29 August 2022

(Dog) collared after 3 years in Southwark

 
 


 
 


Mr Mustard often looks at cases where the adjudicator's decision is to refuse the Appeal but suggest (recommend) to the council that they cancel the PCN (or not collect the sum due under it).

As soon as the first PCN was issued the Reverend, or his wife, should have woken up and put the blue badge in the car and stopped the rot. It is unlikely that the blue badge would have been stolen in the short time it would have taken to obtain a new AD permit on line.

Shocking really, no PCN for three years and then three in a fortnight. Doubtless the council didn't follow up with residents who hadn't transferred from a paper permit to a virtual one. Mr Mustard's experience in Barnet is that they leave you to find out each time the system changes, rather than proactively helping the public.

Southwark should really have proved that they made the Reverend aware of the new system at the time and, given that this bay was installed especially for Mrs Lucas, not treated it as a profit centre but public service went west a long time ago in parking departments.

End.

28 August 2022

At cross purposes

Mr Mustard thinks the East of England Ambulance Service had good cause to be cross. Luckily for them the Adjudicator cut through the nonsense that had been written to them. This bus lane rakes in £1,000,000 a year as what the cctv doesn't show is that the bus lane ends about a centimetre after what the camera shows and it doesn't show the upcoming roundabout where lots of people want to turn left and slightly cut the corner of the bus lane, an entirely innocent and safe action without gaining an advantage in so doing.

Lovely to see a representative who has read bus lane law especially as it is different in London than in the east of England.

Bus Lane Act means the Act mentioned in the line above.

Waltham Forest Council were simply telling porkie pies when they said the vehicle must be attending an emergency and Mr Mustard has never heard of form 4728 because its existence is not within the legislation. The Act is clear, it says this:

So why do Waltham Forest council claim otherwise, many ambulance services would give up and pay if the council says no as they are rushed off their feet and have better things to spend their time on.

It couldn't be the desperation for revenue could it?

If you have a PCN in this bus lane, or any other in London, do email mrmustard@zoho.com as another expert has found a (so far) killer argument.

End.

16 August 2022

Location, location, location.

This is a PCN case which Mr Mustard won late last year but has only just got around to reporting it.

Here is the PCN


 Here is the car, the black one, the first in view.


 Here is a better view of the road sign


Whilst City Road is just around the corner the PCN has to be accurate as to date and time, place, alleged contravention. The colour of the car would not matter if wrong and TfL don't bother stating it.

In this case as soon as the error in the location was pointed out TfL cancelled, the car was clearly in City Garden Row. They only get one bite of the cherry the same as you do to park in compliance.

End.

1 August 2022

How to waste time as a local government officer

 

Copyright: https://www.flickr.com/photos/timcaynes/148110505

Another expert, amazed that a council would issue itself with a Penalty Charge Notice and then fight it all the way to the tribunal, listed all the steps that were taken in that case. What a stupendous waste of everyone's time, moving money from one section of the council budget to another.

You can't quite believe that councils would fight each other in this way, proof by way of just three of quite a few examples follows. Now you know why they are so mean to you, it is inbuilt, they are beastly to themselves.

Emergency trip to an elderly faller; go the long way round or pay a penalty. Miserable and stupid, the adjudicator put an end to that.

Pragmatic and fast disposal of this Appeal.

 

Mr Mustard would rewrite this one as 'get out of my tribunal as I have real PCNs to decide upon'.



 End.

22 July 2022

Merton - malicious multiples

Sometimes a set of decisions in the public register of PCN Appeal decisions catches Mr Mustard's eye and this is one such case 


There are 11 PCNs in play worth a total of £1,430 although as Merton Council have accepted £65 for the one PCN which they did win and they would have settled for £715 even if they won the lot. Merton Council had to shell out about £300 in fees for the tribunal. School streets are big money earners as only 1% of motorists will go as far as the tribunal, most people will meekly pay up.

This is the location plan:


The 'flying motorbike' sign in one which no-one seems to know although given how much money they have now generated all over London Mr Mustard suspects the sign is much better known now than it used to be.

It is easy to avoid this school street, you can drive around 3 sides of a square although Mr Mustard suspects that most of the people caught were driving their kids to school or else delivery drivers.

Firstly, was it really necessary for Merton Council to issue and pursue all 11 PCNs to the bitter end (although the ending was sweet for the motorist). What are they trying to achieve? In theory the council want compliance to make the street quieter. In practice they look like they are revenue raising.

Secondly, what is interesting is that Merton Council rejected representations which hadn't been made. That is arguable depending on the wording of what was said, reference having been made to further anticipated PCNs. Had Merton Council not rejected the representations as if made against each and every PCN, which were clearly disputed, Merton Council could after 28 days have put them all up from £130 to £195. This was a tricky situation.

Thirdly, it is noted that the school run is now done on foot so the motorist has only paid one penalty at 50% which is fair enough, the council have their wish for more active travel and the distance which was being driven probably wasn't that high as it is now being walked. This is a win/win apart from for council tax payers but they are winning overall. Money doesn't have to come into this. A council could agree to waive all the PCNs in return for the motorist agreeing to not drive to school in future. Carrot rather than stick.

There were two other multiple PCN cases at this location Mr Mustard found when he searched. Mr Obeng was renting out a vehicle but his paperwork didn't meet the requirements for the transfer of liability. Nothing stops him from demanding payment from the hirer.

The other case was a Mr Nowakowski.



The failure to spot the signs seven times counted against the driver (he handled 14 similar PCNs for a person once who had turned right where they shouldn't - were they looking or were they asleep at the wheel on their commute? - they blamed Waze but they were driving!).


A different adjudicator on a different day with a different motorist might have made an entirely different decision. If an Adjudicator finds, as a fact, that a contravention occurred they must refuse the Appeal. They cannot, for a moving traffic case, even make a recommendation that the overall penalty be lowered. Mr Nowakowski isn't without fault (officially) but is paying out £455 a proportionate penalty when compared to fines imposed in the Magistrates' Courts for other wrongs - if you know, please tell us in the comments section.

End.



Covid might be a defence to a PCN but you have to prove your case

 Here is a recent adjudication decision about a parking PCN.


Had further evidence been supplied this Appeal might have been won. You generally only get the one chance to argue your corner (although you can add additional evidence up to the date of the hearing and sometimes even at the hearing itself) the general rule is that if you are claiming an exemption you, the motorist, must prove your case. Don't say that someone else can provide something as the tribunal's job isn't to get your evidence together for you, if you want to win, put in the best paperwork you can find.

End.

19 July 2022

Merton Council - pay to park for free!

Graham had business in Merton and one condition of his contract with the customer was the provision of visitor vouchers but on this day that deal failed.

A PCN was issued for code 12, being in a residents bay without a permit or voucher.


The informal rejection was written by someone who doesn't live in the real world.


Mr Mustard wasn't concerned, he told Graham to sit and wait for the Notice to Owner. The 50% discount didn't matter as he was after 100% off. Once the Notice arrived a more comprehensive representation was made.




The response was also longer.



Longer wasn't better in this case. The Grounds of Appeal set out the stall in detail.



Once an Appeal was made to an independent adjudicator, a lawyer, whose knowledge of parking law is vast, Merton Council could finally see the writing on the wall and they filed a Do Not Contest form and cancelled the PCN.

Take no nonsense is Mr Mustard's advice.

End.