Showing posts with label goods bay. Show all posts
Showing posts with label goods bay. Show all posts

29 June 2026

The no good goods bay

Mr D delivers goods for his employer using his own vehicle (he might have stopped now as it exposes him to PCNs which is unfair if the employer won't pick up the tab). He made a delivery in Church Rd, NW4 (Hendon central). Here is the location.


 Here is the sign

Mr D was not in a goods vehicle but that isn't a problem as there is an error in the wording of the relevant Barnet traffic order. The sign must match the traffic order so Mr Mustard took a look (it is available online here)


 

Mr Mustard was surprised and amused, there aren't usually such blunders to give him a get out of jail free card. The area where the white van was parked, where Mr D also parked his car, is defined as a Pay by Phone bay, it isn't a bay for goods vehicles to load or unload. Thus any PCN for being in a goods vehicle loading bay without loading or for not being in a goods vehicle is a dead duck.

Mr D made his own informal challenge. He supplied proof of loading but was rejected as he wasn't in a goods vehicle.

Having spotted the error Mr Mustard sent the details to the council but they don't like anyone writing back to them after they have rejected an informal challenge and in response to Mr Mustard pointing out the error in the traffic order Barnet Council rather stupidly said the PCN was issued correctly. Mr Mustard didn't mind as he knew he would win in the end.

Mr Mustard made the formal representation once the Notice to Owner arrived. The meat of his representation was:

The council's traffic order does not create a goods vehicle loading bay at the location in question, outside 77-79 Church Road, NW4. It creates a pay bay numbered 9323. The council's PCN is therefore unlawful as is the erection of the sign.

This time someone realised Mr Mustard had fired his arrow into the bullseye and the PCN was cancelled.


The heading is wrong, it should say 'Alleged contravention' until such time as an Adjudicator decides it is a contravention in law. Nice, an apology although Mr Mustard would much prefer the council spells out what they did wrong. The council then ruin it by saying the decision doesn't set a precedent when of course it does, if the rules and the sign were wrong the same cancellation should happen every time.

There haven't been many PCNs at this location but if you had one then ask the council for your money back.

Mr Mustard has just checked the traffic order. It does not seem to have been corrected yet.

The end. 

26 September 2018

Yeah but no but yeah

Not 100% certain this was the bay but the sign fits the decision
Mr Mustard keeps an eye on the decisions made each day by parking adjudicators. In the next decision the council ticketed a goods vehicle for being in a goods vehicle loading bay and then when the motorist points out that his was a goods vehicle the council change their argument, which never plays well with an adjudicator, being a slippery eel.

Not all adjudicators will cancel a PCN for the lack of adequate description reason, many will say that in combination with the sign, you know what you did. If the vehicle owner isn't the driver though and wasn't there it would not be obvious. The public is entitled to be told exactly why a penalty is due, you shouldn't have to guess.

The adjudicator slays the second argument about not being engaged in loading as that is not the allegation on the PCN so the council, in their desperation to extract £110 from the innocent Mr Joyce, blathered on about an irrelevance. Mr Mustard thinks the quality of correspondence has gone downhill since NSL moved the back office to Dingwall because it is cheaper, naturally, but cheap ain't often also good.

Rare though it is to see costs awarded Mr Joyce clearly felt he had been badly done by and applied for costs.

If a council don't oppose an application for costs it is more likely to be granted, it being assumed that the council has no objection whatsoever.

It doesn't matter if the council don't see you unloading. They rarely observe for even 5 minutes and so if the traffic warden is only there for one minute, they aren't likely to see much happening.

Barnet Council were adjudged to have been 'wholly unreasonable' - nothing new there then.

What Mr Joyce should have claimed for was the costs of preparing his Appeal i.e. from the moment he received the Notice of Rejection and his travel time in attending the hearing, at the litigant in person rate of £19 per hour.

Barnet Council are lucky to have got off with wasting £35.

Remember, just because the council state that the traffic warden didn't see something happening doesn't mean that it wasn't happening. If Lady Godiva had ridden down the street whilst the traffic warden was intent on his handheld equipment and didn't see her ride by, it doesn't mean she wasn't in East Finchley that day (although it is an unlikely event) only that the traffic warden didn't see her. The same goes for loading, please please do it properly dressed.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

23 March 2015

Does the Chief Executive decide & if not, who does?

When a PATAS adjudicator makes a recommendation to a council to cancel a PCN for a reason not to do with the application of the law (as other the adjudicator could cancel) the suggestion is meant to go to the office of the Chief Executive. Mr Mustard wonders if, given the love of outsourcing currently on display, the paperwork gets anywhere near the building, let alone to his desk.

Here is one recent such case;

1)      Mr. H attended the Tribunal to present his appeal. 
2)    The evidence clearly established that Mr. H had parked in a bay reserved for the loading of goods from goods vehicles. Mr. H was driving a car that was plainly not a goods vehicle.
3)    Despite the fact that the contravention is made out, I find that there are compelling reasons to recommend that the enforcement authority cancels the PCN.
4)    I was satisfied that although Mr. H was not using a goods vehicle, he was loading and unloading goods from a Hospice Shop. He had misunderstood the signage. The contravention was unintentional.
5)    Mr. H is in his late 70's and is proud of his previously unblemished driving record, never previously having had a parking contravention. He is unwell, and of limited means. He is in receipt of income support. He would find the penalty a very significant commitment.
6)    Given his personal mitigation and the unintentional contravention, I recommend that Barnet Council cancel this PCN. I also remind the enforcement authority that they also have power to pursue the mitigated penalty, even at this late stage of enforcement. (The adjudicator means the 50%)

What was the council's decision. To reject the recommendation. Not the way to treat charitable folk, now is it?

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard