11 July 2012

Costs and consequences of a One Barnet Commissioning Council

Mr Mustard has permission to reproduce this report.
Barnet Commissioning Council FINAL

If you don't have the time to read it all councillors just take a peek at page 7 "the consequences for Councillors" - you are going to be impotent once all these big One Barnet contracts are awarded and it is you who will have to take the flak for stuff that goes wrong and it will be a nightmare and expensive to fix. Have you checked how the parking contract with NSL is going? Accordingly to my lady friend Miss Feezance it is going badly, take a look here, NSL are not providing paperwork to PATAS. Perhaps you could have a look and let Mr Mustard know as that might be quicker than him waiting for an answer to his FOI request of 7 June 2012 (#1296 about NSL invoices & Key Performance Indicators for May 2012) which is now overdue.

Also take a look at page 18. Mr Mustard wrote to Cllr Dean Cohen today suggesting some simplification of the charges for parking permits and advocating the KISS principle (Keep it Simple Stupid). Didn't I hear you talking about that recently as well Cllr Hugh Rayner, but you were too coy to use the word stupid. Well, tell Mr Mustard, does that table look simple? No. It is bonkers for a council that can't manage to even issue purchase orders properly.

Look at the Leadership Matrix on page 19. Would you follow Nick Walkley into battle? Does he inspire you? Is he a great leader?

Don't you think councillors that it is time you stopped all this One Barnet nonsense, chucked out Agilisys and started to look at the nuts and bolts yourself?; there is about £9m worth of senior management who you could put to work. The devil is always in the detail. There is so much superfluous detail at Barnet Council it is impossible to see the wood for the trees.

Are you really in charge councillors? Don't answer that last question. It is too embarrassing for you.

In APSE isn't to your liking councillors might listen to what Conservative MP Liddell Grainger has to say about outsourcing in his neck of the woods

Somerset West and Sedgemoor talking about IBM and the Strategic partnership known as Southwest One. 

“The company has recorded chronic losses in every year of trading and has failed to do what its creators promised - namely save any significant public money. Instead it squandered cash on a computer system that still isn't working properly and continues to overcharge Somerset County Council and other "partners" for so-called services.
Somerset Council has now caved in to FoI requests and published the bids:

Supplier / Bid
Total cost over 10 years
BT Standard bid
£220.552M
BT Variant Bid
£248.055M
Capita Standard Bid
£256.671M
Capita Variant Bid
£267.687M
IBM Standard Bid
£253.820M
IBM Variant Bid
£253.820M

“BT came in almost £34 million cheaper than IBM on the standard bid - and very nearly £6 million cheaper on the "variant" bid - the projected cost of the grandiose extras the customer (Alan Jones) fancied. Capita's approach was to pitch ridiculously high, like a builder who doesn't really want the work at all. But the fascinating thing about this table of statistics is the IBM tactic. There is no difference whatsoever between their standard and variant bids. In other words IBM seemed to be prepared to keep the price the same whatever nutty bolt-on extras the customer wanted. Jones had asked for an "iconic" HQ for South West One, for example, to be built in Taunton. Needless to say IBM never provided it. They were promising the moon for the same price as an ordinary product.”
You can read his full article here

If it went wrong there, why would it go right in Barnet? and what is the backup plan? Every sensible company has a disaster recovery plan. 

In Barnet we are walking the high wire without a safety net.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

10 July 2012

Barnet Council employees - want to be your own boss?

Eat this and you get a certificate; the Harry Ramsden's Big Fish challenge

and now a different sort of challenge. A press release from the Communities and Local Government department.

Community Right to Challenge comes into force

Published 27 June 2012

From today more communities will be able to bid to take over local services they think they can run differently and better as the Community Right to Challenge provisions come into effect.

The Community Right to Challenge hands more power back to communities, allowing voluntary and community groups, parish councils and local authority staff to express an interest in taking over the running of local authority services, making services more responsive to local needs and delivering better value for money.

Also from today a range of specialist support is being put in place to help community groups wanting to take greater control of their community through every stage of the process - from setting up a group and developing a proposal right through to the delivering services on the ground.

The Social Investment Business, in partnership with Locality and the Association of Chief Executives of Voluntary Organisations will deliver a three year support programme worth £11.5million. The programme will include a dedicated advice phone line where support and information will be available. It will also include grants to help groups to use the new right and bid to run local public services, resources, and case studies.

Now is your chance to break free of the shackles of the toxic One Barnet nonsense and get together with your colleagues to run your service. Remove all those layers of management and provide a proper service at a lower price by streamlining the service as you know best what needs to be done and how to do it.
Cemetery staff; do you need telling how to run a funeral? No, you don't. Put in a bid to run the cemetery yourselves.

Building controllers; you are the technical experts. Put down your own foundations and build a new business.

Who else could go it alone? These, for starters:

Parking permit team

Internal audit - become external internal audit

Highways - all of it - as separate companies

Payroll - an easy service to hive off

Communications - talk amongst yourselves about this idea

Revs & Bens - get Dave Sharpe onto this as he may have the free time?

Print & Document management - lease some kit and some space and press the go button.

Estates management - you are out of sight half the time anyway doing your work - you could easily manage the estates of the council and others.

Accounts payable - you could work on your own account

So at your tea break or lunch today why not sit down with a colleague and have a chat. Chop the department up into logical segments that could be run as stand-alone businesses and start working on your ideas. Do not take any information that is not already in the public domain (we don't want another Finance for Schools type investigation) or do anything improper or against the interests of your employer.

Best to start on this website, My Community Rights

Well, what are you waiting for. Get on with it. You are now the boss. Please also spread the word around other departments.

Don't let the fact that you are part of the DRS or NSCSO sell-offs and that Barnet council can accordingly reject your challenge. Any open organisation which is genuinely looking for savings will appreciate having a second price to consider.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard



Not credit card worthy

There seem to be an infinite number of things wrong at Barnet Council with even the simplest administrative tasks seemingly beyond the ability of management.

Take "Residents Permits" for example (let's not mention the missing apostrophe as there is a grave shortage of them at the council. It might be better for all concerned if the wording was turned around to be Permits for Residents)

If you cannot renew your permit on-line for some reason then you need a form to post in. This is available at this page on the Barnet website.

If you click on "Residents Parking Permit Application Form" at the right of the screen you obtain a form that is version 3.1 from December 2011, viz

Residents Parking Permit Application Form December 2011

If you then click on the words "Residents Application Form" you get version 3.2 from June 2012


Residents Permit v3.2 June 2012

What did you notice. That if you use the December form the price is £100 and not £105. Mr Mustard will leave you to decide which form to download print out and send in. (I expect the Tooting twister who is in overall charge of the website will leap into action and correct this error pretty quickly so the form may not be available from the council website for long - you can download it from here though - nudge nudge wink wink) (Mr Mustard has just remembered that Barnet Homes, a Barnet Council ALMO, have a subsidiary called "Your Choice" - well this is your chance to have a choice which you don't normally)

Did you want to pay by credit card? You can't. Parking has gone cashless (almost) you know. Now it seems to have gone credit card less as well. Look, here is an older version of the form in the middle of a long report.
Parking Permit Religious-Faith Duties

So someone has decided that if you pay by post you must be such a luddite that you don't have a credit card. Is this reasonable or equitable? No, of course it isn't. Sometimes when you buy a replacement vehicle that is the only way that you can pay for the new permit as happened to Mr Mustard recently who then found his cheque book, knocked the dust off and wrote one out.

Is it right that you should then be penalised £5 because the council's systems can't cope? No, of course not.

Is a two tier pricing structure bonkers? Yes it is. A cheque costs nothing to clear and the credit card merchant will charge about 2% so if anything the person paying by cheque should pay less.

Have councillors collectively decided upon this new policy? Not that Mr Mustard has noticed.

Has there been an "Officer decision" recorded in a Delegated Powers Report of this new policy? Again, not as Mr Mustard has noticed. (Feel free to tell Mr Mustard is wrong and he will correct any errors).

Does this new policy fit well with the One Barnet key principles?

A relentless drive for efficiency? Doesn't look like it does it going back to a method that has been around since the 9th century and which was until recently being phased out, except in Barnet where it is being phased back in.

Delivering more choice for better value? Oh dear me no. Less choice is being offered.

A citizen-centric council? No, you must do it the way that some faceless individual has decided upon.

Can you add this into your parking review please Councillor Dean Cohen (I have dropped you an email)

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard




9 July 2012

Building Control Awards not

Brown envelopes - Barnet Council? - oh yes"!

Awards day. From the Barnet council website

Boost for Barnet’s Building Control team

Published Thursday 14 June 2012

The partnership working of Barnet’s Building Control team has been recognised at a prestigious awards ceremony {held on 24 May 12 at the Old Library, the Guild Hall (sic)}

The Local Authority Building Control London Region Building Excellence Awards ceremony acknowledges the best examples of building design and construction. Awards are given for the quality of the construction, the innovation involved in the developments and the professionalism and skill involved in delivering entire projects across London.

Barnet Building Control nominated Alan Cox Associates Limited, in conjunction with Andrew and Dickens and Malone Associates, for their work in creating a smart new housing development in Uphill Road. The nomination won the ‘Best Small Housing Development’ category.

The award was part of a high profile and prestigious field of entrants which also included the Olympic Stadium and Velodrome in east London as well as the new London Aquatics Centre. The Olympic Stadium was the winning project in the Best Community Building category. The velodrome won the Best Sustainable category. The Aquatics Centre won the Best Technical section. Therefore none of these three mentioned projects were in competition with Alan Cox and any mention of them is just to sex up the dossier and make the award seem more worthy. A pretty desperate press release if ever there was one.

Alan Cox Associates is based in High Barnet and works with Barnet Building Control in a partnership arrangement and can make Building Regulation applications via Barnet for works anywhere in England and Wales.

Thursday 14 June must have been a very quiet day for news in Barnet. Well done Alan Cox for getting the award - you had Mr Mustard as a client a couple of years ago but someone will have to tell you who I am! ("the man with the mansard roof" might help you work it out - 4 applications for planning permission - no evidence of partnership working with the council during those 2 years -  just shock and awe that someone didn't want an ugly dormer)

When Mr Mustard first read this press release he was going to blog about people giving awards to themselves because the LABC awards are given out by an association of Local Authority building controllers so if they gave the award to Barnet Council Building Control it would be a self-congratulatory award worth nothing at all but it is even less than that.

In fact, having read the press release more carefully it looks like the Tooting Twister has been twisting for all he is worth (I agree Mrs Angry, not much, about a tenth of what his town hall tax dodging company is paid) and that all that Barnet Council have done is to nominate someone else for an award. This is deemed worthy of space on the website.

Mr Mustard is also a regular customer of building control and apart from one new-boy who was a bit rule bound all of the building controllers are sensible souls who work very hard and do a good job and take a pragmatic approach. One of them visited Mr Mustard to do the final inspection on the extensive rebuild of Mustard Mansions and spent the visit admiring the workmanship and wishing he had the same budget for his own property - he was drooling over the solid oak floors and it was a pleasure to have him in the house. He was sadly too busy to stop for a cup of tea and a longer chat about house renovation.

If a client getting an award is all it takes to boost Barnet Building Control then their lives are very boring indeed. Mr Mustard expects that they are embarrassed by the publicity for simply having done their jobs.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

8 July 2012

Bogged down at the Annual Audit

British Toilet Awards

Barnet Council love putting themselves forward for awards and Mr Mustard thinks they are in training for the British Toilet Awards. Otherwise why would they be going to the trouble of escorting any of the bloggers to the toilet when they visited North London Business Park to inspect the Accounts of the council when they are opened up for audit once per year as required by law. The 3 bloggers Mr Reasonable, Mrs Angry and Mr Mustard were joined by a parking expert who was acting on behalf of a local resident. It is the case that one can simply turn up between 9.30am and 4.30pm and ask to see whatever documents relate to the year ended on 31 March. The bloggers had quite a list and being generally quite businesslike had sent their list in a week or even two weeks ( Mr R is so organised) in advance so as to cause the minimum disturbance.

Now for those in the know we were in Training Room 6 about 25 metres up a busy corridor from the cafe which overlooks the lovely courtyard. The toilets are situated at the other end of the cafe. Now one would think that we could have been treated as if we were respectable residents (no-one was wearing a hoodie, carrying a knife or sporting love and hate tattoos on their knuckles) and allowed to walk 25m on our own to the toilet and to pick up a cappuccino on the way back but no, if we headed for the escape hatch door, a young and embarrassed employee would appear at our elbow and escort us to the toilets and then stand outside looking embarrassed until we had adjusted our attire and reappeared. It transpires that no other guests have been treated that way in the past and hopefully they won't be in the future.

When he returned to Room 6 after his second coffee, Mr Mustard found the following text appear on his mobile phone

"Is this a fascist state? - no, just Barnet Council"

which was sent by an employee called redacted

Mr Mustard really wonders what Barnet Council think and he thinks they are bereft of ideas for dealing with the bloggers. It would take more than some perfectly polite young man walking with him to the toilet to upset a debt collector of 25+ years experience, maybe you could buy a ball and chain for the next visit or Mr Mustard might even turn up in a convict's uniform. The council were somewhat short of manners when it comes to receiving guests as well. The norm in any business meeting is to offer tea and coffee. If the audit had been taking place at Grant Thornton Mr Mustard can guarantee that there would be a tray of drinks and biscuits in the room 2 minutes before the meeting started and if the meeting went through lunch a tray of snadwiches and fruit would arrive. Mr Travers was not in the building, he was probably on the beach in East Sussex. Would you be so good Andrew as to slip one of your minders a tenner out of your £1,000 a day so that your guests can be properly accommodated. Don't you have to be in Barnet though when the statutory Audit is going on being as how you are the part-time S151 officer?

If any councillors want to meet with Mr Mustard to explain perhaps why One Barnet is such a good thing Mr Mustard will personally put the kettle on and willingly make you a tea or a coffee because that is polite before he then tries to put a hole in your argument.

If any senior officers want to pop round perhaps because they think have been unfairly reported of in this blog as, say, being piss-poor at procurement and that henceforth you should be known as the Prince of Procurement rather than Captain Chaos then you too would be most welcome and given tea or coffee after which we could study a list of what has gone wrong in procurement and what has gone wrong. The first list will be much longer than the second.

Now having got the housekeeping out of the way we moved to the documents themselves. Mr Mustard wanted to look at the invoices of 3 suppliers of agency staff and of PATAS. He limited one of the enquiries, about Hays, to just one month in order to limit the workload. He was not presented with a file of original invoices as he expected but with copies which had been redacted and he has now taken home the copies of copies that were made for him and which look like they are set to become exhibit A in his formal complaint. Barnet Council had crossed out anything that he wanted to see such as the names of consultants, hourly or daily rates, number of hours or days worked, the project they were working on (sometimes) and this is just utterly and completely wrong.

Here is the invite to pop along and inspect the accounts. Do turn up without notice if you fancy looking at any invoices at all for the year ended 31 March 2012

S15 Audit Commission Act 1998 says that information about "a member of staff" can be redacted. Mr Mustard did not ask to look at such information; he plays by the rules. He does expect to be able to look at the invoices for supplying a senior consultant, or even a junior consultant, from Agilisys or iMpower, and that has been denied to him and will lead to a complaint. These people are in effect deciding who will provide our services in the future. They must be accountable to residents.

Mr Mustard wanted to take a look at the invoices from PATAS (the Parking and Traffic Appeals Service) and again he only asked for 3 months worth in order to save time of council staff. The time of the legal department was wasted in redacting all the unit prices. Now not only are Barnet Council wasting time but they are wasting time on redacting information that is in the public domain on the London Councils website as it is they who manage PATAS and they charge each borough a fixed annual fee based upon the number of parking tickets issued in a previous year and a fee for each case that is appealed to them. Mr Mustard is shocked at how little the redactor knows about their world of work. The fees of PATAS will be the subject of a future blog post.


(3) A person who has the custody of any such document and—
(a) obstructs a person in the exercise of a right under this section to inspect or make copies of the document, or
(b) refuses to give copies of the document to a person entitled under this section to obtain them,
is guilty of an offence and liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 3 on the standard scale.

Mr Mustard will have to consult his solicitor but he thinks that the redaction of a price from a London Councils' invoice is an obstruction. A level 3 fine is £1,000 so one day's pay lost is no big deal for black hole but the loss of face would be enormous.

Our time was also wasted whilst the legal department finished off the redaction of some documents on the grounds of supplier request. Another completely unacceptable way of going on. Both the lateness as they had at least a week to prepare and the fact that suppliers were consulted. 

Barnet Council need to get out of this fortress mentality. If they don't want to be criticised the best way is to behave in a way that does not allow them to be criticised. Mr Mustard has long advocated that he wants them to become a boring council and leave him with nothing to write about. There is no sign of that happening for some time.

Mr Mustard needs to go now and draft his email of complaint to Andrew Travers. It will not contain any criticism of the staff who will just have been doing what they are told.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard


5 July 2012

Barnet Bloggers' open letter re. Helen Michael of Cafe Buzz



Helen Michael: open letter to Councillor Richard Cornelius and to Scotland Yard

Since the electoral defeat of former Assembly Member and Barnet Cabinet member Brian Coleman in May, Barnet’s Tory council leader Richard Cornelius and his colleagues have sought to distance themselves from most of the more controversial policies that Coleman promoted.

Most significant among these is the parking scheme, which has caused so much anger among the residents and traders of this borough.

At a meeting with Barnet traders at a North Finchley forum in December last year, Councillor Cornelius was told in no uncertain terms by the shopkeepers and small business owners of this borough about the devastating impact of this ridiculous scheme. He replied:

“I’m listening, but I haven’t got any intention to do anything else other than that ... I’ve heard you and it’s obviously affected me. I don’t know what I can do. I don’t know if I can do anything.”
 
Local cafe owner Helen Michael said:

“We are wasting our time – you’ve said in no uncertain terms that you’re not going to do anything. We are begging for our businesses, for our livelihoods. Please do something.”

Councillor Cornelius and his fellow Tories sat back and watched as the life of our local high streets ebbed away, in some cases losing up to 40 percent of their usual level of trade.

He refused to do anything for us, so we acted for ourselves.

Bloggers, traders, residents, community activists and trade unions united and voiced their opposition to the changes. Prominent among the campaigners was Helen Michael. As spokeswoman for North Finchley traders she made every effort to focus attention on the injustice and devastating impact of the policy, and hold Councillor Coleman to account for the consequences of his scheme. Her efforts won admiration from London Mayor Boris Johnson – and even Richard Cornelius, who is reported to have suggested she should think of standing as a Conservative candidate for the council.

Only since Brian Coleman lost his seat on the London Assembly, and then his Cabinet post, and in response to two other electoral defeats, has the Tory group on Barnet Council admitted that the parking changes were unfair, and sought to retract them. Councillor Cornelius has now apologised for introducing the policy, and a review is underway.

How ironic it is, therefore, that the woman who did what Councillor Cornelius failed to do, and fought for the best interests of residents and traders, is now being investigated by Scotland Yard, after an allegation of wrongdoing in relation to a poster produced by her in the course of the parking campaign. An omission on this poster was rectified early on in the campaign, and Helen Michael was informed by local police that there would be no further action.

Despite this assurance, Helen Michael is now being investigated by officers from Scotland Yard, and yesterday spent two hours, under caution, being interviewed at a local police station about the poster, and her motivation for its publication.

We believe that this targeting of a local campaigner is a deliberate and politically motivated act of intimidation.

To involve the police in this way is inappropriate, and a serious misuse of their time and resources.

We call on Council leader Richard Cornelius to speak out against the victimisation of a brave, resourceful and admirable woman. We call on Scotland Yard to desist from taking any further action in regard to this matter.

Signed:

Derek Dishman
John Dix
Vicki Morris
Theresa Musgrove
Roger Tichborne

One Barnet - The One Way Bet


The contract that Mr Mustard is about to tell you about was not a One Barnet contract but it doesn't matter because the same principles will apply.

Mr Mustard made a Freedom of Information request as follows:-

Please provide a copy of the contract signed with Enpeyz Consulting Ltd (in about March 2009)

Please also provide a list of all payments made to them as recorded on SAP showing the amount and date as far back as the record goes.

Here are the payments:

Date of Gross
Clearing Amount £
02/10/2009 3,881
01/10/2009 1,840
06/10/2009 1,409
24/12/2009 15,266
23/02/2010 2,080
25/02/2010 22,166
02/03/2010 925
22/03/2010 6,045
20/04/2010 8,061
20/04/2010 5,199
29/06/2010 1,040
29/06/2010 5,199
07/07/2010 2,015
08/07/2010 1,008
05/08/2010 10,399
02/11/2010 470
30/11/2010 8,319
13/12/2010 7,053
18/01/2011 6,239
09/03/2011 1,062
23/03/2011 15,435
06/04/2011 1,029
28/04/2011 4,248
Total 130,389

Two contracts were provided. One for the External Assessment of Financial Management Standard in Schools (FMSiS) and the other for the Internal Audit of Schools.

They are quite long so not published here but the bit that matters is that they were contracts which both started on 1 April 2009 until 31 March 2012 with a 2 year option to extend if both the council and Enpeyz agreed.

Two months later Mr Mustard made another FOI request:

Thank you for your answer. I have some new questions.
 
The two contracts that you have provided run until March 2012. Invoices stop in March 2011 ( per the over £500 lists).
 
Did Enpeyz provide the services in the year to 31 March 2012?
 
If not, who did, and provide a copy of their contract, of any delegated powers report which refers and details of when and where the opportunity to provide the financial services to schools was advertised.
 
If Enpeyz did provide the services, why are the payments not showing under their name in the over £500 lists?
 
Here is the answer.
 
The government abolished FMSiS in March 2011, the contractor Enpez (sic) notified the Council in May 2011 that due to the viability of the contract with the reduction of FMSiS and the movement of many schools to academy status that the contractor could no longer service the contract, it was agreed to mutually terminate the contract early.

The work was moved to the in-house team and as such there have been no further payments to an external agency.

So with a year to run on a three year contract the supplier is simply allowed to walk away (presumably without making any payment in compensation as it isn't mentioned and good news usually is) and in-house audit have to pick up extra work which will have taken them away from more urgent tasks like auditing One Barnet.

This was a small contract which the supplier bid for knowing that academies had existed since 2000 and that the government changes legislation all the time and this should have been priced into their bid. 

So the reward was taken for 2 years and then when the risk was too rich for the supplier they just walked away. 

Now think about One Barnet and the risks there will be over 10 years when £1bn is involved. Suppliers will fall over themselves to get rid of bits of the contract they don't like and it seems as if the senior management at Barnet Council will just let them.

Let us not hear any councillors in the future in council and committee meetings saying that the risk is passed to the supplier. It is passed back to the council. The supplier always has the ace in the hole.

Think about it councillors. Are you still sure this One Barnet nonsense is going to achieve what is being promised as savings.

In the dreadful shilly-shally words of Jay Mercer, the Deputy Director of Children's Services, at the Business & Management Overview & Scrutiny committee on 11 June 12 "It is an issue of terminology. An indicative target is only an estimate" (This was in relation to the number of free nursery places for 2 year olds where Cllr Harper was trying to claim that there wasn't a target and the council were only planning to make 500 places available instead of the 800 recommended by government - neither Harper nor Mercer covered themselves in glory on 11 June). 

If Jay Mercer is going to be delivering any One Barnet savings in the future the figures he comes out with won't be ones that we can rely on.

Mr Mustard has just remembered the phrase he keeps on seeing in One Barnet paperwork. "Aspirational Savings". If the potential suppliers are of the Mercer mould that means a number that they tell the council in order to make them sign up and which afterwards will only be an estimate that can be missed.

Think about this as well councillors. Have you given too much power to officers and hence to potential suppliers.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard