Showing posts with label dnc. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dnc. Show all posts

23 November 2024

Islington - not everything was as it first appeared.

 

One of Mr Mustard's regulars is a heating engineer. Despite being from Enfield, and also notwithstanding the extra £10 per hour or part thereof, Harry (not his real name) is still prepared to drive up his diesel van up to Islington. Naturally he asks his customer to arrange parking rights if they are willing (they may be a tenant so they may not have an account or may not think it is their responsibility) and if they can't he then pays to park. This can take a few minutes and in that time a traffic warden inevitably arrives.

In this case the PCN didn't make it off Harry's dashboard, a veritable paperwork graveyard, in time to challenge with the discount still intact. In such a situation Mr Mustard fights to the end even if he thinks he doesn't have a prayer. Mr Mustard would need to be frivolous, vexatious or wholly unreasonable in order to have costs awarded against him. They are rarely awarded and in this case the PCN had a wording error in that the 28 days quoted should refer to the date of the alleged contravention and not the date of service which was an argument that held sway at first and then adjudicators changed their minds.

Once the Notice to Owner dated 22 January 24 arrived Mr Mustard made the formal representations (as they are known, it is simply a challenge made at the correct time). His representation was the sign and the traffic order differed. He relied on a decision he had himself obtained against Barnet Council, that the traffic order did contain a tariff for the location in question.


 

Needless to say, Islington Council rejected the contention.

It is irrelevant whether or not the decision relied on was for the same road or a different one or whether it is for Islington Council or another one. It is the case that tribunal decisions are not precedents as they are 'legally persuasive'. What they means is that the council should look at the factual matrix of the decision and compare it to the facts in their case and decide the extent to which they are on 'all fours'. The failure to do so was, in Mr Mustard's opinion a procedural impropriety i.e. a failure to consider the representations which is a statutory duty. Mr Mustard often wins on procedural error.
 
The error which Islington made was to not offer the discount as at this stage Mr Mustard had quite a weak hand but there was nothing to lose by bluffing it out. Not offering the discount at this stage when it isn't obligatory is a growing trend that Mr Mustard has noticed.

Mr Mustard duly started an Appeal at London Tribunals. That is free for the motorist but costs the council the thick end of £30. Only 1% of PCNs end up at the tribunal. Mr Mustard would like to see that percentage rise radically.
Mr Mustard doesn't mince his words at Appeal.

Mr Chan is now the Chief Adjudicator so you would expect his decisions to be given careful consideration by other adjudicators.

The Appeal was started on 26 February with an in-person hearing date of 28 March. Islington served the Evidence Pack, which contains the arguments of both sides, on 19 March.

There was more nonsense in the council's case summary:

The next paragraph in the Case Summary piqued the interest of Mr Mustard

What this means is that in Islington if you pay for location 61095 and you should have paid for 61059 but they are both within zone A then you are not in breach of the requirement to pay. People often pay for the next bay along or the one opposite and in Islington 99% of the time that will be OK.

At this point a curve ball arrived. Mr Mustard asked Harry for his payment records for the day in question. They disclosed that on the day in question Harry had paid for parking in Hardwick Street (and as it happens for the correct bay number) and it has expired at 10:32 am. He had paid for a mere 10 minutes of parking but that gives you 20 minutes as thanks to the Right Honourable Eric Pickles MP as he was at the time (now Lord Pickles) a payment of 10 minutes leads to an extra period of 10 minutes when a PCN cannot be issued.

If you look back to the start of the blog the PCN was issued at 14:05. The PCN was for not paying. The actual contravention which had occurred was staying beyond paid for time. Mr Mustard had a little laugh to himself, he had been on the high wire and he was saved, the traffic warden had blundered. Mr Mustard wonders if the hand held equipment of the traffic warden simply does not show expired payments? The evidence pack suggested that the traffic warden only checked for payments from 1:29 when he first observed the van.

Mr Mustard filed a preliminary argument on 22 March. Adjudicators probably quite like these as if they are correct they can ignore everything on the file and Allow the Appeal, thus cancelling the PCN, without having to study the typical 100 pages of evidence.

Islington Council saw the writing was on the wall and took the very rare decision, after they had done all of the work to produce the Evidence Pack of cancelling the PCN which thus vacated the hearing.

Mr Mustard learnt a lot from this case.

The end.

23 June 2017

Seven to One

OK, this is 15 but you get the idea
It is the norm for new Appeals to be listed at the tribunal 4 weeks after you submit the Notice of Appeal form. For administrative convenience all of Mr Mustard's cases are listed together so that they can be disposed of with the minimum amount of the tribunal's, and Mr Mustard's time, being taken. It is Mr Mustard's duty, as a professional lay representative (an oxymoron) to assist the tribunal to come to the just decision. Of course, both sides will stress the positive parts of their case and play down the negative aspects but the adjudicator knows and levels up the playing field. If the enforcement authority do not appear he tests arguments they would have made.

Four weeks ago Mr Mustard submitted 7 new Appeals all together in a batch, 2 for TfL and 5 for Barnet Council. A week before if he hasn't received an evidence bundle Mr Mustard goes looking for it and checks the balance on the council computer to see if it has gone to zero. Usually one or two cases get discontinued by enforcement authorities who are either too busy to prepare their case or recognise that it is hopeless, although if that is the reason they should have thrown in the towel at an earlier stage rather than incur a £30 tribunal fee.

Although Mr Mustard had two evidence packs to hand, he ended up with only one live hearing (and a Review, i.e. a second go at the cherry which Mr Mustard had asked for so was always going to go ahead, although he did not get granted a Review in the end, but that is a story for another day).

So here are Mr Mustard's thoughts on the 7 cases.

PCN1

Barnet Council had forgotten to re-offer the 50% discount in response to a challenge made to the PCN on day 14. That was a nailed on win so the council sensibly cancelled the PCN. Just so you know, if a PCN is issued on 10 June, day 14 is 23 June i.e. add 13 not 14 as the day of issue is day 1.

PCN2

The motorist had driven away the instant he saw the traffic warden and had been sent a PCN in the post. It was fairly certain that the traffic warden would have been held to have only observed and not to have started preparing a PCN. The council cancelled.

PCN3

The motorist had paid but not displayed. The alleged contravention was that he had failed to pay. That was an arguable point but the council decided to cancel.

PCN4

TfL issued a PCN which had a poor description of the location where the PCN was issued. If you do not get the PCN and have to rely on a document which comes in the post then the PCN falls at the first hurdle for lack of clarity. TfL sensibly cancelled when the Appeal was logged. They often do. They have of course tried it on earlier by rejecting the identical representations.

PCN5

TfL had probably had the PCN back in the post undelivered, a fact which they didn't want aired in public, so they cancelled.

PCN6

In this case Barnet Council had made a blunder within their evidence pack, no wonder when they can run to 100 pages, and once that was pointed out to management they cancelled the PCN. Fair play to them.

PCN7

The only case to actually have a hearing. It concerned a motorist turning right out of Oak Grove into Cricklewood Lane. The analysis of the actual Regulations about when you can turn right into a box junction are interesting and Mr Mustard did not have his copy of them to hand so couldn't argue the point, he will have another go on another day:

The PCN was cancelled though because within the Notice of Rejection it does not (currently) say that the tribunal may allow more than 28 days to make your Appeal if there is a good reason (like being hospitalised perhaps) even though it does say that in the notes which come with the letter. Mr Mustard still recommends that you make your Appeal in good time and if you use the on line system it only takes 5 minutes. 

Within the 28 days either pay up or Appeal, do not do nothing as that costs you 50%

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

11 May 2014

Hold on a minute

Each month or so the Barnet Council parking department thin client side has a meeting with NSL, the enforcement contractor. The Internal Audit department has recently criticised the minutes as being insufficiently detailed, a view with which Mr Mustard concurs. He did wonder if it was because of him that the minutes were left a bit vague as he would pick up all the processing errors from the minutes and use them to get Appeals granted.

Mr Mustard has never thought that having a "thin" client side was a good idea. If you have a contractor you need to monitor them closely as otherwise it is possible they will take the wotsit and not perform in accordance with the contract.

NSL's performance at PATAS, the Parking & Traffic Appeals Services, has been lamentable at best and hilarious at worst and one adjudicator has simply said to Mr Mustard, after he gave one of their Evidence Packs a going over that led to a rapid cancellation of the PCN, "well, that is typical Barnet for you". Mr Mustard also sees Evidence Packs and the processing skills of other boroughs and NSL Barnet are certainly in the relegation play-offs.

In the pack of minutes for 2013 which Mr Mustard asked for in one of his nowadays rare Freedom of Information requests (only one official request this year with some other PCN representations wrongly being turned into FOI) was the following page which supposedly shows an average performance at PATAS (as your first argument in response to a PCN is an informal Challenge, the second in response to the Notice to Owner are your formal Representations and finally your third bite at the cherry is your Appeal to an adjudicator at PATAS).

If these statistics were correct this would be an acceptable level of performance.

DNC means Do not Contest and is when, even though the council might have turned down your informal challenge and your formal representations once they know that an independent adjudicator is going to look at the case that they think they will lose (or they have too many cases to prepare) and throw in the towel. What this tells you is that persistence pays. When the council tell you you were in the wrong, it doesn't mean that you were.The average London-wide DNC rate is 20% with the City topping the table at 40% and Enfield only giving up 7% of the time ( figures from 2012-13).

The won  / lost numbers are usually about the same so well done NSL, but 

Mr Mustard doesn't, based on many years of experience, trust statistics which help the party who produced them so he checked two days at random. Here is 17 December 12:

There were only 10 cases decided that day, not 24. Mr Mustard thought that was odd, so he checked another day, the 10 January 13, and here from the PATAS website, are the real numbers:



Mr Mustard sees nine Allowed Appeals (i.e. nine PCN were cancelled) and none were refused. Where those seven Refused Appeals got to that NSL are claiming is anybody's guess.

Mr Mustard thinks that the newly appointed Parking Manager will be looking much more closely at statistics from NSL from now on, especially as Mr Mustard will be looking over his shoulder at them. Mr Mustard does hope that no KPI payments were based upon false statistics.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

N.B. It is possible that Mr Mustard has got hold of the wrong end of the stick and that the date column when used by NSL is the date that they were notified of an Appeal and what the eventual outcome was (which would all be on differing dates) although those are much harder statistics to track.