Who takes a table. Well the 6 shortlisted companies do because as sure as eggs is eggs if they don't take a table they almost certainly won't win an award. Let us suppose that there are 6 short-listed entrants for each category. Each of them uses this as a justification to take a table. So that is £7,200 in the bank for the organiser. Who owns Inside Housing? It is Ocean Media Group. They are not some philanthropic organisation who are dedicated to making social housing better but a commercial company (nothing wrong with that) who just want to make money. They do it by printing magazines and organising conferences. Take a look at their website.

Look at what else they also publish. Back Street Heroes magazine. Mr Mustard has come across this magazine before as he will read most things about 2 wheels.

Is an award for housing from a company which promotes custom motorcycles really worth much? It is a vanity award in Mr Mustard's opinion. You are only offered an award, a moment in the spotlight, so that you take a table at The Hilton Park Lane and boost the profits of Ocean.

What we don't know is how many of the 60 ALMO's that exist entered the ALMO of the year section. Maybe it was only 6 and so they all got short-listed? Maybe the best ALMO is modest and doesn't put itself forward for awards? Maybe the winner is simply the one chosen out of the only 6 who put themselves forward and agreed to take a table at the Hilton as after all it wouldn't be much of a night if none of the winners in any of the 14 categories were present.

Mr Mustard's question is - does this award make Barnet Homes a better ALMO? No, of course it doesn't. It makes them into an ALMO with £1,200 less in the bank and 7 staff who will probably be a bit shabby on the morning after the awards and not working at full effectiveness.
 
Have Barnet Homes got money spare that they can spend on drinking and dining at public expense? 

This is part of what Chief Executive Tracey Lees said when taking about the short-listing 

"our vision of great service at great value" £120 for dinner is not great value.

Mr Mustard's vision of great value is that staff earning over £58,200 p.a., as 7 of the people attending the dinner do, should buy their own dinners and drinks. Please each pay £120 into the pot which can be used for any maintenance backlog.

Listen up Barnet Homes and Barnet Council. Stop entering vanity awards and save us all from this waste.

Buy your own drinks in future.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

p.s. Mr Mustard has just been googling Barnet Homes and finds that they were shortlisted in the GO Awards for 2012/13 in the section of GO Best Customer Engagement Initiative of the Year Award, ( link here ). The GO awards celebrate "Excellence in Public Procurement". Mr Mustard recently found out that Barnet Homes have been using the same design company for years, and have paid them ( Dogstar Design ) over £163,000 without a written contract being in place so procurement is evidently not an area of expertise for Barnet Homes.

Barnet Homes and Barnet Council would have to fight it out for the Private Eye Piss Poor Procurement Award. You haven't got a clue about how bad you are.

21 February 2012

Standard & poor

A shovel is employed behind this animal before every council meeting

Last night was a meeting of the Cabinet, the inner cabal which basically wields all of the power within the council (or gives it to officers to wield). There is an uncomfortable 30 minutes at the start of the meeting where residents get the chance to ask questions and the cabinet take the chance to largely avoid them. If they do answer them they often get jeered as the video on Roger's Barnet Eye website shows.

The trick, which Mr Mustard is going to keep working on, is to work out your second question, as you are allowed a supplementary, before you submit the first one. You have to confine your questions to the business within the paperwork produced for the meeting. Mr Mustard's first submitted question was ruled out of order. Here it is.

1 Given that the tax treatment of Ed Lester, the boss of the Student Loans Company is now that of a PAYE employee are there any plans to review the tax status of employees at Barnet Council who hold staff positions such as Chief Finance Officer and Head of Human Resources ( to name but two example staff positions )and put them on a proper tax basis i.e. PAYE, or has that already happened?

As Uncle Eric  Pickles entered into the fray just after that question and squashed the idea of Town Hall tax dodging Mr Mustard decided not to resubmit the question with some amendment which would have made it fit the bill as instead Mr Mustard is keeping an eye on the tax affairs of officers.

The first question on the agenda was Mr Mustard's:

Question 1
Could you please tell me what the "people and culture workstream of the One Barnet programme" actually means? (see paragraph 4.6 on page 8 of Business Planning ) 
Response
This is a monthly meeting to engage with the Trade Unions in relation to the One Barnet Programme which generates actions and solutions. The purpose of the meeting is to; discuss employee engagement, managing change and what actions/solutions are required, receive an update on all the One Barnet Projects, and a forum for the Trade Unions to seek clarification and ask questions.

Interpretation
If a decision is made to move jobs to Croydon the union can complain all it likes but the jobs are still going there. Thus Mr Mustard did not ask a supplementary to that question.

There were lots of questions on the agenda and other residents were doing a good job of spearing Robert Rams about the Friern Barnet library so Mr Mustard was happy to keep out of the way and not ask a supplementary. So his next question was simply left on the record. Here it is.

27. Does the budget assumption in relation to pay increases also apply to payments for personnel provided to the Council under “contracts for services” in the same way as it will apply for those directly employed by the Council”?
Response
The budget assumption in relation to potential pay increases is a contingency as discussions, at a national level, in relation to pay for lower paid staff are still ongoing. Personnel provided to the Council under ‘contracts for services’ are not covered by the national pay bargaining framework.

Interpretation
We don't want residents to tie our hands about how we pay staff and we will try to give some of them pay rises to make up for the loss of tax saving that they are now going to suffer. (Mr Mustard will be doing a salary to fees comparison later)

By the time the question rota came around again for the third time Mr Mustard did have a supplementary.

Question 28
The Leader's foreword has a target ( success measure no. 7 ) for answering the telephone of 75% of calls answered within 20 seconds. Is this target not ridiculously & pathetically low for either the council and/or a supposedly expert future outsourcing provider to achieve and shouldn't the target be above 90%?

Response
The figure of 75% of calls in 20 seconds is a reasonably accepted standard for call answering – as it relates to about 5 rings of the phone. By way of comparison, 80% within 20 seconds is the industry standard for contact centres across the whole industry (not specifically within local government) and this is the level we will specify for the our NSCSO provider to deliver.
 
90% is a level that is generally set for emergency services, and is not the norm for customer service call centres, as it requires a level of ' slack' within the environment to assure the increased level of service, and is therefore not the most economic approach.
 
Another reason it is not normally set higher is that, for each service, there will be a daily and weekly pattern of calls from the public. For example – Monday morning is busiest – with call volumes dropping off later in day and later in the week. There will also be peaks of call in response to specific events (e.g. school admissions, council tax bills). So while a well run call centre would exceed this target for much of the week – it is generally not economic to resource to a level where it can be achieved all the time. Therefore the 75% is an average to be achieved over the course of the week. Private sector contact centres will often deploy more flexible staffing arrangements to better match staff numbers to actual demand.
 
However, feedback on this matter tells us that what really matters to customers is less the waiting time, but the extent to which their problem is solved.
 
If you increase the percentage target for call answering, you run the risk of providing the wrong incentives – e.g. the call centre operator tries to close the call as quickly as possible – rather than fully address the customer issue – or the over-use of automated systems (e.g. press 1 for …) to meet the target. Both of which we know customers don’t like.

It is ultimately a balance between service quality and affordability.

For the outsourced provider we will monitor a basket of indicators (of which this measure is only one) so that we can have a good handle on our customers' overall experience. E.g. how many calls don’t get answered at all, the length of the longest wait, and % of calls where the issue is resolved at the first point of contact.

Mr Mustard read that load of flannel and then asked his supplementary question expecting the answer to be some official body or quango or association of call centre operators.

Supplementary.
Whose standard is the "Reasonably accepted standard" 
It is hard when you are sitting there to take it all in but the leader waffled on again about something and didn't answer the actual question so Mr Mustard simply repeated it again. The answer was shocking. The reasonably accepted standard was that of the leader and the cabinet.

So it isn't an industry standard. 

It is a standard that the complacent leader has decided is good enough for the residents of Barnet. It isn't.

Mr Mustard thinks that rather than getting a Standard & Poors type rating of AAA or similar you qualify for the Private Eye rating of PP

piss-poor

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard