Helping the mentally or physically ill, the elderly & the poor to fight Council PCNs.
Writing about blunders, democracy and profligacy at Barnet Council.
Mr Mustard has blogged previously about the message that you get when you email the Council tax section (Revs & Bens as it is known)
The auto-acknowledgement is still the same as it was 2 months ago..
Thank you for your email enquiry to the London Borough of Barnet Council Tax Team. Clear and polite.
Following the issue of council tax bills for the new financial year, which were issued at the end of March and in early April we are currently experiencing a high volume of enquiries what,still, in June? and may be unable to deal with your email within our normal 10 working days very true. We will respond to you as soon as possible and apologise in advance for any delay.Again very polite but no substitute for an answer.
Information about Council Tax can be found on our website at http://www.barnet.gov.uk/council-taxPlease go away and answer your own question even though it is not your area of expertise, it is ours.
Payments can also be made on line at http://www.barnet.gov.uk/payIt is very unlikely that the email sent in was "how do I pay" as it tells you on the bill.
Please remember to always quote your Council Tax account reference number in the subject line of all further emails to assist in speeding up a response.One would hope that everyone does this. Unfortunately the council rarely quote my reference when they write to me. Why not?
Make life easier – pay your Council Tax by Direct Debit Make the council's life easier, paying by direct debit can easily mess yours up. If you let the council help themselves when you like and why they like the possibility of you paying something that you don't owe is increased. At this very moment Mr Mustard has his account for the empty property he is still refurbishing (decided as no-one was showing any signs of buying at the right price to get rid of the horrible Everest double glazed windows and fit double glazed sash in wood made and installed by local firms - one makes and one fits) under query and if he paid by direct debit he would probably have had some instalments collected that Mr Mustard does not think are due. As soon as he is satisfied he will pay the account.
What has gone wrong this year? Last year it was the enforced change of software which led to some people being billed twice (including those who pay by direct debit) and this year it is the fault of senior management who have decided upon a massive reorganisation of One Barnet when they don't really know what they are playing with. They "let go" the expert who has kept the service running run for years, Dave Sharpe, when he was exactly the man they needed, the staff respected him (they tell Mr Mustard) and they are pushing staff who don't want to go there into a call centre. Staff are already slowly starting to leave as they find other posts. I am sure that all of the surrounding local authorities will be keen to take the Barnet employees who have performed so well.
Mr Mustard predicts that the March 2013 statistics for council tax recovery will be worse than for March 2012 and he can already hear the twistometer being cranked into life and excuses about the recession being lined up. Bill Murphy and John Gregson and all the other town hall tax dodgers and consultant cronies will be well up the road by then ruining another high performing council somewhere else but don't worry as Mr Mustard will make sure news of your failings follows you to the next council.
Mr Mustard's alter ego will be writing to say no thank you to the proposed borough wide ban. The questions that are being asked in the survey, and there is no need to use surveymonkey and give your data to some company in America - you can simply email to this stupidly long, out of date, e&o? email address
are as follows:
The Council would like to understand the views of the community before deciding whether to proceed with the proposals. Please therefore help us by answering the following questions and by explaining why you either agree or disagree.
1. What is your opinion of the proposal to introduce a borough wide Designated Public Place Order?
I am in favour of the proposal
I am against the proposal
I don't know
2. Please provide an explanation for your choice:
Please respond to the following questions so that we can analyse the results of the survey on area basis.
3. Are you...? (you can choose more than one option)
a London Borough of Barnet resident
a Business Owner
an owner of a Licensed Premise
a representative of a Community/Voluntary/Faith Group
a non-borough resident who works in Barnet
Other (please specify)
2. What are the first three digits of your postcode?
Mr Mustard's alter ego will be responding as follows:
1. The borough wide Order is not necessary so he is against
2. You can't trust officials to enforce sensibly
3. It is not enforceable anyway
4. It doesn't fix the problem
Let us look at the DPR itself using the same section numbers.
2.2 One must assume that the priorities are to tackle the 3 listed priorities - the report reads like they are being promoted.
This paragraph also says that "appropriate support pathways" have to be in place. What are they? - there is no detail about them.
3.1 The report as good as says that the police won't be able to enforce this drinking in public ban.
3.2 The council's response to the problem of public drinking must be proportionate. It isn't.
4.1 this sets out the real problem. These poor people will not be helped in any way by a borough wide ban on street drinking. There is absolutely no detail about the extra support which will supposedly be offered and the report is defeatist in this regard.
5.1 One would think that £12,500 would go a long way to helping a small number of people get back on their feet. Even if it only changed the life of one problem drinker it would be money well spent.
6.2 The proposed response is not proportionate. One can be pretty sure that before long a family enjoying a picnic in the park with a glass of wine will be targeted.
8.1.1 There is not a borough wide nuisance of the type required for this measure to be introduced. It is a very bad idea.
8.1.6 Enfield and Haringey manage without borough wide Orders so perhaps Barnet should learn from them. The administrative problems that Police response teams have should not be used to support this Order, they should sort themselves out.
8.1.7 More selective statistics doubtless.
8.2.1 What about the figures for 2011/12?
8.2.2 Data presented that cannot be relied upon.
8.2.4 There are supposedly a population of only 84 street drinkers in the whole of Barnet and thus legislation affecting 300,000 is proposed. Disproportionate or what? Mr Mustard lives 100m from the Spires. There is not a group of "up to 5" urinating and intimidating people there. The report is just gossip and conjecture.
8.2.5 Enforcement across the whole borough will be impossible. The size of the SNTs has been reduced recently.
8.3.1 So what? It is perception not reality.
8.3.2 Were there any actual events to support these views?
8.3.3 There are less drunks in Barnet than the London average.
8.4.1 This table shows that DPPO make no difference. Two areas got worse and two got better in a year.
8.4.4 The statistics in this paragraph are incomplete and not easily compared. One would really like to see the figures for a 5 year period starting before the introduction of the DPPO to properly measure its effect, if any.
8.4.5 This is not important. What is important is whether they work or not.
8.4.6 The council is unlikely to find that an Order it introduced was wrong.
8.5.3 If this Order goes ahead that is going to be an awful lot of signs polluting the borough.
8.5.5 Don't stand outside the pub enjoying a beer is the simple translation of this section.
8.6.1 No problem drinker will stop drinking because this Order is made.
8.6.2 Why are we extending the ambit when the existing Orders are inconclusive?
8.6.3 Much more effort needs to be put into fixing the underlying problem.
8.6.4 The million dollar question. Is there the resource for enforcement in a borough as big as Barnet?
10.1 Mr Mustard is finding it hard to take this report seriously given that it is agreed by the Cabinet Member for Safety and Resident Engagement. Who is that? It is the actor, David Longstaff (what made the residents of High Barnet think that a small time actor would be a suitable person for the serious business of being a councillor?). Take a look at his showreel here which will be 5m 37s of your life utterly wasted.
Why does an actor who is happy to make money by playing a drunken elf think he has the right to stop anyone else having a harmless tipple on the streets of Barnet?
Why Mr Mustard is against the proposals
1. Not necessary.
The police already have powers to deal with drunkenness, see here so this disproportionately large borough wide zone is not needed.
2. You can't trust officials to enforce sensibly
There are lots of public servants who do a good job but the number who get carried away with their own importance and lose all common sense is huge. Here are a few examples, click each one to see the whole story.
If you want to see some jobsworths in action this film by Rod Liddle about CCTV certainly contains them. Barnet say that a family enjoying a picnic with a glass of wine are not intended to be disrupted but a family with a windbreak already has been.
3. Lack of resources to enforce
There won't be enough resource to enforce it as they have found in neighbouring Brent, as this report shows.
4. It doesn't help the problem drinker.
For 5 years Mr Mustard helped out at the Crisis at Christmas shelters. He saw the problems of the homeless and some of them drank too much. How will passing this law which will be an ever present threat to 300,000 residents help the 84 people who are listed as problem drinkers. It won't help them in any way. This proposal should be filed in the stupid ideas drawer and the £12,500 thus not spent used to directly and positively help as many of the street drinking population as possible.
Do you remember Mr Cornelius your article in the local paper which talked about interference in our lives by Europe? You are not keen on Europe interfering in how the council is run especially in the area of procurement (where it happens to be very poor) so if you support the council interfering in the general public's behaviour, and there will be some stupid interference, you will have to look yourself in the mirror and ask "Am I the pettifogging bureaucrat who allowed a borough wide alcohol consumption ban to come into force".
Action needed
Please write to the council, or email them, saying we do not want a borough wide ban but we do want help for troubled drinkers (Barnet Council are always banging on about targeted support for troubled families but this isn't an example of it).
Update 8.30pm
Cllr Robert Rams has kindly retweeted this superb story of council (& police aided) idiocy to highlight why giving Town Hall pravdas (copyright, Eric Pickles MP) any power at all over us is such a bad idea.
Mr Mustard has received unprintable comments with this weekly message and he does tend to agree that it is possibly the most amazing weekly message that he has even seen.
.
.
.
.
.
.
amazingly awful, that is. The blog isn't read so much on a weekend so let Mr Mustard spare his readers and get this message out of the way.
From: First Team
Sent: 15 June 2012 10:57
To: AllStaff
Subject: Weekly message
Nick has asked me to do the weekly message as this will be my last week in Barnet for the next year or so.
One of the best things about being a Director of Children's Services is hearing the stories of families who've turned their lives around and created a real future and a proper childhood for their kids.
I've seen kids go back to school, adults off drugs and into work, and parents looking after their children rather than the state. All of this in the midst of an Armageddon of budget cuts.
I now have a wealth of these success stories that others want to hear about and I've been given an opportunity to do so through a secondment to the Troubled Families Unit of the DCLG.
Even though the impetus for the national support for this work is born out of the economic crisis, the public sector has always sought the life outcomes we are now delivering here in Barnet for our most chaotic families.
I've said it before and I really don't care about repeating it, I think our staff are brilliant and I have every expectation you will continue to deliver the outcomes Barnet families need regardless of structures, governance and even strategy.
The public sector has never faced a challenge as big as the one we are in now. The dinosaurs had it easy with that meteorite 65 million years ago. And if I stick with this analogy for a while, those councils with a tendency for inertia will be the fossils referred to in the annals of the Municipal Journal of the next decade.
This makes life more than a bit difficult for everyone (sic) of us and I have been frankly amazed at how staff have accepted this challenge and got on with it.
Barnet Council and its partners have been blessed with a hugely talented and committed workforce and a supportive leadership from our Councillors. I have worked in many LAs so I speak with some authority here and I know Nick and my fellow directors share this view.
Better for less, has not just been another political sound bite here in Barnet, it's what's happening. We have seen huge changes already in the last two years and the usage and quality of our services have continued to improve even in these times.
The council has now entered a further significant period of evolution which other councils are watching carefully.
I will be closely following developments over the next year and of course wish you continued success. And if I can apologise in advance, I will be voraciously plagiarising all your work for the benefit of other councils.
Nick will be back next week, so enough from me. I will begin the secondment with the DCLG on the 25th of this month. Thank you for all that you do, have done and will continue to do for those most vulnerable and disadvantaged.
Robert
"Who is this Robert fellow"? is the polite version of one of the questions that was asked of Mr Mustard. Of course, as Mr Mustard knows more about the workings of the council than many on the inside, he can tell them that it is Robert McCulloch-Graham who is off on secondment for a year, taking his delusions of grandeur with him.
So, is Barnet a better place thanks to 3 years of paying Robert £165,504 p.a.? (2011/12 rate)
How was the final performance report for his department? It should be good after 3 years in charge? Here it is. The red ink is the council's and not Mr Mustard's this time.
A deeply unimpressive state in which to leave a department after 3 years of management. Only 60 managers submitted a monthly absence return (the basics not being done) a HR rating of negative 4.5 suggesting the staff are not being properly managed and 23 cases (3%) of Employee Relations Cases.
15 May, absolutely siling down, warden in woolly hat & jumper
The warden did not know this picture was being taken. You can see from the puddles at the kerb how heavy the rain has been and still is.
Sadly today's joke is deadly serious.
Let us remind ourselves of some of the content of the weekly message that Pam Wharfe, the Director responsible for parking & the interim (for now, but how much longer?) Director of Environment, Planning & Regeneration spouted on 4 May
From: First Team
Sent: 04 May 2012 15:20
To:
AllStaff
Subject: Weekly message - Pam Wharfe, Interim Director for
Environment, Planning and Regeneration
Nick has asked me to write the weekly message as he is at Alexandra Palace
in his role as Returning Officer for Barnet and Camden in the GLA
elections.
Most of my week has been tied up with the implementation of the One Barnet
programme.
Monday was the last full day of the parking staff working directly for the
council as they transferred to NSL and RR Donnelly on Tuesday. We had an
informal farewell on Monday organised by their colleagues for the staff working
in NLBP and the Civil Enforcement Officers (CEOs) had an event last week. On
Wednesday I met with Tracey Lees (Chief Executive) and Deep Sagar (Chair) from
the Barnet Group to discuss how things are going with the transfer of Housing
Needs staff and looking ahead to how we can work together to address various
challenges facing the council. Mr Mustard notes that Pam Wharfe knows so much about the companies to whom she is content to abdicate the responsibility for staff that she can't even spell their name correctly. It is "Donnelley" not "Donnelly".
Tracey in passing said she had noticed that the CEOs out and about in North
Finchley had smart new uniforms. This is a striking comparison to my first
winter when I was responsible for the service and we discovered we couldn't
actually provide enough coats for all the staff.This is a practical example
that shows the new provider has a better understanding about how to run this
service.
So there is the joke. Pam Wharfe says that before NSL, Barnet council couldn't afford enough coats for their outdoor employees (which is palpable nonsense but what she wrote) and NSL have sacked someone partly for asking for a coat (per GMB) in the wettest summer we have seen for ages.
The non-joke part is that an employee who was not on the largest salary, about £110,000 less than the obscene amount that Pam Wharfe is paid, now doesn't know where his next pay cheque will come from or even when he will next have one and he has family responsibilities.
It should go without saying, in a civilised society, that staff who are expected to work outdoors all year round should be automatically provided with the necessary clothing to do their job without the risk of catching pneumonia.
It is also important to note that councillors bang on all the time about how employees who are transferred to a new employer under TUPE+ have the same terms and conditions as they had before the transfer. That must mean that if there is a family friendly staff policy at Barnet Council then the same family friendly policy should be in place at NSL. The staff did not ask for a new employer and should be no worse off if one is foisted upon them.
Mr Mustard will follow the story of Mr Ojikutu and report the outcome to you.
Update 08.30: Mr Mustard found a little time to see what he could find out about family friendly policies at Barnet Council and here they are. The London Borough of Barnet - Pay and Benefits
You will have spotted the howler on the first page. "High caliber individuals" and of course there is no such thing. There are "High calibre individuals" around but one of them didn't write the offending page. Caliber is the spelling favoured in America and if all the One Barnet consultants could move there, as they will evidently feel right at home, Mr Mustard would be delighted.
It isn't only bloggers who are interested in the minutiae of council business, residents also are and rightly so as "we are all in it together" and Barnet Council are in grave danger of putting us right in it with the 10 year contracts they are going to sign and which will be impossibly expensive to get out of.
Why are the big One Barnet contracts (worth about £1bn over 10 years) going to be 10 years long? Not because the council have studied what is best for the residents of the borough but because that is what the bidders have indicated they favour.
One Barnet; where the tail wags the dog.
A resident who was much more on the ball than Mr Mustard tried in March 12 to get the tendering process run again so that the previous track records of the bidders, in so far as it related to the way they treated their staff and their Employment Tribunal records could be re-examined. The resident, Mr X, was looking to ensure that there was public confidence in the process. Most bloggers would tell you Mr X that they have little confidence in Barnet Council to do the right thing. Mr X wrote to Nick Walkley but he is far too busy doing something else, goodness knows what, and so he gave the letter to Declan Hoare, the Assistant Director for Highways and Transport, to respond to, as follows:
You will note that Mr Hoare answered a different set of questions and so the answer to question 1 "any civil...legal actions" was not answered nor was Q3 "any legal claims". Now the council will say they are not relevant because claims in an employment tribunal are not one of the criteria which allow for a bidder to be rejected but a large number of employment tribunal claims or compromise agreements would make any sensible council stop and think and mark the bidder down for the quality of their staff relations.
Not in Barnet apparently where the answers given by NSL were "satisfactory". Mr Mustard has always regarded anything described as satisfactory to be unsatisfactory simply because it is not great or super. It seems that Barnet Council are more easily satisfied.
Q4 was technically answered correctly as all staff were transferred to NSL but then 11 were made redundant at the end of the same month. It shows you how little protection comes with a TUPE transfer, none at all if you can simply be terminated on transfer, the new employer never wanted you, they are just doing the dirty work of the council.
Q5. Oh dear it seems that NSL failed to disclose the Hakim Berkani case to Barnet Council at the proper time. The tribunal found that NSL did unfairly dismiss Mr Berkani and had to pay him £20,000
Mr Mustard wonders if the fact of taking this up with NSL management is what caused the contract start date to slip from 1 April to 1 May.
Mr X is following up with Declan Hoare for more information.
Although in the case of Michael Onumajuru the tribunal found in favour of NSL there is the possibility that this particular case will be reviewed as the NSL manager involved, Adebowale Onadekou, has himself had a problem with the law and now looks to be less than the most reliable witness.
All in all NSL seem to have plenty of employee relations problems. One wonders if the councillors who voted in favour of outsourcing the parking enforcement to NSL bothered to do any background checking of their own before they voted in favour. Mr Mustard also wonders if they are now starting to think that bad press for NSL equals bad press for Barnet Council and problems for the conservative councillors who voted in favour getting re-elected in May 2014.
There will be another NSL staff problem along tomorrow.
What on earth is Mr Mustard on about; staff cannot be trained for 24 hours of the day can they? They can according to this set of Q&A. Mr Mustard thinks that the answers which are in OneBarnetspeak, a modified form of councilspeak as spoken, at length, at Croydon Council (see InsideCroydon) need clarifying so he has added an answer in plain English, in red.
Revenue & Benefits Q&A’s: 29 May 2012
Q1. When will we receive the assimilation outcomes?A. The evaluations are still being undertaking and as soon as these are complete we will invite people to individual meetings to discuss the outcomes and next steps. Indicatively we will be looking to commence outcome meetings at the latter end of week commencing 4 June 2012. w/c 4 June 12 Q2. What happens if I am away from the office on the day outcomes are communicated?A. It is likely that the outcome process will take place over a number of days, should individuals be out of the office for the entirety of this period we would seek to make them aware at the earliest point on their return.
Local arrangements for communicating outcomes can also be agreed for planned extended leave.
You will be told as soon as you are back
Q3. When we are advised where we will be based, when will we find out which team we will be in?
A. The structure of the teams will be determined by the respective senior manager in collaboration with the Team Manager’s, and this will be discussed in detail over the coming weeks.
Pass.
Who put that rogue apostrophe in?
Q4. Do we have the right of appeal of where we are told we will be based? A. You will be invited to a meeting to discuss the outcome of the assimilation evaluation and a rationale for the decision that has been taken.
No.
Q5. When and how will Revenue & Benefits training be delivered?
A. Training will be delivered both by existing subject area specialists and the Training team, and this will be on a continuous basis to ensure that the team is appropriately prepared for the future needs of the service.
See this link for the difference between continuous and continual. It is very worrying that the management of the massive One Barnet programme is run by people who are so sloppy in their use of language. It makes one question their competence. Q6. Will Job description be changed?A. Where there is a current proposal to amend existing JD’s this has formed part of the consultation process.
Maybe
If as the service develops there is latterly a need to revisit the existing job descriptions this would be done through consultation.
New job descriptions will be imposed in the usual way.
Q7. Can I refuse to move to a role in the contact centre?
A. No. Appointments to the contact centre will be by assimilation and reflect the needs of the organisation.
Yes, get your coat and your P45
Q8. Who will make the decision on where people will be placed?
A. Decisions are being reached as follows:
Assimilation evaluation: These are undertaken by the respective line managers, plus an second informed manager. The finalised outcome is an average score taking in to consideration both evaluations. Details of the criteria used have been discussed during the consultation sessions and can be found on the intranet.
Structured interviews will be undertaken where the evaluation has not suitably differentiated between those in scope for assimilation. The interviews will be held by senior front and back office service managers'
The management will decide. Another surplus apostrophe has appeared.
Q9. Why are performance reviews not being used as a selection tool?
A. The assimilation evaluations focus on the core knowledge, skill and experience requirements of the assimilable roles, the outcomes will therefore allow for informed decision to be taken. Performance reviews don't give the answer we want.
Q10. The required skill, knowledge and experience may differ between roles. Does the evaluation take this in to consideration?
A. The evaluation looks at the core requirements of the respective roles.
Yes.
Q11. Why has the scale 0, 10, 20 been used? A. The evaluation criteria and scale are defined by the Managing Organisational Change policy
Pass.
Q12. Who will need to attend an interview? A. Interviews will take place where the assimilation evaluation has not suitably differentiated between members of the in-scope team to reasonably allow an informed decision to be taken.
Interviews will be structured and scenario based therefore focusing on the core competencies for both assimilable roles (front and back office).
Anyone who has rocked the boat.
Q13. Will I find out my evaluation outcome before any interview? A. Yesgosh, a one word answer
Q14. Is there a reduction in Appeal’s or Overpayment’s team roles?
A. Customer contact activity and the appropriate resource to manage this will transfer to the CSO but there is no overall reduction in permanent Officer roles.
No.
Q15. Will individual work load increase?
A. The proposed changes, in addition to increased financial accountability, are focused on service improvement. This means that we will need to work smarter through improved process and a more empowered staff team.
As has been communicated throughout the consultation period, the putting in place of:
- A dedicated Customer Contact team
- A centralised Support and Control team
- The Transition team
Will see the service transformed and resource more appropriately aligned to meet current and future demands. Workloads will increase.
Q16. Why has the structure changed from that first proposed when consultation was opened? A. The structure has changed twice since consultation was opened, firstly the addition of two Team Leader roles within the front office structure, and subsequently through the introduction of two additional roles within the Revenue’s team.We didn't know what we were doing. Another duff apostrophe.These changes have been as a direct result of the consultation period and reflect the level of involvement of the staff team in the defining of the future operating structure.
The optional second round of one to one’s consultations that are now taking place have been offered with a view to discussing the recent changes in more detail, and offering further input to the process. Another duff apostrophe.
One Barnet is run by verbose illiterate management.
Tuesday, 12 June 2012 at 14:19 - Schroder, Johnathan
Mr Mustard has had his red pen out again.
At the beginning of May the Parking Service transferred over to the new providers, NSL and RR Donnelley.
Declan Hoare, Assistant Director for Highways and Transport, said: (did he really come out with this rubbish or did he let Schroder put words into his mouth. If you did Declan accept these words, I suggest spit them out next time and write your own.)
"I am pleased that although the past few months created some uncertainty for staff, throughout the process staff, managers and unions have been able to work together very professionally and constructively. In turn NSL and RR Donnelley have been amenable to staff requests and have tried to accommodate them where possible. NSL have already made 11 back office staff redundant because they have moved the work to Worthing so those 11 have got certainty, "you're fired". "Worked with the union" Hmm, here is the union view from April 2011. Make up your own mind.
Both new providers were keen to share their job vacancies with staff in the weeks running up to the transfer as that would save on employment agency fees. One of the benefits that the council is hoping to achieve is that staff who transfer to new providers will have more opportunities for career development. One would have thought that a council with over 3,000 staff already offered a lot more opportunities for staff development than nearly every business in Barnet can manage. New opportunities are already now being made available. Several staff from the Parking Service have been retained in the council because it will take 5 people to monitor the external providers. and a few were found alternative roles within Barnet which doubtless led to some agency workers being terminated and they are local residents too.
It is important to remember that those who have transferred over to the new providers are still delivering public services in Barnet (but the 25 new jobs in Worthing have been lost for 5 years at least to residents of the London Borough of Barnet?) and as such are still part of the Barnet family which will the largest most dysfunctional and widespread family ever seen.. One of the key principles of One Barnet is that the council will have to work collaboratively with an increasingly diverse public sector workforce and this will mean some old colleagues ("former colleagues" surely?) who have moved on (they have not moved on except in the context that they had to find a new job, change location or be sacked) to new external providers." "Some" might mean 2,000.
Were you one of the Parking back office staff who was made redundant? Do you want to talk to Mr Mustard and perhaps have a guest blog, anonymously or otherwise. If you do, then send an email to mrmustard@zoho.com and you can tell the residents of Barnet what you think about your treatment.