22 May 2012

Mr Mustard likes a good dinner


although he is not quite as gluttonous as Mr Creosote.

How much do you have to pay for a good dinner? Well, one of Mr Mustard's favourite local restaurants is Chez Tonton which has been serving fine French food in Barnet since the late 80s.

don't let the unassuming building put you off. It's the chef that matters.
If you visit mid-week you get the benefit of the fixed price menu which is a bargain £17.95 for 3 courses. Mr Mustard always skips the garlic bread which is offered whilst you choose your dishes as otherwise he finds he doesn't have room for coffee and a wafer thin mint at the end of the meal (glass of port more likely - Ed). Even with a gin and tonic to kick off, a bottle of wine each and a glass of port to finish you will struggle to pass the £50 a head marker. That is as good a dinner as you need of an evening.

Now what does give Mr Mustard indigestion is an average meal at an elevated price. Meals in Park Lane hotels come into this category. As it happens Mr Mustard was one of the team that helped to sort out a Park Lane hotel which the bank foreclosed on. He didn't know until then that rather than there being a whole battery of chefs in the kitchen cooking fresh food for you, the dinner is often bought in with maybe just the pre-prepared vegetables being cooked from raw on-site. Your starter, main and dessert may all come from different suppliers of pre-prepared food. You might as well get a ready meal from Waitrose. Not only that but you pay £120 a head for the privilege. OK that includes a glass or two of champagne in a reception ( a quarter of a bottle which probably cost the hotel £13 or less ) and some wine with the meal but you always end up buying more wine at inflated prices.

Mr Mustard gets double indigestion when Barnet Homes decide to reserve a table for 10 at a total cost of £1,200. Here is what Barnet Homes have told him.

The question:

How many staff (including Board Directors) of Barnet Homes are going to the Housing Awards 2012 at the Hilton Hotel, Park Lane on 27 June 2012?
Who is paying for their tickets and how much do they cost?
Has any hotel accommodation been booked for any of them and if so how many and at what cost?

The answer:

We have arranged a table of 10 to attend the housing awards at a cost of £1,200 (this includes wine and dinner for all 10 guests). This is to recognise that we have been successfully shortlisted in the ‘ALMO of the year category’.

Attending will be:

2 members of Barnet Homes Executive Team
3 Board members
2 London Borough of Barnet senior staff
The Mayor and Mayoress of Barnet (fair enough, it's the job of the mayor to eat for the borough - a gym membership should be included in the mayor's perks )
1 resident (no problem with a resident going)

No accommodation has been booked; all guests will be making their own way to the awards ceremony, (how they get home wasn't mentioned, crawling, naked or otherwise, up the Edgware Road probably, except for the Mayor & Mayoress who will travel home regally in the mayoral limo - do please go round Brian)

Do you think that it's bloody marvellous that Barnet Homes were shortlisted for an award? (they have not won anything yet mind). How did they get to be nominated in the first place? Well, the usual thing seems to be that you nominate yourself. "I would like a good night out in the West End paid for by the public and we do manage a few homes so please enter us in the ALMO category" or words to that effect.

These awards are just a money making machine. They don't exist because the magazine has any particular legal right to dole out awards. They are so that they tie people to their magazines and make everyone feel good about them. Last year 700 people attended the awards and so Inside Housing grossed £84,000 (at this year's prices) from ticket sales alone. These are not their only wards. they also sell sponsorship of the event, sponsors are usually firms who want to gain more business or at least to keep their name in the frame and they get the chance to rub shoulders with 700 possible customers.

Who takes a table. Well the 6 shortlisted companies do because as sure as eggs is eggs if they don't take a table they almost certainly won't win an award. Let us suppose that there are 6 short-listed entrants for each category. Each of them uses this as a justification to take a table. So that is £7,200 in the bank for the organiser. Who owns Inside Housing? It is Ocean Media Group. They are not some philanthropic organisation who are dedicated to making social housing better but a commercial company (nothing wrong with that) who just want to make money. They do it by printing magazines and organising conferences. Take a look at their website.

Look at what else they also publish. Back Street Heroes magazine. Mr Mustard has come across this magazine before as he will read most things about 2 wheels.

Is an award for housing from a company which promotes custom motorcycles really worth much? It is a vanity award in Mr Mustard's opinion. You are only offered an award, a moment in the spotlight, so that you take a table at The Hilton Park Lane and boost the profits of Ocean.

What we don't know is how many of the 60 ALMO's that exist entered the ALMO of the year section. Maybe it was only 6 and so they all got short-listed? Maybe the best ALMO is modest and doesn't put itself forward for awards? Maybe the winner is simply the one chosen out of the only 6 who put themselves forward and agreed to take a table at the Hilton as after all it wouldn't be much of a night if none of the winners in any of the 14 categories were present.

Mr Mustard's question is - does this award make Barnet Homes a better ALMO? No, of course it doesn't. It makes them into an ALMO with £1,200 less in the bank and 7 staff who will probably be a bit shabby on the morning after the awards and not working at full effectiveness.
 
Have Barnet Homes got money spare that they can spend on drinking and dining at public expense? 

This is part of what Chief Executive Tracey Lees said when taking about the short-listing 

"our vision of great service at great value" £120 for dinner is not great value.

Mr Mustard's vision of great value is that staff earning over £58,200 p.a., as 7 of the people attending the dinner do, should buy their own dinners and drinks. Please each pay £120 into the pot which can be used for any maintenance backlog.

Listen up Barnet Homes and Barnet Council. Stop entering vanity awards and save us all from this waste.

Buy your own drinks in future.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

p.s. Mr Mustard has just been googling Barnet Homes and finds that they were shortlisted in the GO Awards for 2012/13 in the section of GO Best Customer Engagement Initiative of the Year Award, ( link here ). The GO awards celebrate "Excellence in Public Procurement". Mr Mustard recently found out that Barnet Homes have been using the same design company for years, and have paid them ( Dogstar Design ) over £163,000 without a written contract being in place so procurement is evidently not an area of expertise for Barnet Homes.

Barnet Homes and Barnet Council would have to fight it out for the Private Eye Piss Poor Procurement Award. You haven't got a clue about how bad you are.

20 May 2012

Give me a parking ticket

Mr Mustard wants to blog about parking ticket problems which have arisen since the service has been provided by NSL on 1 May 12. For that he needs to see a recent parking ticket and they are something he tries very had to avoid.

If you have had one could you please send it to mrmustard@zoho.com so that he can see all of the wording. Mr Mustard will redact all data before he blogs it.

Please scan both sides of the ticket.

Thank you

Mr Mustard

18 May 2012

Barnet's least wanted

Another title suggested to Mr Mustard by one of his followers, unamused by their eyeballs being assaulted by the ever changing array of desperate screensavers that he/she/it sees early in the morning. This is what passes for communication in the corridors of North London Business Park.

I am keen; is everyone?

"I want" but will they?

hopefully the website won't replace human interaction

aah, customer journeys.

priceless
ms green light
This pack of AD's is currently up for reduction as part of the management reshuffle which will see 1/3rd of them go. Perfect time to advertise them then.

Here today and possibly......................

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

17 May 2012

The cost of One Barnet 2010-11 - on the Road to Ruin



Here are the One Barnet savings for 2010-11 (you have seen them before; please pay attention at the back and on the Barnet Council front bench)


Item Amount £
Revenue Income Optimisation
Advertising on advertising hoardings on council land 152,000
Income following change of policy on CPZ spaces 174,000
Development of settlement checking service 11,000
Children's service - additional lettings income 3,000
sub-total 340,000


Procurement
Environment 160,000
Planning, housing, regeneration 47,000
Corporate governance 11,000
Commercial 186,000
Chief Executive 7,000
Finance 10,000
Human Resources 164,000
Children's service 212,000
Unknown 67,900
sub-total 864,900


E-recruitment
Implementation of an e-recruitment service 161,000
sub-total 161,000


Transport
Better demand management & changing routes 71,000
sub-total 71,000


Grand total 1,436,900  

Here are the costs for the same period.


Vendor Name £ Comment/Description
Local Authority Trading Company
Care and Health Solutions Ltd 22,400 High level analysis, stakeholder engagement and delivery of High Level Options Appraisal
Impower 68,229 Detailed business analysis and delivery of Business Case - Business Analysis paper
Impower 11,940 Re-modelling of financial analysis and high level project planning
Impower 8,245 Stakeholder engagement workshops interviews and project transition plan scoping
Taxation Expertise (KPMG) 12,000 Commercial taxation advice and reports on company group structure
Trowers and Hamlins 7,110 Commercial legal advice on tekal exemption LATC proposal
Childrens Project
Agilisys/Impower 29,987 Children's Centre Business Plan
Customer Services Transformation
Hays Recruitment 5,700 Agency Business Analyst brought in through Hays
Greensand Public Finance Consultancy 4,427 Training consultancy
BTS Holdings PLC 320 Telephony data report
London Councils (Room Hire) 171 Room Hire
Hays Recruitment 28,333 Agency Business Analyst
Agilisys/Impower 8,425 Workpackage to investigate opportunities for greater transactional use of the web to support development of CST and NSCSO business cases
Agilisys/Impower 46,940 Workpackage to support the first phase of customer services consolidation
Agilisys/Impower 43,152 Workpackage to investigate opportunities for greater transactional use of the web to support development of CST and NSCSO business cases
Agilisys/Impower 11,657 Workpackage to support the development of the CST and NSCSO business cases
Development and Regulatory Services
Agilisys/Impower 57,068 Development of business case
Agilisys/Impower 105,239 Development of business case
Agilisys/Impower 11,975 Development of business case
CDT Design Limited 8,217 CDT to commission, manage and design the digital printing of Barnet Brochure
Impower/Agilisys 83,983 DRS procurement support to start of dialogue
Trowers and Hamlins 153 Legal advice on this complex procurement project
Trowers and Hamlins 1,578 Legal advice on this complex procurement project
Trowers and Hamlins 6,566 Legal advice on this complex procurement project
Charted Insitute of Public Finance And Accountancy 166 Room Hire
New Support and Customer Service Organization
Agilisys/Impower 34,975 Support to the project to provide technical expertise and analysis for delivery of the NSCSO options appraisal
Agilisys/Impower 52,462 Support to the project to provide technical expertise and analysis for delivery of the NSCSO options appraisal
CIPFA Data Returns 5,625 Data required for Options Appraisal for the CSO
Agilisys/Impower 41,207 The purpose of this work package was to highlight the IT Service Delivery challenges facing the
Council and help mitigate risk through recommendations and highlighting available options to the
Council.
CDT Design Limited 8,217 CDT to commission, manage and design the digital printing of Barnet Brochure
CDT Design Limited 8,217 CDT to commission, manage and design the digital printing of Barnet Brochure
Agilisys/Impower 10,314 The purpose of this work package was review the Council's use of business systems, looking at value for money and providing recommendations for their future management.
Charted Insitute of Public Finance And Accountancy 166 Room Hire
Agilisys/Impower 20,520 Support to the project to provide technical knowledge of services in scope in support of delivering th NSCSO business case
Agilisys/Impower 17,891 Support to project and services in scope in putting together pre procurement documentation such as specifications
Agilisys/Impower 14,550 Support to IT service to identify and produce a service catalogue of applications in use
Parking
Agilisys/Impower 4,250 Parking procurement and specification development support
Agilisys/Impower 6,750 Parking procurement and specification development support
Programme Management Office
Tribal Resourcing 3,628 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 10,864 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 653 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 12,600 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 784 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 78 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 2,061 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 4,563 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 124 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 10,539 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 593 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 27,576 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 608 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 17,685 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 751 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 11,259 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 11,990 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Tribal Resourcing 188 Consultancy on development of One Barnet programme
Trowers and Hamlins 15,562 Legal fees during development of One Barnet programme
Trowers and Hamlins 33 Legal fees during development of One Barnet programme
Headshift Limited 500 IT equipment
Headshift Limited 500 IT equipment
Genisys Group 5,315 IT equipment
Agilisys/Impower 43,450 Assessment of the costs and benefits of the programme within the context of a business case structure/format.
Agilisys/Impower 19,900 Strategic review of the One Barnet Programme and related governance arrangements/Support the creation of the new Programme Management Office
Hays Recruitment 12,368 Comms Officer for One Barnet Programme
Agilisys/Impower 7,337 One Barnet Competitive Dialogue Training
Agilisys/Impower 10,500 Programme Management Office Support Officer
Agilisys/Impower 13,825 Programme Management Office Support Officer
Agilisys/Impower 37,696 Programme Management support to work with the project managers and various key stakeholders
Agilisys/Impower 10,800 Support in the reshaping of the Corporate Procurement Function.
4Projects 3,145 Secure Document Management Tool
Penna Plc 71,875 NSO Support
Hewlett Packard Ltd 54 IT equipment
Office Depot 100 Stationery requirements for the programme
SAP Optimization Project
Logica 11,333 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 11,333 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 11,333 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 11,333 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 11,333 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 11,333 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,320 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 60,000 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 120,000 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 100,000 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 2,400 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,200 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,200 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 300 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,500 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,500 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,500 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,500 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,500 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 2,550 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 175 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 3,500 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,500 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,500 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,650 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 4,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 4,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 4,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 4,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 4,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 4,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,500 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 2,000 SAP Optimization Project
Garfield Associates Ltd 0 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 700 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,050 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 700 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Practicus Limited 1,750 SAP Optimization Project
Green ERP Limited -165 SAP Optimization Project
Corporate Pensions Adjustment -1 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 24,960 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 29,600 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 14,494 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 3,500 SAP Optimization Project
Logica 7,195 SAP Optimization Project
Insight Direct (UK) Ltd 2,052 SAP Optimization Project
Insight Direct (UK) Ltd 20 SAP Optimization Project
iStock International 14 SAP Optimization Project
Amoria Bond Limited 12,000 SAP Optimization Project
Transport
SRP Limited 34,893 Procurement support for the passenger transport project
Rapid Improvement Project
Habanero Business Consulting 7,000 LEAN consultancy to help identify improvements to council processes
Habanero Business Consulting 6,000 LEAN consultancy to help identify improvements to council processes
Habanero Business Consulting 5,500 LEAN consultancy to help identify improvements to council processes
E-Recruitment
Advance HR Consulting Limited 40,000 Programme Manager costs
Prototyping
ThinkPublic Limited 60,000 Running Community Coach project and design of 'prototyping' tools.
The Highstreet Gift Voucher 304 Gift Vouchers to thank people for volunteering as coaches.
Revenue Income Optimisation
PricewaterhouseCoopers 40,000 Review the council's income and identify the opportunities to improve
PricewaterhouseCoopers 150,000 Review the council's income and identify the opportunities to improve

2,087,435
In-house costs 434,318
Total 2,521,753

Mr Mustard will leave you to amuse yourself (except that this level of spending isn't very funny for inadequate return, comparing spend to saving or lack of it.

Over a £1m paid out more than saved.

Remember what one Barnet is? 

It is everything and nothing. ( Does anyone know what it is?)

The figures for 2011/12 should follow next month. 

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard