13 June 2012

Ed gets £80,472 p.a. to write guff

what sort of website wouldn't be online?

Croydon Council are the complete masters of writing loads and saying nothing but Barnet are catching on. Look at this rubbish on the Inside Croydon blog. This is all such vague stuff that Mr Mustard can barely be bothered to get his red pen out. Now for the second division councilspeak offering from One Barnet

Tuesday, 12 June 2012 at 14:42 - Schroder, Johnathan

What next for the Corporate Change Programme?

The council is starting to think about the next wave of corporate change programmes. A series of strategic reviews are being conducted which are cross-cutting and inter-linked. Can't we just cut your post Mr Gowan?

These reviews will examine: community safety; early intervention and prevention; health and social care integration; leisure; and the street scene.

Ed Gowan, assistant director of commercial transformation, said: "These strategic reviews are the next stage in the transformation of Barnet. We are beginning to build upon what has been achieved so far by the One Barnet Programme by looking beyond the mechanics of how we deliver services to identifying where we can improve the lives of residents. The council wants to make sure that our resources are focussed on what residents need and that we can facilitate communities taking ownership of some of these issues for themselves."

"These reviews are very much part of the 'one public sector' approach as they will necessitate working closely with other public sector partners in the police, NHS, probation, and across many directorates of the council itself. As ever, the council will be driving for efficiency by mapping how much public money is spent across the large number of bodies involved with these five areas, and sharing resources and reducing duplication where possible. The council will also look to be customer-centric by assessing whether it is meeting all the needs and expectations of residents."

These strategic reviews are in their early stages. A business case will be developed for each of these reviews. It will be requested under Freedom of Information legislation.

See future editions of First Team for further updates. Mr Mustard has his log-in and will keep an eye out.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

The step by step guide - without any steps!


Every other step by step guide that Mr Mustard has ever seen had a list of each and every step. Things are not done that way in One Barnet; you just get a load of Schroder waffle.

NSCSO/DRS process for selecting bidders 

a step by step guide

Tuesday, 12 June 2012 14:37 Schroder, Johnathan
Mr Mustard in red.
The New Support and Customer Service Organisation (NSCSO) and Development and Regulatory Services (DRS) projects, are currently in the competitive dialogue stage of the procurement process. This means project teams and service leads are in a heavy schedule of meetings with bidders and are starting to finalise some of the detail of how bidders intend to deliver the in-scope services.

At the end of the competitive dialogue stage the bidders will submit their final solution. These will be evaluated against the agreed set of criteria that were set at the beginning of the project when bidders were first invited to tender for the contract. The evaluation teams, who will be made up of the project team, procurement team and service leads, must assess each bid against the set criteria. The decision must be able to stand up to scrutiny as it can be subject to challenge. Residents have not been given the chance to carry out any scrutiny and yet they will suffer the consequences of failure and pay for any mistakes.

The evaluation team will make a recommendation to Cabinet Resources Committee (CRC), but the final decision of who to select rests with CRC. As these two major procurement projects are running alongside each other, there has been a great deal of discussion about the best way to ensure both projects run smoothly and that the operational interdependencies are well managed. Recently, procurement in Barnet has been shown to have more holes in it than a Swiss cheese.

The programme board is discussing several options at the moment but it is likely that NSCSO will transfer slightly before DRS and it is hoped to be able to confirm exact dates shortly. Whilst there will be an overlap, this will avoid trying to manage two very large service transfers happening at the same time. The idea of separating these two enormous lumps of outsourcing by a year so that lessons can be learnt from the first contract before proceedings, or not, with the second, is far too sensible an idea for One Barnet.
One Barnet is not going to be heaven; we are off to hell in a handcart.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Mr Mustard blog is "Lots of fun" - Barnet Homes

lots of fun
Although Mr Mustard's blog has a serious message it wouldn't be good if it wasn't fun sometimes. Now Mr Mustard can report, with mixed feelings, that the Mr Mustard blog has been described in an email sent by Jonathan Lawn the "Communications Manager" at Barnet Homes/The Barnet Group/Your Choice as:

"Lots of fun"

Mr Mustard is pleased that his readers, even including the Barnet Homes employee with an ill-judged view of what the job of a misCommunications Manager is, like the blog. This pleasure is though tempered by a worry that the relationship with Dogstar is far too cosy.

Here is the email:

To put this email into context you need to look at the Broken Homes blog post written on 15 May (the very same day that this email was sent). So Mr Lawn has had time since 9am to look at this blog, have a chat on the phone with Dogstar about it (otherwise the email makes no sense) and then send this email which alerts the Account Manager and two Account Executives at Dogstar to the blog. You can see their work for Barnet Homes here.

What is Mr Lawn reported as saying about their work? (which leaves Mr Mustard completely underwhelmed, both the work and Lawn's puff piece)

"They really took the time and effort to gain a detailed understanding of the brief and our requirements. Because of that, their concepts for the new logos met with virtually universal approval from everyone involved in the project, right from the initial design stage. That’s incredibly rare in my experience.

It's been a pleasure to work with Dogstar Abstracts on this project and we’re delighted with the new brand identities."

Jonathan Lawn, Communications Manager

Now bear in mind that Dogstar have been paid over £160,000 by Barnet Homes without a contract, that Jonathan appears happy to give them his permission to use Barnet Homes in order to try and bolster the commercial appeal of Dogstar (otherwise he would already have made them take the endorsement off their website) and that if a Barnet Blogger writes anything about a supplier the misCommunications Manager is sending them an email within 49 minutes of it appearing. (If only repair response times were so low?).

Mr Mustard hasn't seen the job description of the Communications Manager but is prepared to wager that it does not include telling suppliers if they appear in any of the famous five Barnet blogs.

This email stinks.

What should happen now? The internal auditor at Barnet Homes needs to drop what he/she is doing and audit the procurement "arrangements" in the communications department (Barnet Council only had an "arrangement" with MetPro).

Barnet Homes need to go out to tender for the next batch of design work.

The Chief Executive, Tracey Lees, needs to give Mr Jonathan Lawn some words of advice or a rollocking, she must decide, or maybe she will do nothing at all?

Craig Cooper at Barnet Council needs to review his own directorate's recent use of Dogstar to make sure it is compliant. Mr Mustard will be running the ruler over you soon Craig.

Mr Mustard is already rather busy with Barnet Council and so repeats his appeal for a Barnet resident to step forward and try their hand at blogging about Barnet Homes. There is evidently lots of material to blog about.

This post also highlights how useful the Freedom of Information legislation is as that is how the above email was obtained. Mr Mustard asked for any emails sent to Dogstar between 9am and 10.02am on 15 May. 

Yours, officially lots of fun,

Mr Mustard

12 June 2012

Parking ticket cancellation procedure

If you want to get your parking ticket cancelled you would do well to read the following cancellation policy procedure and try and fit your representation or appeal (the first informal letter is a representation and the second official one is an appeal apparently - Mr Mustard expects that the distinction is lost on most people) into one of the categories and provide the listed supporting paperwork so that the ticket should be cancelled.

PCN Cancellation Procedure v1.15 1 April 2010

Even if your appeal is on different grounds that are not listed it is still worth sending it in as it might be accepted and the penalty is frozen at the 50% payable level until your representation is answered.

Do follow the instructions on your parking ticket and appeal either using the form on the council website or in writing as instructed on the parking ticket. Don't leave the matter as it only gets more expensive if you do nothing.

Don't worry if your informal representations are rejected. Simply re-submit the same grounds at the formal stage. Mr Mustard suspects that a lot of bluffing goes on and that if you take your appeal all the way to PATAS (Parking & Traffic Appeals Service) a lot of cases get dropped by the council at the last minute.

It is a good idea to download the document to your computer, print it out and give it to friends who have had a parking ticket and/or email it to everyone in your address book. It might be the next present you have ever given them?

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

11 June 2012

Look out ALMOs - Uncle Eric is thinking about ALMO transparency

The good thing about writing to the fan of Barnet's bloggers who is warmly referred to as Uncle Eric (really the Rt Hon Eric Pickles MP) is that you know that even if you don't ask for a reply, Uncle Eric will give your letter to one of his team to think about and you can be pretty sure of a no nonsense approach to the subject matter. Sometimes you just find that Eric acts to fix what you have written about as he already had the matter in hand.

Mr Mustard wrote to Uncle Eric in mid-May because although Barnet Council publishes spending information (quite badly but it's a start) as soon as spending is routed through a contractor, outsourcer or an ALMO (Arms length management organisation) such as Barnet Homes, then the spending information is simply not available. That is an unsatisfactory situation. Barnet Home manages about 15,000 properties and has an annual turnover of £27m. The public should be able to easily see the major items of expenditure.

Business Plan 2011-2013
Here is the email that Mr Mustard sent

Dear Mr Pickles

I am sure that you realise that an anomaly can be created by councils outsourcing and/or moving their assets into ALMOs (for good business reasons) who, as private companies, are not required to publish their over £500 spending data. Barnet Homes do respond to FOI requests but I don't know what to ask about if I don't see who they pay money to.

It was by accident that I came across the particular spend highlighted in my latest blog posting. broken-homes

Please could you have one of your team look at this area with a view to extending your guidance to all organisations to whom councils contract out service provision (Barnet Council have already contracted out the entire parking service and are planning on contracting out Customer Services and Development & Regulatory Services which will greatly reduce the amount of spending detail the council publishes; outline details attached).

The devil is always in the detail and there won't be much detail left in Barnet when one only sees a monthly payment to NSL, BT, Capita etc.

Best wishes

Yours sincerely

Mr Mustard

and here is the considered reply with some emboldening by Mr Mustard


Dear Mr Mustard,

Thank you for your e-mail of 15th May to the Right Hon Eric Pickles MP which has been passed to the Directorate for Local Government Policy in view of our local government transparency responsibilities and I have been asked to respond.

I would like to reassure you that this Government is committed to increasing transparency throughout central and local government. If we want local people to be able to hold politicians and local authorities to account, while fostering a new spirit of localism, we must provide them with the tools and information to do so. To support and drive this agenda forward, beyond the excellent start local authorities have already made on releasing expenditure over £500, this Department in September 2011 published the final Code of Recommended Practice for Local Authorities on Data Transparency. The Code enshrines three principles of transparency, demand-led, open and timely. It also sets out the minimum datasets that should be published. Embedding a culture of transparency within authorities takes time. The department has committed to review the Code within 18 months of publication. Ministers do have the option to make the Code mandatory.

Thank you for drawing to our attention and sharing your concerns about the potential lack of transparency created when some councils outsource services or move assets to ALMOs who, in turn, might not be required to publish their spending data. We are aware of the issues and officials will be considering these in the round when reviewing the Code.

The Government's view is that it is important to make more data publicly and readily available to the citizen to enable them to challenge public authorities about how they are using taxpayers’ money, so citizens are better placed to raise issues and concerns.

We have noted your concerns and you will have the opportunity to feed in further views during the next phase of the Code review process.

Kind regards,

PJ (name redacted by Mr Mustard) 
| Department for Communities and Local Government | Local Government Policy & Productivity | Accountability & Transparency Division|3/J3 Eland House | Bressenden Place | London SW1E 5DU
 
Mr Mustard looks forward to the day when the spending of Barnet Homes is published although he doubts that they are.
 
Yours frugally
 
Mr Mustard

10 June 2012

Another nail being driven into the democracy coffin at Barnet Council

Proposed Revisions to Planning Delegated Powers at Barnet Council - 14 June 2012

Here is a press release issued by the hard working Liberal Democrat Councillor Jack Cohen, the councillor who strongly believes in the ethos of public service (words which you hear less often than excessively high executive pay at Barnet Council)

Barnet Council: Another attack on Public Participation

Councillor Jack Cohen Leader of Barnet Liberal Democrats is attacking proposed changes to the rules on public participation at planning committees. Under the existing rules if three or more residents object to a planning application it has to be determined by the Planning Committee. This is why Planning Committees are so well attended and why so many residents turn up to exercise their right to speak. As a result Committees are not able to conclude their business and meetings are being adjourned. The Council are so concerned about this that they are putting forward a recommendation to the Planning and Environment Committee that the minimum number of objectors that will trigger a referral to Committee is increased to five.

Cllr Jack Cohen a member of the Planning Committee since 1986 is incensed. Cllr Cohen who is credited with introducing the right for the public to speak at planning committee when the Liberal Democrats were in Joint Administration says the Conservatives never supported this. "gradually they have eroded the rights of residents and this is another example. The problem is all of their own making. Last year they reduced the number of planning sub committees from three to two. We predicted that this would cause difficulties. But instead of accepting responsibility they blame the public for having the effrontery to want to participate in the democratic process."

Cllr Cohen is calling on the Planning Committee to throw the proposals out. "I will be voting against it and warns Conservatives Councillors that the Public will never forgive them if they force this through"


Mr Mustard finds he often agrees with Jack Cohen (you will have to ask Jack himself if the inverse is true).

Barnet Council don't like the spotlight being on them because it shows up the appalling mess that they often make of things. In this case the change isn't for that reason (planning cockups have not recently been in the news as far as Mr Mustard recalls although the Carmelite monastery fiasco did cost a packet in 2010). The main driver seems to be cost saving, which is laudable when done in the right place, and the by-product is that democracy will be reduced except that Mr Mustard predicts that it won't.

Mr Mustard is not a fan of delegated powers. He can see that in routine circumstances they have a place but any changes made to the built environment are likely to last for 100 years. We don't even have a permanent Assistant Director in planning, the report comes from an acting AD i.e covering the post above the one he normally does. So in a year's time the AD could be gone and we are stuck with his delegated decisions for the next 100 years. Or has Mr Mustard missed the point. Will delegated powers be delegated to an outsourced provider like Capita and this change is to make the contract easier to manage?

Mr Mustard has been collecting screensavers on his secret visits to NLBP and so he can't describe Joe Henry as faceless unaccountable bureaucrat because we can see what he looks like. Just unaccountable to the electorate then.


Mr Mustard thinks that the little speech bubbles that the ADs make are just hollow words. Look at what Joe has said "improving customer journeys through the planning process" and then reconcile that to not leaving home because you were one of only 4 people to object to a planning application. 

Your journey will not be improved, it will be non-existent.

The number 4 bus will not be late after 16 June (but the route has been scrapped!).

Mr Mustard predicts that there will not be a reduction in the number of applications in front of the committee. Why? Well for a start all of the publicity which is about to be generated by Jack's press release in the local papers and on the blogs ( Mrs Angry is on the case as soon as she has finished with motherly domestic goddess duties; from lemon posset to a lemon of an idea? ) will mean that more people start to look at planning applications.

Secondly, because if you object to a planning application and send it to mrmustard@zoho.com, he will, provided he agrees with you, write a blog about it and submit an objection and invite others to do the same. 

Thirdly, because this might bring another blogger into being. One who specialises in planning matters. (There is still a vacancy for a blogger about Barnet Homes as well. Able to read boring reports, string a sentence together, add 2+2 and be half as funny as Mrs Angry)

Mr Mustard has to stop now and send an email to Uncle Eric, the fan of Barnet Bloggers (The Right Hon Eric Pickles MP) to let him know that localism isn't going very well in Barnet.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

9 June 2012

Councillors & public - put 7 July in your diary (please)

Councillor: I can't see anything wrong with One Barnet
 
If the One Barnet programme is robust it will be able to withstand proper scrutiny. I don't mean some feeble committee which will ask a few questions and then vote for what their colleagues have decided upon without proper understanding, real research or penetrating questions. I mean the sort of study that questions the fundamentals of something and gives them a good shake to see what happens.


Imagine that the purchase of a table is proposed.

Under proper scrutiny one would ask what is the purpose of the table, is it the best size of table, is it the best shape of table, is the surface properly finished, can sufficient people sit at the table, will it withstand the effect of hot tea cups, can one stand on the table (tables are not for standing on but it will happen at some time so best to plan for the probability) does the table have enough legs, what could we use instead of a table, do we even need a table, have we gone out to tender for the table?...............etc (you get the idea)

If a One Barnet table is proposed the scrutiny committee would probably coo over what a lovely OB table it was, ask the officer if other tables had been considered and get the answer "Yes, but they weren't as good" and then not ask any penetrating follow-up questions and go on to vote in favour of the table.

(The next chance for the public to see scrutiny in "action" is on Monday 11th June at 7pm when Business Management Overview & Scrutiny committee meets. Be at Hendon Town Hall by 7pm and see for yourself whether you think scrutiny is wonderful or woeful)

Many people know that the council is embarked on possibly the largest local authority outsourcing project ever seen. Other councils have started down this route, looked over the edge of the cliff and pulled back. The first section to be outsourced was parking ticket issue and enforcement on 1 May and already one of NSL's managers has had to be removed because he had tried to buy an iPhone using a fake credit card. Hardly a good start and an illustration of how outsourcing leads to lack of control.

Mr Mustard has looked at a lot of One Barnet reports and has yet to see a fully worked Cost Benefit Analysis. Mr Mustard does not mind if some services are outsourced if that would lead to economies of scale but for most services the council already has those. Take the parking contract. There were 75 people working on it. That is an organisation that is big enough to have economies of scale. Show Mr Mustard a service with just 2 employees and then he would agree that if say 10 of the councils in London got together that they could manage with less than 20 people and outsourcing might well make sense but even then it would be cheaper if one of the 10 councils took charge and simply spread the cost.

Unison exists to represent its members and can foresee that if One Barnet proceeds to the end that they may lose 70% of their local membership because their jobs could be exported to anywhere. We have already seen that 25 parking back-office staff have been made redundant and their jobs have been exported to Worthing. The council don't listen to Unison although they say they do (which is a different matter and will be the subject of a future post) and so Unison decided to commission an external consultant to study One Barnet. The consultant is called Andy Mudd and he is from APSE who say this about themselves:

The Association for Public Service Excellence (APSE) is a not-for-profit local government body working with over 300 councils throughout the UK promoting excellence in public services. APSE is the foremost specialist in local authority frontline services, hosting a network for frontline service providers in areas such as waste and refuse collection, parks and environmental services, leisure, school meals, cleaning, housing and building maintenance.

So you would think that if Unison arrange for APSE to run the ruler over One Barnet and produce a briefing that councillors (especially the conservative ones who run the council) would want to see it because it will vindicate their course of action? One would hope that was the case but sadly it isn't. Conservative councillors are showing a reluctance to attend any presentation by APSE (10 out of 63 councillors of all political hues have so far said they will attend the briefing being put on especially for councillors. The Salingers are notable, as ever, for their willingness to listen). What on earth can the rest be so worried about? Maybe that their grand project does not stand up to expert scrutiny (they can try and brush off criticism by Unison claiming ideological opposition and by Barnet's bloggers although they are possibly a bit harder to give the brush off to given the mounting readership and visibility that they are getting) but scrutiny is necessary and scrutiny is what you will get.

The public know very little about One Barnet, they have not been asked to vote on it by the local conservative candidates (although that is coming from opponents as the Brunswick Park by-election recently demonstrated) and residents are not allowed to ask questions about it at residents forums as it is a banned question, being about policy. Opponents of One Barnet have decided that if conservative councillors won't tell the public about One Barnet then they will. Surely councillors, you want to ensure complete accuracy, openness and transparency by being involved. Here is a second chance if you can't make the private screening. A public presentation by APSE, Professor Whtfield and Mr Reasonable (details copied from the Citizen Barnet blog) three men who know a lot


Barnet Council Not For Sale
Saturday 7 July 12–3pm,
Greek Cypriot Centre, 2 Britannia Road, North Finchley, London N12 9RU

A special conference by Barnet Alliance for Public Services and Barnet Unison

Speakers include:

Prof. Dexter Whitfield, Director of the European Services Strategy Unit
Mr. Andy Mudd, Principal Consultant in the Association for Public Service Excellence
Mr. John Dix, resident and "Mr Reasonable" blogger.

Refreshments provided. (councillors like free refreshments don't they?)


There is a small free car park at the centre for the first people to arrive but otherwise you are going to have to use pay-by-phone parking or do what Mr Mustard will do which is to drive about 250m north up the High Road (A1000) until you reach the end of CPZ zone sign and then park for free. Councillors can park for free using their any zone permit (if they haven't handed it back due to misuse) because this would be classed as on council business.

Mr Mustard hopes to see you there. This is only a mile or two from your home in Totteridge, Councillor Cornelius. Have a look in your diary and see if you can make room for this meeting. An easy walk also for Robert Rams and for Lisa Rutter who both also live in N20.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard