10 June 2012

Another nail being driven into the democracy coffin at Barnet Council

Proposed Revisions to Planning Delegated Powers at Barnet Council - 14 June 2012

Here is a press release issued by the hard working Liberal Democrat Councillor Jack Cohen, the councillor who strongly believes in the ethos of public service (words which you hear less often than excessively high executive pay at Barnet Council)

Barnet Council: Another attack on Public Participation

Councillor Jack Cohen Leader of Barnet Liberal Democrats is attacking proposed changes to the rules on public participation at planning committees. Under the existing rules if three or more residents object to a planning application it has to be determined by the Planning Committee. This is why Planning Committees are so well attended and why so many residents turn up to exercise their right to speak. As a result Committees are not able to conclude their business and meetings are being adjourned. The Council are so concerned about this that they are putting forward a recommendation to the Planning and Environment Committee that the minimum number of objectors that will trigger a referral to Committee is increased to five.

Cllr Jack Cohen a member of the Planning Committee since 1986 is incensed. Cllr Cohen who is credited with introducing the right for the public to speak at planning committee when the Liberal Democrats were in Joint Administration says the Conservatives never supported this. "gradually they have eroded the rights of residents and this is another example. The problem is all of their own making. Last year they reduced the number of planning sub committees from three to two. We predicted that this would cause difficulties. But instead of accepting responsibility they blame the public for having the effrontery to want to participate in the democratic process."

Cllr Cohen is calling on the Planning Committee to throw the proposals out. "I will be voting against it and warns Conservatives Councillors that the Public will never forgive them if they force this through"


Mr Mustard finds he often agrees with Jack Cohen (you will have to ask Jack himself if the inverse is true).

Barnet Council don't like the spotlight being on them because it shows up the appalling mess that they often make of things. In this case the change isn't for that reason (planning cockups have not recently been in the news as far as Mr Mustard recalls although the Carmelite monastery fiasco did cost a packet in 2010). The main driver seems to be cost saving, which is laudable when done in the right place, and the by-product is that democracy will be reduced except that Mr Mustard predicts that it won't.

Mr Mustard is not a fan of delegated powers. He can see that in routine circumstances they have a place but any changes made to the built environment are likely to last for 100 years. We don't even have a permanent Assistant Director in planning, the report comes from an acting AD i.e covering the post above the one he normally does. So in a year's time the AD could be gone and we are stuck with his delegated decisions for the next 100 years. Or has Mr Mustard missed the point. Will delegated powers be delegated to an outsourced provider like Capita and this change is to make the contract easier to manage?

Mr Mustard has been collecting screensavers on his secret visits to NLBP and so he can't describe Joe Henry as faceless unaccountable bureaucrat because we can see what he looks like. Just unaccountable to the electorate then.


Mr Mustard thinks that the little speech bubbles that the ADs make are just hollow words. Look at what Joe has said "improving customer journeys through the planning process" and then reconcile that to not leaving home because you were one of only 4 people to object to a planning application. 

Your journey will not be improved, it will be non-existent.

The number 4 bus will not be late after 16 June (but the route has been scrapped!).

Mr Mustard predicts that there will not be a reduction in the number of applications in front of the committee. Why? Well for a start all of the publicity which is about to be generated by Jack's press release in the local papers and on the blogs ( Mrs Angry is on the case as soon as she has finished with motherly domestic goddess duties; from lemon posset to a lemon of an idea? ) will mean that more people start to look at planning applications.

Secondly, because if you object to a planning application and send it to mrmustard@zoho.com, he will, provided he agrees with you, write a blog about it and submit an objection and invite others to do the same. 

Thirdly, because this might bring another blogger into being. One who specialises in planning matters. (There is still a vacancy for a blogger about Barnet Homes as well. Able to read boring reports, string a sentence together, add 2+2 and be half as funny as Mrs Angry)

Mr Mustard has to stop now and send an email to Uncle Eric, the fan of Barnet Bloggers (The Right Hon Eric Pickles MP) to let him know that localism isn't going very well in Barnet.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

9 June 2012

Councillors & public - put 7 July in your diary (please)

Councillor: I can't see anything wrong with One Barnet
 
If the One Barnet programme is robust it will be able to withstand proper scrutiny. I don't mean some feeble committee which will ask a few questions and then vote for what their colleagues have decided upon without proper understanding, real research or penetrating questions. I mean the sort of study that questions the fundamentals of something and gives them a good shake to see what happens.


Imagine that the purchase of a table is proposed.

Under proper scrutiny one would ask what is the purpose of the table, is it the best size of table, is it the best shape of table, is the surface properly finished, can sufficient people sit at the table, will it withstand the effect of hot tea cups, can one stand on the table (tables are not for standing on but it will happen at some time so best to plan for the probability) does the table have enough legs, what could we use instead of a table, do we even need a table, have we gone out to tender for the table?...............etc (you get the idea)

If a One Barnet table is proposed the scrutiny committee would probably coo over what a lovely OB table it was, ask the officer if other tables had been considered and get the answer "Yes, but they weren't as good" and then not ask any penetrating follow-up questions and go on to vote in favour of the table.

(The next chance for the public to see scrutiny in "action" is on Monday 11th June at 7pm when Business Management Overview & Scrutiny committee meets. Be at Hendon Town Hall by 7pm and see for yourself whether you think scrutiny is wonderful or woeful)

Many people know that the council is embarked on possibly the largest local authority outsourcing project ever seen. Other councils have started down this route, looked over the edge of the cliff and pulled back. The first section to be outsourced was parking ticket issue and enforcement on 1 May and already one of NSL's managers has had to be removed because he had tried to buy an iPhone using a fake credit card. Hardly a good start and an illustration of how outsourcing leads to lack of control.

Mr Mustard has looked at a lot of One Barnet reports and has yet to see a fully worked Cost Benefit Analysis. Mr Mustard does not mind if some services are outsourced if that would lead to economies of scale but for most services the council already has those. Take the parking contract. There were 75 people working on it. That is an organisation that is big enough to have economies of scale. Show Mr Mustard a service with just 2 employees and then he would agree that if say 10 of the councils in London got together that they could manage with less than 20 people and outsourcing might well make sense but even then it would be cheaper if one of the 10 councils took charge and simply spread the cost.

Unison exists to represent its members and can foresee that if One Barnet proceeds to the end that they may lose 70% of their local membership because their jobs could be exported to anywhere. We have already seen that 25 parking back-office staff have been made redundant and their jobs have been exported to Worthing. The council don't listen to Unison although they say they do (which is a different matter and will be the subject of a future post) and so Unison decided to commission an external consultant to study One Barnet. The consultant is called Andy Mudd and he is from APSE who say this about themselves:

The Association for Public Service Excellence (APSE) is a not-for-profit local government body working with over 300 councils throughout the UK promoting excellence in public services. APSE is the foremost specialist in local authority frontline services, hosting a network for frontline service providers in areas such as waste and refuse collection, parks and environmental services, leisure, school meals, cleaning, housing and building maintenance.

So you would think that if Unison arrange for APSE to run the ruler over One Barnet and produce a briefing that councillors (especially the conservative ones who run the council) would want to see it because it will vindicate their course of action? One would hope that was the case but sadly it isn't. Conservative councillors are showing a reluctance to attend any presentation by APSE (10 out of 63 councillors of all political hues have so far said they will attend the briefing being put on especially for councillors. The Salingers are notable, as ever, for their willingness to listen). What on earth can the rest be so worried about? Maybe that their grand project does not stand up to expert scrutiny (they can try and brush off criticism by Unison claiming ideological opposition and by Barnet's bloggers although they are possibly a bit harder to give the brush off to given the mounting readership and visibility that they are getting) but scrutiny is necessary and scrutiny is what you will get.

The public know very little about One Barnet, they have not been asked to vote on it by the local conservative candidates (although that is coming from opponents as the Brunswick Park by-election recently demonstrated) and residents are not allowed to ask questions about it at residents forums as it is a banned question, being about policy. Opponents of One Barnet have decided that if conservative councillors won't tell the public about One Barnet then they will. Surely councillors, you want to ensure complete accuracy, openness and transparency by being involved. Here is a second chance if you can't make the private screening. A public presentation by APSE, Professor Whtfield and Mr Reasonable (details copied from the Citizen Barnet blog) three men who know a lot


Barnet Council Not For Sale
Saturday 7 July 12–3pm,
Greek Cypriot Centre, 2 Britannia Road, North Finchley, London N12 9RU

A special conference by Barnet Alliance for Public Services and Barnet Unison

Speakers include:

Prof. Dexter Whitfield, Director of the European Services Strategy Unit
Mr. Andy Mudd, Principal Consultant in the Association for Public Service Excellence
Mr. John Dix, resident and "Mr Reasonable" blogger.

Refreshments provided. (councillors like free refreshments don't they?)


There is a small free car park at the centre for the first people to arrive but otherwise you are going to have to use pay-by-phone parking or do what Mr Mustard will do which is to drive about 250m north up the High Road (A1000) until you reach the end of CPZ zone sign and then park for free. Councillors can park for free using their any zone permit (if they haven't handed it back due to misuse) because this would be classed as on council business.

Mr Mustard hopes to see you there. This is only a mile or two from your home in Totteridge, Councillor Cornelius. Have a look in your diary and see if you can make room for this meeting. An easy walk also for Robert Rams and for Lisa Rutter who both also live in N20.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

8 June 2012

NSL - another staff fraudster

councillors sleepwalking into trouble
When Mr Mustard read about the Operational Support Manager ("OSM") who had been assigned to the Barnet contract by NSL who tried to buy an iphone with a fake credit card and received an 80hour unpaid work sentence Mr Mustard got to wondering how important the job of OSM was at NSL. Naturally, he turned to the Internet and from a link on the NSL website he was redirected to Totaljobs and found a vacancy in Birmingham, salary not stated, for which the main job elements are as follows:

The role will require you to support the Contract Manager in the implementation and maintenance of quality systems ensuring the best practice is identified and disseminated throughout the operation. The successful candidate would have to ensure effective communications both within the operation and with outside parties, representing the Company as appropriate.

The ideal candidate would have to:
  • Provide management information/reports as and when necessary for the Contract Manager.
  • Deal with all written customer enquiries and complaints in accordance with set standards and the customer care policy, logging each occasion against the appropriate case record.
  • Maintain adequate levels of all controlled and uncontrolled stationery
  • Prepare the monthly enforcement plan and to monitor the success of those on-going on a daily basis.
  • Assist in developing Quality Assurance systems and procedures in the service area
  • Receive and administer the implementation and removal of parking suspensions
  • Undertake the duties of the post in accordance with the Quality Assurance systems and procedures within the service.
This looks like a routine administration post which has an overblown title.

What happened in July 2011? Well an OSM called Bruno Inegbese received a sentence at Blackfriars Crown Court (case no. T20107575) of 40 months in jail because he failed to process the fact that 19 staff had left and continued to pay them. He then, with the help of family and friends, laundered their pay through 4 bank accounts and defrauded his employers of £48,000 (Mr Mustard wonders which council contract he was on and if NSL have credited the salaries back to the relevant council as they don't have to pay for ghost workers?)

He didn't work on the Barnet NSL contract because it didn't exist then but that is two Operations Support Managers, out of not all that many, that NSL have managed to find dishonest people to fill. One has to wonder about their recruitment systems and you need to realise, Barnet councillors, that by outsourcing the people you have not outsourced the problem. 

One Barnet = loss of control.

In Barnet, Unison, on behalf of their members have expressed concern about data security and NSL have made the usual bland and unconvincing corporate response; you can read it in the local paper here. . Have they actually done an audit of what their fraudulent employee got up to? Mr Mustard doubts it. 

Mr Mustard particularly likes this piece of puff which issued from NSL:

He had no access to information or data owned by members of the public

Now look at his job duties again:

Deal with all written customer enquiries and complaints in accordance with set standards and the customer care policy, logging each occasion against the appropriate case record.

Can you deal with an enquiry and edit a case record without having access to data or information? No.

Councillors. You are sleepwalking us all into trouble. Wake up and stop this outsourcing nonsense. You can, if you set your minds to it. Make the officers do some real work & make all of the savings yourself. Get all consultants out of the building and look at what you do and how you do it. Scrap processes that you do not have to do and devise methods of doing what you do have to do in the most effective way. It is How you do the job not Who does it that leads to savings as Andy Mudd of APSE (independent non-profit specialist in local authority service provision)  will tell you very soon (sorry Andy if I have stolen your thunder but you have much more to tell councillors than the message Mr Mustard took home as the essence of your recent presentation).

You will find Unison to be more amenable to in-house cooperation than complete outsourcing. John Burgess is an intelligent man, you need to talk to him more Richard (Cornelius).

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard



Not a joke - Traffic Warden - £8.20 an hour

click to enlarge
Imagine it out in all weathers and getting abuse from irate motorists and making the lives of people doing their best a misery and all for £8.20 an hour. What is that a year? On the standard 36 hour working week that Barnet Council uses it is £15,350 p.a. Would you do it for that? Is it fair and reasonable? What did Barnet Council pay when they employed traffic wardens (Civil Enforcement Officers) directly? Pay scale SCP20 as a minimum which is, Mr Mustard thinks, about £19,947 + the local government pension scheme membership which is worth having.

Civil Enforcement Officer - Role Profile - 100368

So this is the result of One Barnet outsourcing. A two tier workforce with one section getting paid 77% of what others doing the same job get.

What sort of workforce do you get at £8.20 an hour do you suppose? Probably just one that will take any job they can get. Do you leave school thinking you want to be a traffic warden? Mr Mustard didn't either but he did start life as the taxman although that wasn't the plan, being a civil servant was the plan. The way that life changes?

Did Barnet Council tell NSL they wanted pay rates cutting for traffic wardens in the contract they signed? Eventually Mr Mustard will be able to tell you but his FOI request of 13 March is stuck in the sidings somewhere at North London Business Park along with quite a few others. Mr Mustard doubts that a wage reduction is written into the contract but there could be any number of side conversations or unspoken expectations coming into play.

Ignore the bit in the advert by the way about the removal of vehicles. NSL either haven't bothered to read their contract or are too lazy to make a small amendment to their standard advert but vehicle removal is not carried out in Barnet and long may it stay that way as it does not make the borough a better place to live. Mr Mustard has asked officers to ensure that NSL don't advertise this again in the future. It's a good job he, and the other bloggers, are here to keep them on the straight and narrow.

Update on vehicle removal. It has been pointed out to Mr Mustard that abandoned vehicles do have to be removed in Barnet and so the advert may be referring to that removal. Mr Mustard is awaiting further clarification but he hopes that a specialist deals with authorising the removal of vehicles that appear to be abandoned and not someone on £8.20 per hour. Remember how many parking tickets get issued that have to be cancelled because they are wrong. Imagine what havoc would be wreaked if the CEO was able to authorise vehicle removal without proper checks and balances.

Mr Mustard wonders if any councillor knows what has happened to pay since they outsourced the parking contract or do they just wash their hands of it? Every by-election is a chance to remind them of their folly.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard




Proofreader wanted - apply to Barnet Council

you should see the desk

Mr Mustard received a circular letter from the Council. He was pleased that from now on the green bin would be collected on a different day to the black bin as it stops bin wars erupting on the pavement. He was slightly less pleased that the letter was a sloppy piece of work which had not been properly checked.


The front page is not too bad. No email address is given even though that is supposedly the preferred method of contact (or is it no contact at all?) the use of right justify was abandoned in the final paragraph, Jason can't make up his mind if he works in "Street Scene" or "Streetscene" and the use of 02nd and 01st looks rather odd. It is when one turns over that the letter gets amusing.


Seedling marked compostable bags cost about £3 for 20 which seems like an amazingly expensive waste of money when you can throw your food waste straight into the green bin. Mr Mustard's co-Director, also a local resident, who has run a business for 25 years, and dealt with all sorts of complex business problems, was amazed to find she needed to be told how to put a bag into a bin, fill it and then throw it away! The public are not that stupid.

There is an error. "your blue box" has been printed as "you blue box". Mr Mustard is not a blue box! (mustard coloured if anything)

Now it is time that you owned up. How many times have you mistaken your old plastic garden chairs for something that you grew in the garden? Never. The same as Mr Mustard. This most interesting exclusion is not repeated on the website.

Now branching out there is a huge gaff. The leaflet says you can recycle branches up to 20cm in diameter. That is 8 inches in old money. That is more like a tree trunk than a branch. If made of larch a branch that was 20cm in diameter and 60cm long would weigh about 17kg. You would be struggling to lift it up into the bin and the bin would doubtless get rejected on the health and safety grounds of being too heavy, and fair enough too. The website says 8cm (3inches) diameter which seems more reasonable. What has happened? Someone has seen 8cm and thought it was 8inches, decided we have gone metric and multiplied 8inches by 2.5 and got 20cm. That person has not then stopped to think "ooh, that sounds a bit large, am I sure" and probably hasn't shown the leaflet to anyone else. Senior management are too busy grappling with the One Barnet monster to take much notice of day to day routine and so sloppiness becomes endemic.

It has got to stop.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard

Pay consultants accused of conflicts of interest

Take a look at this article in the Guardian of 5 June 2012
Pay consultants accused of conflicts of interest
70% of remuneration consultants behind bumper executive pay packages earn fees from extra services to same firms

What the article says is that companies who provide a service setting pay of executives who provide other services to the same clients have a conflict of interest e.g. if you help to hire executives and your reward is a percentage of their earnings then there is no incentive to keep the recommended pay scale down.

Note who got a mention in the article. The Hay Group (don't confuse them with Hays Employment, they are different) and so this is of interest to readers in Barnet:

...and Xstrata, which employs the Hay Group, another consulting firm which sold additional pay data to the mining group.

Now look at the papers from the first meeting of the Remuneration Committee of Barnet Council. Who do you find there, The Hay Group (and Penna)

Remuneration Committee Reports 9 May 2012
Do The Hay Group sell any other services to Barnet Council? It would seem so.

 
Department Item Date Ref Value £
Children's Service Staff Training 20/10/2010 5000277068 34,100
Children's Service Staff Training 11/11/2010 5000280404 22,050
Children's Service Staff Training 11/11/2010 5000280419 850
Children's Service Staff Training 10/01/2011 5000287081 30,000
Children's Service Staff Training 11/02/2011 5000291595 22,050
Deputy Chief Executive Consult Fees 10/03/2011 5000295930 6,491
Deputy Chief Executives Consult Fees 15/08/2011 5000314400 5,000
Deputy Chief Executives Consult Fees 05/10/2011 5000319582 20,190
Children's Service Staff Training 13/01/2012 5000330514 22,050
Total


162,781

Richard Cornelius asked a question of Sarah Murphy-Brookman at that meeting. Are there other (pay measurement) systems. SBM replied that there were but they were not as robust. How very interesting that the Guardian article also mentions firms called Deloitte, Towers Watson, Kepler and Hewitt New Bridge Street so there is plenty of choice. You need, Richard, to start asking questions to which you already know the answer otherwise what is the point? or when you get the answer which is vague to keep asking until all of the relevant facts are out in the open.

What evidence is there that the Hay system is the most robust? None that we have seen. 

If there had been competition for the pay scale setting work it could have been done on the basis that it is the only type of work which the winning bidder could do for the council in order to get some impartiality into the equation.

There is something called the  Framework Agreement RM692 which has been set up by the Government Procurement Service ("GPS") for the supply of non-permanent staff and which Barnet Council can sign up to and use without getting into a long tendering process. In Lot 6a there is a supplier called the Moorhouse Penna Partnership.

Mr Mustard sent GPS the following question:

I note that a supplier in lot 6a of Framework Agreement RM692 for non permanent staff is named as the "Moorhouse Penna Partnership".

I would like to know which companies make up this partnership please.
The answer duly came

For the purposes of the Non-Permanent Staff framework agreement, the Moorhouse Penna Partnership consists of Moorehouse (sic) Consulting, Hay Group, Penna and BiP Solutions
If you look at the recommendation on the first page of the Senior Posts and Council Re-organisation report it recommends Hay as Reward advisers and Penna as Recruitment advisers. It would have been open and transparent if the fact that they operate in a partnership had been noted but we have to find these things out for ourselves.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard



7 June 2012

One Barnet is bad for your Heart

Over the jubilee holiday Mr Mustard relaxed and had plenty of time to read the paper and there was an article about heart attacks which is of relevance in the light of One Barnet.

One Barnet is the umbrella name for just about every change going on at Barnet Council whereby a vast number of jobs are being outsourced (the council will use other more vague terminology like provider or partner) to BT or Capita or some other huge monster of a company.

Barnet Council also now has a lead role in improving the health of residents. One of its targets is to "increase the number of smoking quitters in people aged 18 and over to 2,200". You can see this target in the following document.
Adult Social Care and Health

Now it is Mr Mustard's hypothesis that the One Barnet programme will lead to less opportunities for staff to even hold on their jobs, never mind get promoted. In a shrinking organisation, how can there be increased opportunities? The council will claim that one of the benefits of One Barnet outsourcing is better opportunities for staff within the new organisation. Look, here is an example from February in relation to the huge NSCSO ( New Support & Customer Services Organisation) project.
NSCSO Staff Briefings Feb 2012
That is clear, is it not? Isn't outsourcing a wonderful thing for staff?

Now let us look at the reality of outsourcing in the real world, not the fluffy world of One Barnet. On 1 May 2012 NSL took over parking enforcement. There were about 75 staff involved. 50 of those are traffic wardens. Their work has to be done locally. It simply cannot take place outside of Barnet. Mr Mustard saw the same familiar faces in May (he chats to all of the wardens when he sees them) as he did in April. The 25 back office staff had their jobs transferred to Worthing (it was Croydon at first, see how flexible the labour market is!) which really isn't commutable from Barnet. On the day they were officially TUPE transferred to NSL they got "at risk" letters and on 31 May they were all made redundant. So much for protecting their terms and conditions. Are you noting this councillors? 25 of your staff made redundant because of a decision that you made.

If you work in DRS and NSCSO you can't trust the fancy powerpoint presentations, can you?

Now having established that promotion opportunities are reduced Mr Mustard will tell you about you some research that was the subject of an article in the Guardian at the weekend "Job promotions reduce the risk of a heart attack". You can get a digest of the research here or by clicking on the word "article" above and then on the link within the article itself. It is very interesting and worrying research. Here is a potted summary.

Michael Anderson, assistant professor of agricultural and resource economics at the University of California, Berkeley, and Michael Marmot, professor of epidemiology and public health at University College London, tracked the employment histories and health outcomes of 4,700 civil servants in the London area.

They found that those civil servants in departments with high rates of promotion were approximately 20% less likely to develop heart disease than their counterparts in departments with low rates of promotion.

Reducing smoking rates is all about decreasing smoking related illnesses such as heart attacks, and Mr Mustard doesn't want to worry council employees, but it looks like the One Barnet programme will increase them. That was something no-one thought of for the One Barnet risk register (unless it is one of the many redacted entries) and they had better add an entry for now.

The following report (to December 11) shows that the number of smoking quitters is on target but that mortality from cardiovascular disease is still too high.

Barnet Council performance indicators q3 11-12

If you work for the council and want promotion you should join a more sensible council, or a private sector employer with a good reputation for looking after their staff, or start your own business. You will also help yourself if you don't smoke, if you drink less ( OK; pot, kettle!) and if you take exercise but hey it's your body so do as you please.

Yours frugally

Mr Mustard