4 July 2012

At One with the Barnet One

Helen Michael is on the left

It is hard to separate Nick Walkley the Returning Officer, from Nick Walkley the Chief Executive of Barnet Council, especially as he swans around in one of the mayoral jaguars come election time and uses Barnet Council staff to organise the polling stations and carry out the count. It must be about time that the Electoral Commission thought about the wisdom of getting independent people to deal with voting rather than ones who are so close to local politics.

Who knows if it was Nick's own idea to call the police in to closely question Helen Michael of Cafe Buzz ( aka the Barnet One ) or if a local councillor has made a robust suggestion to him but the fact is that the problem with the poster was minor and immediately rectified once realised.

Mr Mustard knows what it is like to be on the receiving end of silly behaviour by pettifogging bureaucrats as one of his evenings got ruined when he was at a foreign racetrack and instead of enjoying a beer in the bar he had to deal with the £40,000 argument about the cost of Freedom of Information Requests and his non-registration under the Data Protection Act, an act under which bloggers do not need to register. A fat lot of good that strategy did Barnet Council, as they have since found out, with Mr Mustard having to continue to put in regular FOI requests as Barnet Council are as open and transparent now as they were a year ago i.e. hardly at all.

You have to question the value of employing Chris Palmer, as the Assistant Director of Communications, who has the hopeless task of trying to make Barnet Council look good. It's an impossible job and even if he were the most brilliant communicator in the land (not that Mr Mustard is claiming that he is!) to pay an agency (Hays, but that is just a conduit to his own company) £504 a day for turd polishing can only be an utter waste of money.

You also have to think that Barnet Council were not really very strategic when they shopped Mr Mustard to the Information Commissioner as if he had needed to register he would have done so and that would have killed the complaint. Moreover, to go on the offensive against a debt collector of 25 years standing without considering that he might therefore have a backbone and been through a few legal battles in his time was not very bright.

The same lack of thought is evident now. Helen Michael is a popular lady and well respected by the other traders in North Finchley. She is a lady who makes her mind up and knows what is right and wrong and has a kind heart as she has donated some of her takings to help Mencap keep their juice bar going. She has worked hard for years to build up a good business and does not want to see her efforts ruined by a radical, ill-conceived, badly implemented and unworkable parking policy that no-one voted for in May 2010 as it wasn't in the manifesto. She will be no easier a pushover than Mr Mustard was and just as Mr Mustard was supported by the other Barnet Bloggers, David Hencke, Private Eye etc. the Barnet Bloggers and other Barnet organisations are flocking to support her. Mr Mustard has his cheque book ready should the need arise.

Here are links to the other local bloggers' posts about Helen.




 
If you are off out shopping or even just passing through North Finchley (just north of Tally Ho) do call in and buy a tea or coffee and cake or maybe have lunch. You will not be disappointed.

Yours frugally (but generous to his friends)

Mr Mustard

Not a spoof, Roger

be prepared
Oh dear Roger, you wrote a spoof weekly message from Nick Walkley in the Barnet Eye blog and it turns out that truth is stranger than fiction:-

Make sure you’re prepared for the Olympics

Monday, 02 July 2012 15:11 Schroder, Johnathan
 
England were knocked out of Euro 2012 at the quarter final stage and expectation levels for Andy Murray to win Wimbledon are low, but there is still reason this year for some sporting anticipation as the opening ceremony of the London Olympics is now less than four weeks away.
 
As mentioned previously in First Team, it is vitally important that all leave plans for the Olympic and Paralympic period are well planned in advance by staff and managers to ensure that the council can continue to deliver excellent services throughout the period.
 
Ensuring that business continuity plans are in place, up to date and tested was the aim of a recent ‘desktop exercise’ to test the council’s Olympic preparedness. Managers are advised to check their plans are watertight prior to the Games, so that the council is able to continue functioning no matter what.
 
Staff who are planning to continue working throughout the Games period should also be aware of the large increases in traffic expected as a result of the Olympics and the potential impact of many more people using London’s public transport systems and ensure they leave plenty of time to get to work, particularly if they need to travel through East London. Transport for London (TfL) have set up a website entitled www.getaheadofthegames.com which gives a lot of helpful advice to people planning to travel during the Olympics.
 
Two days prior to the big kick-off on 27 July, though, Barnet will greet the Olympic Torch and it will pass within less than a mile of NLBP. Staff will be allowed to leave the office to watch this once-in-a-lifetime event but managers will be expected to ensure that frontline services continue to operate throughout the day. More information on when and where the torch will be will be shared through First Team later in July.
 
Kate Solomon, Emergency Planning Manager, said: “The desktop exercise which we ran at the end of June highlighted some of the key considerations that managers across our departments need to be thinking about in the run-up to the start of the Olympics.
 
“Business continuity plans not only need to be in place for each service area, but should include contingency plans for any eventuality arising out of potential incidents, be thoroughly tried and tested, and be owned and understood by staff and managers alike to ensure everyone is aware of their roles and responsibilities. We need to expect the expected and the unexpected and respond to both with equal effectiveness and efficiency."

Right first time - a fine theory



Look out for the launch of the customer care standards

Monday, 02 July 2012 15:23 Schroder, Johnathan

Over the past few months you will have seen posters and desktop messages about how all staff are expected to ‘think customer’ in their day to day jobs, and today sees the launch of the refreshed customer care standards which will provide the next level of detail. This morning, every work station had a booklet and business card placed on it setting out the council’s expectations related to customer service. This should provide a model for the work every member of staff does – whether liaising with our customers by email, post, phone, face to face and increasingly, we hope, via the new website. There are new guidelines for home visits and 'out and about' which will provide new guidance for some of our staff and contracted partners. (That would be "workstation" then.)

Throughout the council, the customer is continuing to be placed at the centre of everything we do. Work continues in every service to make them more customer-centric prior to the introduction of the ‘New Customer Service Organisation’ in 2013 through a partnership with either BT or Capita. Placed at the centre of everything we do which is why 99% of them have never heard of "One Barnet".

The literature also sets out new expectations when handling member enquiries and complaints.
Monika Singh, Head of Customer Service Transformation, said:
“Step by step, we are introducing changes that will make a real difference to our customers, and demonstrate that the council is ‘thinking customer’ in everything it does from the start of a customer transaction, all the way through to the end when the service has been provided. Its not just about how quickly we pick up the phone or see someone any more (although of course that still matters), but also how we speak to customers and how well we actually deliver on any promises we make. It's "it's" not "its" you illiterate. ("close quotes were missing from this section)

“The customer care standards are there to provide a framework and clear guidance for all our staff about what is expected when they serve Barnet Council's residents and other customers. We want our customers to get a consistently excellent service every time they contact us, and from whoever they choose to contact. I hope everyone finds the time to read them and consider how they can be put into practice in their day-to-day jobs.” 










Mr Mustard knows a lot of staff at Barnet Council. They feel insulted by this booklet full of baloney. They already know how to give good customer service and how to speak to customers. Surely it would have been better to take the small percentage of staff whose skills could be improved upon and give one-to-one training to them. Isn't that the job of their line managers?

Stand by in FOI. There is an incoming question about the cost of this rubbish. The answer was £876

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

3 July 2012

Diary date - 7 July 2012

I'm not for sale
 Barnet Council Not for Sale Conference  
Saturday 7 July 2012.

Barnet UNISON in partnership with Barnet Alliance for Public Services are hosting a conference on the mass privatisation of Barnet council services this Saturday 7 July 12- 3 pm at the Greek Cypriot Centre, Britannia Road, North Finchley, London N12 9RU

The Council is attempting to become a Commissioning Council whereby it no longer delivers council services. In the last few months Barnet Council has already transferred the following staff and services out of the council to new employers

· Social Care services for adults with disabilities

· Housing Needs & Resources

· Parking services

· All of the Legal Department * (talks on the transfer of staff to Harrow Council are still ongoing)

By the end of May 2013 up to 70% of the council workforce will no longer be working for the Council.

The aim of the conference is to provide information about the scale of risk to the council tax payers of Barnet. The conference will be in two parts.

Part One speakers include:

Professor Dexter Whitfield European Services Strategy Unit (ESSU) recently published a report on the cost and consequences of the Commissioning Council.

Andy Mudd from the well-respected local government research body the Association for Public Service Excellence (APSE) published a report warning that over the past few years those at the north London Council involved in the awarding and managing of contracts to private contractors, have often ignored both council guidelines and UK competition law.

John Dix resident, one of the infamous Barnet Bloggers recently reported the Council has agreed another £10million be allocated to consultants to deliver the outsourcing One Barnet Programme

The second part of the meeting will include speakers from Aberdeen UNISON, and Edinburgh UNISON. Both of these councils recently decided not to go ahead with outsourcing after taking part in lengthy procurement discussions with a number of private sector contractors. A speaker from Sefton UNISON will talk about why Sefton Council decided to terminate their contract early with Capita Symonds. Capita Symonds is one of the Bidders for one the One Barnet projects.

John Burgess, Branch Secretary UNISON said “We are continuing to seek a meeting with councillors in particular the members of the Cabinet Committee regarding our concerns about the One Barnet Programme. We know from experience that once residents are made aware of One Barnet they are very concerned about the implications. This conference is just one part of a widespread community campaign to bring public scrutiny to the One Barnet experiment.”

Parking ticket - Notice to owner - PATAS


Appealing against a parking ticket can be a question of gimme three steps.

Step 1 is that you send what is an informal request to the council to say why you think the ticket should be cancelled.

If the council agree the ticket is wrong or that you have acceptable mitigating circumstances they will cancel it.

If they don't cancel then they send you the Notice to Owner which is the start of Step 2 at which point you submit your formal request for the ticket to be cancelled. This is a good time to think about using an expert such as appealnow.com whose charges are quite modest and this is the point when you should advance every single reason that you have for the ticket to be cancelled and the more the merrier provided they are serious reasons with a chance of success. If the ticket is cancelled, all well and good. If not, then the guidance from the Department of Transport (DoT) says this:

If the authority rejects the representation, it must serve a notice of rejection (NoR) stating that it will issue a Charge Certificate unless the PCN is paid or an appeal made to an adjudicator. The notice of rejection must set out the general form and manner in which an appeal can be made (to PATAS) and that the adjudicator has the power to award costs against either party. The authority should give the owner clear and full reasons for its decision on a representation, in addition to the minimum required information. (There are rarely costs awarded either for or against)

So step 3 will be your appeal to PATAS.

People generally don't have much staying power and tend to give in and either pay or bury their head in the sand and hope the whole thing goes away although the latter could become an expensive strategy. 

Mr Mustard isn't the giving in type and would always continue to step 3 except that he always parks legally and any tickets he gets are usually caused by error and so his step 1 appeals have always been accepted (and those he has done on behalf of other people). Please people start to plan for writing 3 appeals and stick with the process. You stand a good chance of getting the ticket cancelled (if you aren't bang to rights).

The DoT guidance says that the formal representations at Step 2 must be dealt with by the local authority i.e. Barnet Council. Mr Mustard has heard that they are not being and that the but he doubts that the council would be so stupid as to sidestep official guidance. To check he needs to see a copy of a letter sent out which has rejected your formal representations which you sent in after receiving the Notice to Owner. It would also be useful to see a copy of the letter before that one in which NSL rejected your informal representations because Mr Mustard wants to see if you were then told to write to Worthing (where NSL are ) which would add delay to the process or to London N11 where the council are which would not waste any of your 28 day appeal period. He would also like to see both envelopes. 

Mr Mustard also hears that people are not being told of their step 3 right of appeal to PATAS and if that is true (surely it cannot be true?) then every single parking ticket issued since 1 May should rightly & fairly be cancelled because of procedural impropriety.

So if you are a well organised person (or company) who keeps all their correspondence and is happy to share your experiences with Mr Mustard (and the world, with permission, on a no names basis) then please send an email to mrmustard@zoho.com

Only by persisting and following the rules (steps) can you win.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

2 July 2012

Parking Enforcement Policy

Conference programme

Before Mr Mustard tells you about enforcement policy in Barnet he wants to bring to your attention the 6th annual Enforcement Summit which you can get the details of by clicking on the Conference Programme link about. It is very interesting; the point of the programme is to improve enforcement i.e. screw more money out of the motorist but to be fair to the organisers there are sessions that look at this from the motorists perspective although not presented by a member of the public such as a travelling salesman which Mr Mustard would suggest is an idea the conference organisers could consider for next year.

Now to the main event. How Barnet Council enforce, in Mr Mustard's words (many less than the council use).

Funerals

Unlawful parking will not be condoned but patrols will be sent elsewhere unless someone complains in which case enforcement will take place. No concession available on a key route (where of course many churches will be located).

Mr Mustard doesn't like this arrangement. So if some miserable bugger lives next door and reports your funeral cortege as causing a parking problem then a traffic warden will pop round. This is an insensitive way of going on. Why not instruct parking wardens that any car with a photocopy of the Order of Service in the dashboard can be ignored on that day? The organiser of the service just needs to print twice as many copies.

Religious days

Unlawful parking on yellow lines will not be condoned but wrongful parking in marked bays will be allowed. Patrols will be sent elsewhere unless someone complains in which case enforcement will take place. 

As Religious days are not defined this is rather an unclear policy. It would probably be better to have a list of all religious dates of every religion and specify the streets in which enforcement will not take place and put signs up which the local religious establishments could be supplied with and put up and take down on the day. Big society in action and absolute clarity for the public because lack of clarity can lead to a £110 fine. Feel free to debate this idea in the comment box.

Schools

Mr Mustard didn't know but at school start time and end time (a moveable feast in some schools with after school events) you can park for 10 minutes in residential or a pay and display bay. 

What strikes Mr Mustard as odd about this is that during the clampdown last year on parking on the school zig-zags the council didn't mention this commonsense solution and instead deliberately sent traffic wardens to schools to issue tickets. If you have paid a parking ticket for this offence write to the council for your money back. If you email mrmustard@zoho.com he will provide you with a copy of the policy document that the council supplied him with under FOI.

North Side Junior School are allowed to use the lodge lane car park. This policy could be extended to every other school near a car park?

Bo-Peep and Alyth nurseries have their own identifier to permit them to park nearby. If these two nurseries have a concession shouldn't every other nursery?

Footway parking

If you park on the footway (footpath) inside a CPZ you will get a parking ticket unless you are unloading and are observed doing so (Mr Mustard thinks that delivery vehicles are the last ones that should be allowed on pavements as they are the heaviest and cause the most damage)

Outside a CPZ enforcement will only take place if it has been enforced in the last 3 months. If it is more than 3 months ago a local councillor will be consulted (which will lead to a postcode lottery).

Mr Mustard hopes that he has been of assistance.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

1 July 2012

Brum notes

This is much more interesting than Nick's message. A canal in Brum.

From: First Team
Sent: 29 June 2012 14:59
To: AllStaff
Subject: Weekly message from the Chief Executive

I was in Birmingham for part of this week attending the Local Government Association (LGA) Conference. The overriding message of the conference was that local government faces an extended period of budget reductions and increasing demand. The LGA has set out its cross-party view on what this means and much of it will be familiar to those of you who have attended a budget briefing here in Barnet in the past couple of years.

Not all was doom and gloom although this was not an 'upbeat' conference. There seemed to be three responses which councils from across the country were exploring that go beyond the efficiency agenda we are all familiar with.

Firstly, the troubled families programme and finding new ways to ensure young people do not end up in cycles of deprivation and high demand on local services. As you know, Barnet is recognised nationally for its work in this field but, as the director of the national programme said, we have to move from small 'boutique' projects to mainstream authority. The strategic review of early intervention work needs to set its sights on delivering exactly that.

Secondly, that our growing elderly population must be seen as an opportunity. Engaging these citizens in using their skills and experience to support others delivers for the individual and for communities. Roger at the Barnet Eye was unimpressed with the grab-a-granny type sentiments being expressed here. Doubtless the message was meant to be that older people who have perhaps gone part-time can contribute to help younger people or the disadvantaged by dint of their age and experience but the use of the word "opportunity" is crass. Mr Mustard thinks that Big Society will only get us so far and one reason we pay so many taxes and charitable donations is to provide a safety net for the good of society. If one has to work less in order to volunteer more then one's income is less and thus you pay less tax and have less spare money for charity. There is a limit which might well be reached.

Finally, that councils have a key role to play in promoting the economic growth that ensure the UK economy begins to improve. The council took its first significant steps in this area, agreeing a Skills and Enterprise Action Plan last week. There is a £1million package to support local business and help young Barnet residents back into work. Of the £1m administration will swallow £120,000 and Brent X are getting £150,000 to provide retail training which they could easily fund out of the millions they must make themselves. If we go back to the year ended 31 March 2011, before Brian Coleman went wild with parking charges increases, the annual income from pay & display was £2,109,547 and so £1m put towards reducing parking charges in the High Streets could make a vast difference to local businesses and then jobs would flow without Barnet Council and their various schemes. Councils are not business experts so should leave businesses to run themselves without hundreds of committees. The council are now trying to fix the problem that they caused. Less state interference would be better. 

Guidance for businesses wishing to access the scheme is available on our new web page for business. However, I want to encourage all staff to get involved in signposting local businesses they know to the proposals as we look to significantly improve our business engagement. It would have been helpful if a link had been provided. How many businesses in Barnet do you suppose actually look at the council website?  Here is the link. There you go Nick, Mr Mustard has probably doubled the readership for you.

Nick