14 June 2012

Revs & bens staff to be trained 24 hours a day 7 days a week

http://www.oaktree.org.uk/


What on earth is Mr Mustard on about; staff cannot be trained for 24 hours of the day can they? They can according to this set of Q&A. Mr Mustard thinks that the answers which are in OneBarnetspeak, a modified form of councilspeak as spoken, at length, at Croydon Council (see InsideCroydon) need clarifying so he has added an answer in plain English, in red.

Revenue & Benefits Q&A’s: 29 May 2012

Q1. When will we receive the assimilation outcomes?A. The evaluations are still being undertaking and as soon as these are complete we will invite people to individual meetings to discuss the outcomes and next steps.
Indicatively we will be looking to commence outcome meetings at the latter end of week commencing 4 June 2012.
w/c 4 June 12

Q2. What happens if I am away from the office on the day outcomes are communicated?
A. It is likely that the outcome process will take place over a number of days, should individuals be out of the office for the entirety of this period we would seek to make them aware at the earliest point on their return.
Local arrangements for communicating outcomes can also be agreed for planned extended leave.
You will be told as soon as you are back

Q3. When we are advised where we will be based, when will we find out which team we will be in?
A. The structure of the teams will be determined by the respective senior manager in collaboration with the Team Manager’s, and this will be discussed in detail over the coming weeks.
Pass.
Who put that rogue apostrophe in?

Q4. Do we have the right of appeal of where we are told we will be based?
A. You will be invited to a meeting to discuss the outcome of the assimilation evaluation and a rationale for the decision that has been taken.
No.

Q5. When and how will Revenue & Benefits training be delivered?
A. Training will be delivered both by existing subject area specialists and the Training team, and this will be on a continuous basis to ensure that the team is appropriately prepared for the future needs of the service.
See this link for the difference between continuous and continual. It is very worrying that the management of the massive One Barnet programme is run by people who are so sloppy in their use of language. It makes one question their competence.

Q6. Will Job description be changed?
A. Where there is a current proposal to amend existing JD’s this has formed part of the consultation process.
Maybe

If as the service develops there is latterly a need to revisit the existing job descriptions this would be done through consultation.
New job descriptions will be imposed in the usual way.

Q7. Can I refuse to move to a role in the contact centre?
A. No. Appointments to the contact centre will be by assimilation and reflect the needs of the organisation.
Yes, get your coat and your P45

Q8. Who will make the decision on where people will be placed?
A. Decisions are being reached as follows:
  • Assimilation evaluation: These are undertaken by the respective line managers, plus an second informed manager. The finalised outcome is an average score taking in to consideration both evaluations. Details of the criteria used have been discussed during the consultation sessions and can be found on the intranet.
  • Structured interviews will be undertaken where the evaluation has not suitably differentiated between those in scope for assimilation. The interviews will be held by senior front and back office service managers'
The management will decide. Another surplus apostrophe has appeared.

Q9. Why are performance reviews not being used as a selection tool?
A. The assimilation evaluations focus on the core knowledge, skill and experience requirements of the assimilable roles, the outcomes will therefore allow for informed decision to be taken.
Performance reviews don't give the answer we want.

Q10. The required skill, knowledge and experience may differ between roles. Does the evaluation take this in to consideration?
A. The evaluation looks at the core requirements of the respective roles.
Yes.

Q11. Why has the scale 0, 10, 20 been used?

A. The evaluation criteria and scale are defined by the Managing Organisational Change policy
Pass.

Q12. Who will need to attend an interview?

A. Interviews will take place where the assimilation evaluation has not suitably differentiated between members of the in-scope team to reasonably allow an informed decision to be taken.
Interviews will be structured and scenario based therefore focusing on the core competencies for both assimilable roles (front and back office).
Anyone who has rocked the boat.
 
Q13. Will I find out my evaluation outcome before any interview?
A. Yes
gosh, a one word answer

Q14. Is there a reduction in Appeal’s or Overpayment’s team roles?
A. Customer contact activity and the appropriate resource to manage this will transfer to the CSO but there is no overall reduction in permanent Officer roles.
No.

Q15. Will individual work load increase? 
A. The proposed changes, in addition to increased financial accountability, are focused on service improvement. This means that we will need to work smarter through improved process and a more empowered staff team.
As has been communicated throughout the consultation period, the putting in place of:

- A dedicated Customer Contact team
- A centralised Support and Control team
- The Transition team

Will see the service transformed and resource more appropriately aligned to meet current and future demands.
Workloads will increase.
 
Q16. Why has the structure changed from that first proposed when consultation was opened?
A. The structure has changed twice since consultation was opened, firstly the addition of two Team Leader roles within the front office structure, and subsequently through the introduction of two additional roles within the Revenue’s team.
We didn't know what we were doing. Another duff apostrophe.These changes have been as a direct result of the consultation period and reflect the level of involvement of the staff team in the defining of the future operating structure.

The optional second round of one to one’s consultations that are now taking place have been offered with a view to discussing the recent changes in more detail, and offering further input to the process.
Another duff apostrophe.



One Barnet is run by verbose illiterate management.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Latest score : Worthing 25 : 1 Barnet

Parking Service transfers

Tuesday, 12 June 2012 at 14:19 - Schroder, Johnathan
Mr Mustard has had his red pen out again.
At the beginning of May the Parking Service transferred over to the new providers, NSL and RR Donnelley.

Declan Hoare, Assistant Director for Highways and Transport, said: (did he really come out with this rubbish or did he let Schroder put words into his mouth. If you did Declan accept these words, I suggest spit them out next time and write your own.)
"I am pleased that although the past few months created some uncertainty for staff, throughout the process staff, managers and unions have been able to work together very professionally and constructively. In turn NSL and RR Donnelley have been amenable to staff requests and have tried to accommodate them where possible. NSL have already made 11 back office staff redundant because they have moved the work to Worthing so those 11 have got certainty, "you're fired". "Worked with the union" Hmm, here is the union view from April 2011. Make up your own mind.

Both new providers were keen to share their job vacancies with staff in the weeks running up to the transfer as that would save on employment agency fees. One of the benefits that the council is hoping to achieve is that staff who transfer to new providers will have more opportunities for career development. One would have thought that a council with over 3,000 staff already offered a lot more opportunities for staff development than nearly every business in Barnet can manage. New opportunities are already now being made available. Several staff from the Parking Service have been retained in the council because it will take 5 people to monitor the external providers. and a few were found alternative roles within Barnet which doubtless led to some agency workers being terminated and they are local residents too.

It is important to remember that those who have transferred over to the new providers are still delivering public services in Barnet (but the 25 new jobs in Worthing have been lost for 5 years at least to residents of the London Borough of Barnet?) and as such are still part of the Barnet family which will the largest most dysfunctional and widespread family ever seen.. One of the key principles of One Barnet is that the council will have to work collaboratively with an increasingly diverse public sector workforce and this will mean some old colleagues ("former colleagues" surely?) who have moved on (they have not moved on except in the context that they had to find a new job, change location or be sacked) to new external providers." "Some" might mean 2,000.

Were you one of the Parking back office staff who was made redundant? Do you want to talk to Mr Mustard and perhaps have a guest blog, anonymously or otherwise. If you do, then send an email to mrmustard@zoho.com and you can tell the residents of Barnet what you think about your treatment.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

13 June 2012

Ed gets £80,472 p.a. to write guff

what sort of website wouldn't be online?

Croydon Council are the complete masters of writing loads and saying nothing but Barnet are catching on. Look at this rubbish on the Inside Croydon blog. This is all such vague stuff that Mr Mustard can barely be bothered to get his red pen out. Now for the second division councilspeak offering from One Barnet

Tuesday, 12 June 2012 at 14:42 - Schroder, Johnathan

What next for the Corporate Change Programme?

The council is starting to think about the next wave of corporate change programmes. A series of strategic reviews are being conducted which are cross-cutting and inter-linked. Can't we just cut your post Mr Gowan?

These reviews will examine: community safety; early intervention and prevention; health and social care integration; leisure; and the street scene.

Ed Gowan, assistant director of commercial transformation, said: "These strategic reviews are the next stage in the transformation of Barnet. We are beginning to build upon what has been achieved so far by the One Barnet Programme by looking beyond the mechanics of how we deliver services to identifying where we can improve the lives of residents. The council wants to make sure that our resources are focussed on what residents need and that we can facilitate communities taking ownership of some of these issues for themselves."

"These reviews are very much part of the 'one public sector' approach as they will necessitate working closely with other public sector partners in the police, NHS, probation, and across many directorates of the council itself. As ever, the council will be driving for efficiency by mapping how much public money is spent across the large number of bodies involved with these five areas, and sharing resources and reducing duplication where possible. The council will also look to be customer-centric by assessing whether it is meeting all the needs and expectations of residents."

These strategic reviews are in their early stages. A business case will be developed for each of these reviews. It will be requested under Freedom of Information legislation.

See future editions of First Team for further updates. Mr Mustard has his log-in and will keep an eye out.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

The step by step guide - without any steps!


Every other step by step guide that Mr Mustard has ever seen had a list of each and every step. Things are not done that way in One Barnet; you just get a load of Schroder waffle.

NSCSO/DRS process for selecting bidders 

a step by step guide

Tuesday, 12 June 2012 14:37 Schroder, Johnathan
Mr Mustard in red.
The New Support and Customer Service Organisation (NSCSO) and Development and Regulatory Services (DRS) projects, are currently in the competitive dialogue stage of the procurement process. This means project teams and service leads are in a heavy schedule of meetings with bidders and are starting to finalise some of the detail of how bidders intend to deliver the in-scope services.

At the end of the competitive dialogue stage the bidders will submit their final solution. These will be evaluated against the agreed set of criteria that were set at the beginning of the project when bidders were first invited to tender for the contract. The evaluation teams, who will be made up of the project team, procurement team and service leads, must assess each bid against the set criteria. The decision must be able to stand up to scrutiny as it can be subject to challenge. Residents have not been given the chance to carry out any scrutiny and yet they will suffer the consequences of failure and pay for any mistakes.

The evaluation team will make a recommendation to Cabinet Resources Committee (CRC), but the final decision of who to select rests with CRC. As these two major procurement projects are running alongside each other, there has been a great deal of discussion about the best way to ensure both projects run smoothly and that the operational interdependencies are well managed. Recently, procurement in Barnet has been shown to have more holes in it than a Swiss cheese.

The programme board is discussing several options at the moment but it is likely that NSCSO will transfer slightly before DRS and it is hoped to be able to confirm exact dates shortly. Whilst there will be an overlap, this will avoid trying to manage two very large service transfers happening at the same time. The idea of separating these two enormous lumps of outsourcing by a year so that lessons can be learnt from the first contract before proceedings, or not, with the second, is far too sensible an idea for One Barnet.
One Barnet is not going to be heaven; we are off to hell in a handcart.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Mr Mustard blog is "Lots of fun" - Barnet Homes

lots of fun
Although Mr Mustard's blog has a serious message it wouldn't be good if it wasn't fun sometimes. Now Mr Mustard can report, with mixed feelings, that the Mr Mustard blog has been described in an email sent by Jonathan Lawn the "Communications Manager" at Barnet Homes/The Barnet Group/Your Choice as:

"Lots of fun"

Mr Mustard is pleased that his readers, even including the Barnet Homes employee with an ill-judged view of what the job of a misCommunications Manager is, like the blog. This pleasure is though tempered by a worry that the relationship with Dogstar is far too cosy.

Here is the email:

To put this email into context you need to look at the Broken Homes blog post written on 15 May (the very same day that this email was sent). So Mr Lawn has had time since 9am to look at this blog, have a chat on the phone with Dogstar about it (otherwise the email makes no sense) and then send this email which alerts the Account Manager and two Account Executives at Dogstar to the blog. You can see their work for Barnet Homes here.

What is Mr Lawn reported as saying about their work? (which leaves Mr Mustard completely underwhelmed, both the work and Lawn's puff piece)

"They really took the time and effort to gain a detailed understanding of the brief and our requirements. Because of that, their concepts for the new logos met with virtually universal approval from everyone involved in the project, right from the initial design stage. That’s incredibly rare in my experience.

It's been a pleasure to work with Dogstar Abstracts on this project and we’re delighted with the new brand identities."

Jonathan Lawn, Communications Manager

Now bear in mind that Dogstar have been paid over £160,000 by Barnet Homes without a contract, that Jonathan appears happy to give them his permission to use Barnet Homes in order to try and bolster the commercial appeal of Dogstar (otherwise he would already have made them take the endorsement off their website) and that if a Barnet Blogger writes anything about a supplier the misCommunications Manager is sending them an email within 49 minutes of it appearing. (If only repair response times were so low?).

Mr Mustard hasn't seen the job description of the Communications Manager but is prepared to wager that it does not include telling suppliers if they appear in any of the famous five Barnet blogs.

This email stinks.

What should happen now? The internal auditor at Barnet Homes needs to drop what he/she is doing and audit the procurement "arrangements" in the communications department (Barnet Council only had an "arrangement" with MetPro).

Barnet Homes need to go out to tender for the next batch of design work.

The Chief Executive, Tracey Lees, needs to give Mr Jonathan Lawn some words of advice or a rollocking, she must decide, or maybe she will do nothing at all?

Craig Cooper at Barnet Council needs to review his own directorate's recent use of Dogstar to make sure it is compliant. Mr Mustard will be running the ruler over you soon Craig.

Mr Mustard is already rather busy with Barnet Council and so repeats his appeal for a Barnet resident to step forward and try their hand at blogging about Barnet Homes. There is evidently lots of material to blog about.

This post also highlights how useful the Freedom of Information legislation is as that is how the above email was obtained. Mr Mustard asked for any emails sent to Dogstar between 9am and 10.02am on 15 May. 

Yours, officially lots of fun,

Mr Mustard

12 June 2012

Parking ticket cancellation procedure

If you want to get your parking ticket cancelled you would do well to read the following cancellation policy procedure and try and fit your representation or appeal (the first informal letter is a representation and the second official one is an appeal apparently - Mr Mustard expects that the distinction is lost on most people) into one of the categories and provide the listed supporting paperwork so that the ticket should be cancelled.

PCN Cancellation Procedure v1.15 1 April 2010

Even if your appeal is on different grounds that are not listed it is still worth sending it in as it might be accepted and the penalty is frozen at the 50% payable level until your representation is answered.

Do follow the instructions on your parking ticket and appeal either using the form on the council website or in writing as instructed on the parking ticket. Don't leave the matter as it only gets more expensive if you do nothing.

Don't worry if your informal representations are rejected. Simply re-submit the same grounds at the formal stage. Mr Mustard suspects that a lot of bluffing goes on and that if you take your appeal all the way to PATAS (Parking & Traffic Appeals Service) a lot of cases get dropped by the council at the last minute.

It is a good idea to download the document to your computer, print it out and give it to friends who have had a parking ticket and/or email it to everyone in your address book. It might be the next present you have ever given them?

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

11 June 2012

Look out ALMOs - Uncle Eric is thinking about ALMO transparency

The good thing about writing to the fan of Barnet's bloggers who is warmly referred to as Uncle Eric (really the Rt Hon Eric Pickles MP) is that you know that even if you don't ask for a reply, Uncle Eric will give your letter to one of his team to think about and you can be pretty sure of a no nonsense approach to the subject matter. Sometimes you just find that Eric acts to fix what you have written about as he already had the matter in hand.

Mr Mustard wrote to Uncle Eric in mid-May because although Barnet Council publishes spending information (quite badly but it's a start) as soon as spending is routed through a contractor, outsourcer or an ALMO (Arms length management organisation) such as Barnet Homes, then the spending information is simply not available. That is an unsatisfactory situation. Barnet Home manages about 15,000 properties and has an annual turnover of £27m. The public should be able to easily see the major items of expenditure.

Business Plan 2011-2013
Here is the email that Mr Mustard sent

Dear Mr Pickles

I am sure that you realise that an anomaly can be created by councils outsourcing and/or moving their assets into ALMOs (for good business reasons) who, as private companies, are not required to publish their over £500 spending data. Barnet Homes do respond to FOI requests but I don't know what to ask about if I don't see who they pay money to.

It was by accident that I came across the particular spend highlighted in my latest blog posting. broken-homes

Please could you have one of your team look at this area with a view to extending your guidance to all organisations to whom councils contract out service provision (Barnet Council have already contracted out the entire parking service and are planning on contracting out Customer Services and Development & Regulatory Services which will greatly reduce the amount of spending detail the council publishes; outline details attached).

The devil is always in the detail and there won't be much detail left in Barnet when one only sees a monthly payment to NSL, BT, Capita etc.

Best wishes

Yours sincerely

Mr Mustard

and here is the considered reply with some emboldening by Mr Mustard


Dear Mr Mustard,

Thank you for your e-mail of 15th May to the Right Hon Eric Pickles MP which has been passed to the Directorate for Local Government Policy in view of our local government transparency responsibilities and I have been asked to respond.

I would like to reassure you that this Government is committed to increasing transparency throughout central and local government. If we want local people to be able to hold politicians and local authorities to account, while fostering a new spirit of localism, we must provide them with the tools and information to do so. To support and drive this agenda forward, beyond the excellent start local authorities have already made on releasing expenditure over £500, this Department in September 2011 published the final Code of Recommended Practice for Local Authorities on Data Transparency. The Code enshrines three principles of transparency, demand-led, open and timely. It also sets out the minimum datasets that should be published. Embedding a culture of transparency within authorities takes time. The department has committed to review the Code within 18 months of publication. Ministers do have the option to make the Code mandatory.

Thank you for drawing to our attention and sharing your concerns about the potential lack of transparency created when some councils outsource services or move assets to ALMOs who, in turn, might not be required to publish their spending data. We are aware of the issues and officials will be considering these in the round when reviewing the Code.

The Government's view is that it is important to make more data publicly and readily available to the citizen to enable them to challenge public authorities about how they are using taxpayers’ money, so citizens are better placed to raise issues and concerns.

We have noted your concerns and you will have the opportunity to feed in further views during the next phase of the Code review process.

Kind regards,

PJ (name redacted by Mr Mustard) 
| Department for Communities and Local Government | Local Government Policy & Productivity | Accountability & Transparency Division|3/J3 Eland House | Bressenden Place | London SW1E 5DU
 
Mr Mustard looks forward to the day when the spending of Barnet Homes is published although he doubts that they are.
 
Yours frugally
 
Mr Mustard