Showing posts with label wrong. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wrong. Show all posts

26 October 2025

Sodded about by Southwark Council


Mr Mustard's client wasn't in a lorry but parked here perhaps because she had before when it was ok. As always he checked the rules in case there was a technical problem. The rules are map based in Southwark as they are in many boroughs these days and didn't disclose a loading bay at the location and so he challenged the PCN

 


 


The informal challenge was rejected.


Note the absence of any consideration of the traffic order in the response, the sign must tell drivers what the rules are, it can't be installed without underlying rules.

The Notice to Owner was patiently awaited and the same grounds were put forward.


This was a clearer way of expressing the challenge.


Good news that the PCN was cancelled although that was nothing to do with goodwill, why would a council show goodwill to a car driver getting in the way of a lorry driver trying to go about his work? Most people would stop there but Mr Mustard isn't happy being spoon-fed a load of tosh. If the mapping is the traffic order it cannot be both right and wrong. Mr Mustard therefore dragged the FOI/EIR team into the case. It is handy that they have to reply as getting a reply from parking once a PCN is closed is hard work.


The reply came and referred him to the source he had seen.


'Streets' is not as good as 'Traffweb' which other boroughs use.

Back went Mr Mustard for a proper response.

More nonsense followed:


There are no words setting the rules for particular locations, they are on the map, so back Mr Mustard went asking the vital question:


 
An attempt to baffle Mr Mustard by introducing yet another map system which he hadn't looked at or mentioned. It didn't work:


See how calm Mr Mustard was in the face of being led a merry dance. He asked the central question afresh and asked a very closed, yes or no, question. Finally we got there.


So finally we know, the signs are wrong and will be replaced.

Now you know the value of persistence which runs through Mr Mustard.

if you worry about the discount this is a good example of why you shouldn't. Had the motorist paid up then the council would have enjoyed an unjust enrichment of £80 (the 50% rate) and so all motorists should be trying to work out at the earliest stage exactly what their chances are and then sticking it out until they are proved correct. In this case we didn't have to go as far as the tribunal perhaps because Southwark Council know Mr Mustard well from meeting and opposing him at the tribunal (the meetings folk are fair, just their back office colleagues who are a bit below par based on this case) so that did save some time. Southwark also saved themselves from wasting the 330 tribunal fee.

If you are correct, stand your ground.

The end. 


11 July 2025

Barking Council - wide of the mark

 


Barking & Dagenham Council got the law absolutely wrong in this case. 

They had already rejected a good challenge by the motorist at the PCN stage.

Mr Mustard stepped in at the Notice to Owner stage. He used the council's online system which asks standard irrelevant questions. Whoever sent the rejection did not know what they were doing. Loading/unloading and boarding/alighting are completely different concepts.

The kerb marks would probably have been found to be inadequate as they are not bright and there should be one every 3 metres or so, so that there is always one adjacent to the vehicle. 

Mr Mustard started an Appeal to the independent adjudicators at London Tribunals. Just before the case was due to be heard Barking threw in the towel and cancelled the PCN.

Mr Mustard is concerned that most motorists would believe what a council writes no matter how wrong.

Sadly there is no remedy within legislation which obliged a council which contravenes the Regulations to pay a penalty. There should be in order to improve the quality of processing of representations.

The end. 

24 December 2017

Blunders abound - updated, but not compensated

Although Mr Mustard is very busy working and really hasn't got the spare time for PCNs he can't leave wronged motorists without the necessary help.

A PCN was issued to a Scotsman for code 87: Parked in a designated disabled person's parking place without displaying a valid disabled person's badge in the prescribed manner. The photo above was taken by the traffic warden.

Although the clock is displayed and shows a time of about 11:05 it wasn't necessary to display it as blue badge holders park for fee all day in this car park. The gentleman in question had driven down from Scotland to visit his brother in Barnet General and then nipped up to the town centre where, after finding the PCN on his car, he was lucky to be spotted by a friend of Mr Mustard's on his way to band practice (he plays the tuba whereas traffic wardens just play the fiddle) who passed on the necessary mobile phone number.

The motorist has done nothing wrong, he has clearly displayed a valid blue badge the correct way up. Now he has to fight a PCN and make a charity donation for Mr Mustard's help so will be out of pocket even if the PCN gets cancelled the instant that Mr Mustard's complaint goes in.

Mr Mustard has seen more instances recently of complete lash ups by traffic wardens. Service really needs to improve as being wrongly threatened with a £110 penalty is not cricket. This is another example of an instance in which the motorist should automatically be compensated for the inconvenience.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Here is the council response: 


The arrival time does not appear to Mr Mustard to be wrong (and the council don't actually know the time of arrival) but what usually happens is that the traffic warden looks to see if the clock time is later than the current time & if it is assumes that the motorist was trying to gain extra minutes. The snag with that thought process, if indeed it is one rather than simply mechanical, is that the rules say you just have to set for the quarter hour within which you parked, so arriving at 11:01 you can properly set your clock for 11:14

Note that there is absolutely no mention of compensation. The council do not have to compensate you by law for their errors so the council won't pay any. Bah humbug. When PCN laws get refreshed Mr Mustard will be pushing for automatic fixed sum compensation for council errors.

24 December 2017

28 January 2016

The naughty London Borough of Waltham Forest

cute, unlike Waltham Forest council

Update 28 January 16.

Instead of sending me the FOI response Waltham Forest Council now expect Mr Mustard to go and fetch (like a dog, see above) his response CU127745 from a "MyAccount" that he doesn't have or want (Mr Mustard did look at setting one up but the council wanted his star sign, collar size and to know his favourite colour so he didn't complete the process) and they have clearly forgotten that they agreed to respond to him in writing i.e. by sending a letter. They could email it, that would be fine. They are back on the naughty step.

Councils everyhwere. Your duty is to send the response not to ask requestors to fetch it.



Update 11 January. Someone at Waltham Forest decided to accept Mr Mustard's request after all. Well done them. The council are now off the naughty step.


I acknowledge receipt of your request on 2 January 2016.

We are in the process of updating the procedures in regards to handling Freedom of Information requests which are not via our online portal.


I have logged your request under our reference number FOI 2016-0****.


In accordance with the Freedom of Information Act, the Council has 20 working days in which to respond to your request.  Therefore, a written response will be sent to you on or by 29 January 2016.


Second update: The complaint is also being dealt with. We are cooking with gas now.

We acknowledge receipt of your complaint which will be considered under Stage 1 of the Council’s Corporate Complaints Procedure. This has been passed on to the appropriate Service for investigation and response.

The Council will respond to you in writing within 20 working days from the date of receipt, in accordance with our complaints procedure.



Original blog post

The morning started well and then Mr Mustard received the below email in response to a simple request he made on 2 January:


From: Wfdirect [mailto:wfdirect@walthamforest.gov.uk]
Sent: 05 January 2016 09:01
To: Mr Mustard
Subject: RE: FOI request

Dear Mr Mustard

Thank you for your email

Please note we do not accept Freedom of Information request via email.


As Waltham Forest Council are now going digital Freedom of Information and Complaints can be done via www.walthamforest.gov.uk

Yours sincerely,

Name Redacted by Mr Mustard
Customer Service Advisor
London Borough Of Waltham Forest


Steam started to come out of Mr Mustard's ears. The council must know the law, and expect you to follow parking law exactly, but think they are above it. That, or they don't know the law. Mr Mustard is unsure as to which is worse. He had seen reference on twitter to Waltham Forest refusing requests and he doesn't take no for an answer, when it should be yes. He emailed back:



Dear Sir/Madam

I have seen mention on twitter of the borough's wrongful refusal of perfectly valid FOI requests. I have looked at your title and decided that you are a generalist and not a specialist in this area and so my ire is not aimed at you personally. You probably don't know this but even a request on twitter could be valid so one by email certainly is. I have attached a copy of the ICO's comprehensive guidance on the subject of recognising valid requests. As it is long I have extracted the relevant part here:

My request fits with the above.

I understand why you try and straitjacket people into using (ghastly) webforms, it is because it is cheaper for you to process and administratively convenient. I find that it is quicker for me to use an email as I can automatically add my personal details, I can file the email within my own file structure (and I may not even get a copy of a webform that I complete) and can add a follow-up date. What the borough has forgotten is that it is there to serve the residents and/or other interested parties.

I have now found the relevant page on the council's website (you didn't even give me a link to the relevant page but only to the site itself thus taking up more of my time) and the page gives me no option but to apply for a 'My Account' which I have no wish to have. You cannot put such hurdles in the path of a FOI request. You also insist on being supplied with an email address and I doubt that fits with the requirements of the Equality Act as the elderly and disabled may not possess or easily have access to a computer or smartphone and may well prefer to write a letter.

You now have on your desk not only a valid FOI request on which the clock is already ticking but a complaint that you are ignoring the law. I have therefore copied in the council's monitoring officer with a request that she ensures that the borough follows the law in future.

All I require in response to my complaint is an apology for wasting my time & misleading me, and an assurance that no-one else will be mislead on this subject in the future & that requests by twitter, email, letter or other written forms will be accepted without demur.

Best regards

Mr Mustard

Mr Mustard will let you know what happens next. He is currently making a ncie cup of camomile tea and taking one of his calm tablets.