16 July 2012

It really isn't rocket science

the jpg referred to


The pdf figures

Mr Mustard wonders how many people are giving advice to Cllr Dean Cohen. It is probably quite a few. Hopefully he will ignore anything his predecessor tells him or just do the opposite as that is likely to be popular.

I was sent a copy of an email from a Mr Jez Simms to Cllr Cohen (I have left the misspelling of Choen as I am re-printing not proof-reading). If you want to give the Cabinet Member in charge of parking your opinion you can email him at Cllr.D.Cohen@barnet.gov.uk


From: "Jezza"

Date: 15 July 2012 15:39:10

Subject: Parking

Dear Cllr Cohen.

I write to you this rainy Sunday afternoon in order to articulate my thoughts on the current situation regarding parking in North Finchley.

'P' stands for Parking. It also stand for Potty! This seems to me to be a perfectly appropriate title to represent how this parking project has been handled from the start. I'm starting to wonder if the whole exercise has been designed to eat into whatever money the council does have, in order to justify not having its budget cut for the the next financial year.

A couple of years ago, the council went to great expense by updating the pay-by-coin parking meters with new ones. Barely a year later they were replaced by pay-by-phone ones. Consultation was kept to a minimum because, I suspect, the public and traders alike would have been up in arms about both the way these meters functioned and were priced.

Cutting to the chase Mr Choen, we all know what an utter fiasco this parking project has been. Whilst I appreciate that the council needed to address the issue at the time - about coin machines either breaking down or being vandalised - nevertheless the resultant pay-by-phone solution has not gone down at all well. It's discriminatory, expensive and introduces the necessity of a mobile 'phone in order to allow the facility to function. That - in effect - is taking a tried & tested formula and putting it in reverse - every pun intended!

I understand the council is now thinking about altering the machines - again - to facilitate payment by credit card. Ok, that's fine since it extends the way in which a person can pay for the privilege of using a parking space.

However, I believe the fundamental issue here is about pricing. I've only now just realised - thanks entirely to Helen Michael's efforts - that, in fact, the prices for the Lodge Lane car park, and indeed, all of North Finchley has doubled! Two pounds for one hour? To coin a famous, exasperated cry, "You cannot be serious!" Although, in real terms, when one adds on the addition of 20p that the pay-by-phone operator charges on top of the parking fee, the price increase is even higher.

The reason I attached the jpg Mr Cohen is obviously very clear. The prices that Hertsmere Council set the public are fair and balanced.

And yet this area is seen to be just as if not slightly more affluent than North Finchley. So, if a neighbouring council can come up with car parking prices where, per house-hold, the net income is possibly higher than that of the average home-owner in North Finchley, how on earth can Barnet Council possibly justify trying to extract even more money from the slightly less well off?

The answer is simple - IT CANT!. The leader of the council virtually admitted to me that - there is no money. In other words - thanks to Government cuts - we have no money so we're going to penalise the public through massively inflated parking charges in order to balance the books. Nice try Barnet Council. But when North Finchley is a complete ghost town, when not just a dozen shops have been forced to close down but virtually all of them, what do you plan to do about parking charges then? Because then it will be way too late.

I am disgusted to think that Helen Michael was arrested for effectively defending her right to protest. Yet more waste of tax payers money.

She, like many of her fellow traders, can see the damage that is occuring right before her very eyes. If anyone should be arrested it is the Council itself for its total mismanagement of this whole parking scheme, since it is clearly a contributing factor why businessess having been going under. Those unfortunate businesses are the ones that should be suing the Council! The Council is who should really be questioned - at length - and NOT a lady who is simply fighting for survival.

And on top of this, the Council has the audacity to insist that the shop owners themselves distribute scratch cards to the punters. Discount incentives here, right's to sell at face value prices there - it's just another totally unnecessary addition to a system that has worked so simply, so effectively; for so long.

So I invite you Mr Cohen to look, think and consider again - just for a moment - exactly what the jpeg represents as against the pdf figures.

It's very simple - common sense against common senselessness.

Mary Portas is absolutely right when she observes that the only way to re-invigorate local shopping areas is by giving the incentive to shoppers that they cant get on-line. And one way, as Hertsmere Borough Council have clearly identified, is by setting sensible car-parking charges through machines that are simple to understand and operate. It really isn't rocket science.

If Barnet Council does not heed these warnings, I fear the damage to the local community will be irreparable. And you can bet your bottom dollar that the on-line shopping community is sitting in the neon sun in Sillicon Valley thinking 'thank you Barnet Council - bring it on!"

I look forward to hearing from you at your earlist convenience.

Yours sincerely,

Jez Simms.


That one line "It really isn't rocket science" reverberated with Mr Mustard. Running a parking system should be a cake walk. Make it easy to pay and people will pay; society is fundamentally compliant. Barnet Council is so busy navel gazing and reorganising and having pointless interminable meetings and trying to run One Barnet when it can't even walk that it takes stupid decisions like forcing the motorists of Barnet to go cashless as if Barnet isn't part of the real world. It is and consequently it has to offer the same payment methods as everyone else. By all means offer pay-by-phone but as a choice along with cash, credit card in a local machine or voucher.

Where has Mr Mustard spent money this weekend? John Lewis (Welwyn not Brent X) where he paid with a mixture of vouchers and credit card (large value purchases) Waitrose where he paid with his John Lewis card (to get the 1% cashback) The Paper Shop where he paid by cash, the fish stall on Barnet market (lovely tuna steak) where he paid by cash (it doesn't take credit cards although after 20 years of going though he could probably have an account) Dory's Cafe where he paid by cash, Bargain Buys where he bought 6 lightbulbs and paid by cash and had a free tug of war with Sammy the resident dog. Imagine if all of those 6 shops insisted on being paid by credit card how long it would take to do your shopping and how odd you would think it was.

Do you have a view on how we should be able to pay for our parking and what level the charges should be set out. Then sharpen up your pencil and email Dean Cohen. Remember that councillors work for us and it is our democratic right, our duty even, to write to them and tell them what we think. The more we do it the more they will start to realise that they represent us and not the other way around. If you don't tell them what you think then you can't complain if they do things that you don't like.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

15 July 2012

Get into bed with the wrong partner and contract VD.



Oh dear me Cllr Robert Rams, you can't go around taking a pop at Mr Reasonable and not expect a reaction from the Barnet blogosphere.

This blog post is especially for you. This is what you said in your blog:

Other services will be outsourced and some will be merged with other boroughs – all to make the services better, cheaper and keep council tax down

The most recently ( 1 May 2012 ) out-sourced service under One Barnet is Parking Enforcement. One of the contract elements is to provide paperwork to the ultimate stage of the appeal process, to PATAS - the Parking and Traffic Appeals service. If you look at the parking & traffic appeal statistics 2010-11 here then you can see that of 1028 Barnet appeals in that year some 499 were decided in favour of the motorist which is very nearly half of them (49% in fact)

So let us look now at the PATAS appeal statistics since 2 May. My friend, Miss Feezance is keeping an eye on the cases for me and you can find her blog here. There are notes from the parking adjudicator on many of them which highlight the lack of paperwork from Barnet even on a couple of occasions after asking for adjournments.

Overall since 2 May the position is as follows in this table:

Week Motorist Council
Starting won won
2 May 34 3
7 May 102 1
14 May 34 2
21 May 55 1
28 May 70 0
4 June 2 0
11 June 43 7
18 June 24 8
25 June 17 6
2 July 12 7
9 July 13 1
since NSL 406 36

So if 2012/13 followed the pattern of 2010/11 then the numbers that you would expect to see are 214 in favour of the motorist and 228 in favour of the council.

Therefore NSL and/or Barnet Council's lack of planning and/or incompetence during the handover period means that, so far (and there is no indication that the problem has yet been fixed) 192 appeals have been won which would ordinarily have been lost. So for breach of contract NSL should repay £98 per ticket and also the £46.73 that Barnet Council has to pay for each appeal listed at PATAS. Each failure costs £144.73 which, so far, times 192 = £27,788 which could have been spent on keeping Friern Barnet library open for a few months or would pay for the 5 parking meters that the council is about to buy. 

Mr Mustard is already on the case for information about payments to NSL since they took over. He expects the usual battle to get information (he has already booked 4 weeks holiday for next year June/July so that he can go more thoroughly through the Annual Accounts. Please take this blog post as notice in the Closing section that Mr Mustard will want to see every document relating to the parking account next year. Save yourself some time and start putting the file together now) as if Barnet Council parking management are partly to blame for NSL's he fully expects them to go into fortress mentality mode and try and pretend that nothing was there fault. The FOI request about payment to NSL for May 12 is already late in being answered. Mr Mustard is used to obstruction and will bulldoze his way to his target through anything put in his way.

So why has Barnet Council got VD? Well, they didn't choose very carefully who they got into bed with and now have a Veritable Disaster on their hands. All the clap-trap that gets talked about One Barnet has led them to contract corporate clap.

As outsourcing goes then Robert Rams this doesn't look like a better or cheaper service to me. Does it to you? Answers in an email with your apology to Mr Reasonable for doubting his judgment.

Here is a thought for you ruling councillors (especially cabinet members), once you catch corporate clap it is very hard to eradicate, it is (financially) painful and contagious, prospective partners who hear you have it will run a mile (are you thinking about your corporate image BT, Capita & EC Harris?).

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

for those who ended up on this blog because they have a nasty rash, you need to follow this link instead.

13 July 2012

John Dix speaks (to your group if you wish)

John Dix (aka Mr Reasonable) is a legend. He has been studying Barnet Council's accounts for some time. He runs a small business and is very comfortable with accounts, balance sheets & £millions.

Here is a talk he gave recently:



If you would like John to give a talk at your Residents' Association he would be delighted to tell you about One Barnet and answer your questions. Email him at john@johndix.co.uk 

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

CPZ comparison - Barking & Dagenham

They are less barking in Barking.

CPZ in Barking & Dagenham
Mr Mustard thought it would be useful to compare our CPZ charges with those of another edge of London borough.

Ignore the apostrophe in TMO's. It should not be there. The "s" signifies a plural. Just as in Barnet no-one checks documents before they go out.

Similarly one must assume on the first page that towards the bottom it should read "who will issue Penalty Charge Notices to any vehicle..."

Don't sent to that email address on the final line as an extra "at" has slipped into the word consultation.

Look at the pricing. The blogger bus is a 1995cc diesel powered Renault Trafic so would require Mr Mustard to pay £60 for a permit, some £40 less than in Barnet. Note the lower charges for smaller vehicles.

Visitor permits are £10.50 for 10. Ooh, that is reasonable just like ours used to be.

Didn't Barnet Council claim their charges were in line with similar boroughs? Not with Barking though.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

London Councils - help wanted



lovely car

There is a prize ( a Mr Mustard t-shirt ) for the first person to tell him whose car this is and whether they have a legitimate reason to be in Carnarvon Rd, EN5 on 5 July at 3.20 in the afternoon. Mr Mustard knows 95%+ of his neighbours and thus their visitors. This is the second time he has seen this London Councils employee car in the street with the same post-it note visible. Mr Mustard notes how near he is to the shops of the Spires shopping centre (such as they are nowadays) and wonders if that was the real attraction. 

There is no concession as far as he is aware that London Councils vehicles are not ticketed. The problem comes that any appeal is ultimately heard by PATAS (Parking and Traffic Appeals Service) which is run by London Councils.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard


12 July 2012

Tea & Sympathy from Barnet Council? - not a chance

In New York - where they also have cash & card meters

Don't blame Declan Hoare. He has not written to Mr Mustard in a sympathetic manner but he is probably under terrible pressure because he is trying to manage the havoc that councillors' policies have caused in parking and get out of them under the new cabinet member's guidance and trying to get NSL to do what they have contracted to do.

O2 customers will be particularly interested in this post.

Sent: 12 July 2012 09:41
To: Hoare, Declan; Wharfe, Pam
Cc: all councillors

Subject: Pay by phone parking

 


Dear Mr Hoare / Ms Wharfe

You may have noticed that the O2 mobile phone network has problems today (and had them yesterday).

Having pay by phone as almost the only payment method is now not looking like the best decision in the world.
Will commonsense prevail such that motorists who can prove they have an O2 mobile phone have their parking bay or car park related parking tickets cancelled during the period of network outage or will motorists be expected not to park?

This does rather show the value of meters does it not (especially ones that take cash and credit cards)?

Yours sincerely


Mr Mustard



Dear Mr Mustard

We would expect O2 to compensate motorists if they incur a penalty charge notice through a failure of their phone service. However to be clear it is the motorists responsibility to ensure that they park legally and the Council will not cancel properly issued penalty charge notices.

I have no doubt that O2 will have their network problems corrected shortly. In the meantime motorists are able to pay for parking using Paypoint (details of the nearest outlet are available via www.paypoint.co.uk) or by buying parking vouchers from their nearest library.

Declan Hoare
Assistant Director Highways and Transport
Environment, Planning and Regeneration Directorate
Tel: 020 8359 4320
Mob: 07786 094 966


Dear Mr Hoare

Thank you for your disappointing but unsurprising response.

If you have just arrived in your car from, say, Birmingham, for a business meeting in Barnet and you are faced with pay-by-phone and your mobile telephone network is not working then it will not be possible to use the browser on your handset to find the nearest paypoint shop.

A brummie is hardly likely to know where the nearest library is either. By the time he/she finds out, walks or drives there (the parking problem still exists at the library - you could get a ticket whilst inside the library or whilst you are walking there )and walks or drives back they are probably 30 minutes late for their appointment. In addition, you aren't thinking about the library hours, they are not open at 8am when many cpz start and don't let's even think about Mondays when more libraries are closed than open.

Link to library opening times

Vouchers from libraries are not a practical solution.

Welcome to Barnet. It's not part of the real world.
Yours sincerely

Mr Mustard

What is the point of a CPZ? 

This is what Directgov say:
A controlled parking zone (CPZ) is a parking scheme mainly used in urban areas. CPZs are used by local councils to address particular parking problems in a community - usually in order to help residents park near to their homes.

This means that parking is only permitted in designated parking bays - the remainder of the kerbside space is subject to yellow line restrictions.

CPZs can also be used to allow more free-flowing traffic through town centres, particularly where parking causes problems for the emergency services.

Nothing there about raising revenue. Every council in the land will deny that raising money is the objective but judge councils by their words and deeds and the answer is very different.

Motorists have a problem today. The council is meant to be citizen-centric so do the council help you? no, they kick you when you are down. If the CPZs are really not about making money then a council should be pleased to help  citizens on difficult days and not be thinking how much money they can claw in from Penalty Charge Notices.

If you get a ticket and you were an O2 customer, appeal informally the appeal again formally and then appeal to PATAS who might well take a more sympathetic viewpoint.

Barnet Council, remember this. You are here to serve the public. When it comes to parking you are self-serving money grubbing miseries.

Have a nice day now.


Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Park yourselves Councillors and listen

Friern Barnet Photo Archive


as you had to do because having generated a petition with 13,000 signatures the constitution says so. Here is the speech delivered by Helen Michael, the doyenne of the (in particular) North Finchley traders who have dared to stand up and have their voice heard.

I have been a resident in Barnet for over 20 years and I have owned a business here for over 6 years.

Despite the downturn in the economy, I and the other traders were able to run our businesses on a break even basis.

In November 2011 Barnet Council introduced a parking regime without any consultation with traders or residents, increasing the parking  charges by 70%, higher than any other borough and more expensive than Islington, Camden and Westminster.

If I, as an example were to increase my prices by 70% overnight, I would find that my customers would go elsewhere.  This is what has happened to our town centres.

Furthermore, the pay by phone system gives no other choice.  It can be unworkable and your scratch cards are elusive.

Barnet Council has united the whole borough in the issue of the parking.  The other traders and I  can identify to the day our downturn in business to when our meters were removed.

As a result of the strong feelings amongst traders and residents and comments made to us by the public, who are no longer able to pop to Finchley for a newspaper, coffee, sweets or to meet friends without being charge extortionately for the visit.  The traders in Barnet, North Finchley and I prepared a poster campaign and petition.  Over 25 local businesses signed the petition and as you know almost 13,000 members of the public signed the petition supporting our cause.  Most were outraged, some incredulous that Barnet Council could be so short sighted and insensitive to the needs of its traders and residents and more importantly so  undemocratic.

Almost all had concerns about the cost of the parking in our town centres. Others had concerns about standing in the street with mobile phones and credit cards in hand. There is of course an issue regarding the elderly ,the hard of hearing and vulnerable members of our society. A large proportion of people do not feel comfortable registering their details.

As a public facing business who speaks to people from all walks of life on a daily basis, I meet hundreds of people  who share our concerns about the dying high street.  Instead of the Council encouraging shoppers to visit the high street, you are encouraging people to Brent Cross who spend a fortune advertising free parking.

Our car parks now stand empty . Our children play football in the Lodge lane car park and I believe there is dogging in the carp park by Poundland as it is so underused.

The other traders and I suspect the revenue collected from parking has taking a nose dive.  This is obvious to anyone  monitoring the use of the car park sand the parking bays which are now empty, where they were previously  over subscribed.  I am sure that this is the reason why the Council is so reluctant despite repeated requests to furnish us with the revenue figures,. This parking system has been a failure from start to finish for locals, parking traffic and traders.   Even more so for the tax payer whose assets are not being realised to its full potential. If the Council can’t get the parking right, what hope is there with the One Barnet Programmes.

Contrast the council car parks with the Spires in Barnet.  A privately owned car park who  made a proactive commercial decision to cut their charges in order to encourage shoppers/businesses which has a been a roaring success and it is now very difficult to get a space both at weekends and during the week. They still operate cash meter which is commercially viable unlike the Council car parks which are seriously under subscribed.

To date I have attended about 9 Council run meetings regarding our town centres.  I  have been interviewed on national TV and until this came along the only positive action take  by Barnet Council was a visit from the Police regarding our poster. Not satisfied with the local constabulary paying me a visit in the first instant,  Barnet Council have insisted that I be interviewed by the anti terrorist squad of New Scotland Yard. Two trips by two high ranking officers and a two hour  interview, two weeks from the Olympics. Need I say more…

A review is now being undertaken some nine months after the Council introduced this system and the funding from this is from the Outer London Fund.  Surely this matter can be better spent on the High Road.   Note from the questionnaire it does not ask  the traders about the change in turnover, nor the parking needs of their customers, nor what percentage of their customers come by car.

The Council have been aware of the issues regarding their parking regime from the outset.  You have accepted that there is a major problem and we have given you several alternative solutions which will not only benefit the council, but may also help local businesses stay in business in these difficult times, providing we can entice people back to our high roads all of which  have been ignored.

I have visited both East Finchley and Finchley town centres. The parking controls on the side streets appear to be for only one hour per day.   In North Finchley parking controls run all day for the whole of the day.  I notice that both Finchley Central and East Finchley have regenerated themselves, whereas North Finchley is in serious decline. This has got to  be as a direct result of a very expensive parking charges in North Finchley. There is no station around the High Road, North Finchley, so there is no issue regarding commuters.

The questions I wish to have answered on behalf of the Traders are:

How much is this survey costing?
Why is there such a discrepancy between Whetstone, East Finchley, Finchley Central and north Finchley?
The parking revenue, both before and after the parking was introduced for 10 months either side?

The traders want to be involved in any consultation and decision making in advance of any  changes and perhaps a trader or two could sit on the committee. The London Borough of Barnet is struggling.  What is their timetable for review and action. Dean Cohen has suggested 50p for 15 minutes.  Does he think he is doing us a favour.? There is concession for that. It is still £2.00 per hour, far too expensive. We would urge the Council to give shoppers half an hour free parking in order to entice people back to the high road. It seems like it is a foregone conclusion as he still wants to charge 50p for 15 minutes.

How much did it cost to rip out our meters?
Businesses are seriously struggling and some cannot wait a year for something to be done. We need a date when any changes are going to be implemented.
We need your assurances in future that anyone involved in supporting campaigns will not be harassed by the Police opposing Council policies.

Mr Mustard did not make it to Tuesday's full Council meeting at which this fine speech was delivered although he has seen the film. It was slightly cut short at the end by a flustered looking Councillor Richard Cornelius who, like the biased referee at a fairground boxing match, cuts the round short when his man is losing. Your administration are all looking a bit punch drunk at the moment though aren't they? We are only in about round 3 of the One Barnet boxing match and the opposition keeps getting stronger, has lots of energy left to taunt you and is showing every sign of being still standing at the end of Round 10 whilst team One Barnet will be out cold.

Time to take up golf maybe Richard?

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard