18 November 2026

Why we need a parking ombudsman - #5

The below cctv is what supports Barnet Council's erroneous belief that a yellow box junction has occurred.

 

They are misguided in their belief and the person who hit the button to issue a PCN in this case needs more careful training (always assuming it isn't a decision made by AI).

When does a contravention occur?  


Mr Mustard set out in the formal representations what was wrong (a response is awaited, this is quite fresh)

 

This PCN should never have been issued. The problem with legislation for enforcement authorities which gives them huge powers is that according to Lord Mustill in the case of Doody is they are expected to behave properly but what if they don't?

What does fairness require in the present case? My Lords, I think it unnecessary to refer by name or to quote from, any of the often-cited authorities in which the courts have explained what is essentially an intuitive judgment. They are far too well known. From them, I derive that:-

  1. Where an Act of Parliament confers an administrative power there is a presumption that it will be exercised in a manner which is fair in all the circumstances.

 

As parking, bus lane and moving traffic PCNs have become such a rich source of revenue for enforcement authorities they have become giddy with power, are abusing it and there is no-one to stop them. The role of adjudicators is to decide on such PCNs as people fight all the way to London Tribunals (or TPT outside London) and no-one is tasked with ensuring is empowered to protect the public from the zealous.

It is no comfort that there is the right to contest a clearly wrongful allegation, which some people are not very well equipped to do, wasting everyone's time and causing worry and there is always the possibility that a new adjudicator or one on a bad day would get the answer wrong.

Many lease companies, wrongly in Mr Mustard's view, simply pay PCNs and unless they transfer liability to the lessee, the PCN is over and the lessee is forced to repay £80 for the PCN and ad admin fee of anything up to £40. That cannot be right.

There is no need for councils to cheat, there are plentiful real contraventions.

For expert yellow box advice, look here. 

The end, for now.

15 November 2026

Why we need a parking ombudsman - #4

 

Mr Mustard does not know Mr Corrigan, he just happened to read this tribunal decision.


So what we have here is an innocent person forced to defend 15 PCNs of which 14 were quite properly cancelled by other enforcement authorities as Mr Corrigan has clearly reported the cloning added to which the van has never been to London. An RF registration is a Stoke-on-Trent one and although that doesn't mean necessarily that the vehicle is from that area it probably is, it certainly isn't from Barnet.

Barnet are abusing their powers in not cancelling like everybody else as there is nothing to differentiate their PCN from the others. In fact they have even less information as it isn't a parking PCN which offers the opportunity to take a photo of the VIN. I have seen this stubbornness from barnet Council before in the absence of any facts to show that the vehicle the council saw on cctv is the one to which the registration plate properly belongs.

As it happens you can fix this type of PCN fairly easily. As well as providing photos of your vehicle from the front, back and both sides and prove you have reported the cloning you can then put the ball into the council's court by pointing out tribunal decision number 22201717836 from which the following is an extract.


In Mr Corrigan's case his problems may be at an end as the road fund expired on 28 February 26 and the MOT on 12 May 26 and the van had done 132,015 miles at the May 2025 MOT so may have been taken off the road.

Don't let Barnet Council bully you, make them work for their money. Mr Corrigan was given extra unwarranted stress, it is hard enough to keep up with the paperwork for 15 erroneous PCNs (about two grand's worth) as it is without a bovine response from Barnet Council.

The end. 

10 November 2026

Why we need a parking ombudsman - #3

 

Mr Mustard had a PCN case on which he was asking the council to exercise discretion and they had declined. Mr Mustard took the case to independent adjudication, he wanted to show that Hounslow Council had not properly considered exercising their discretion against their own guidelines so he asked to see them.

The case was coming up when Mr Mustard noticed in February that he had not received a response. FOI promised to chase up the relevant person.

Mr Mustard won the Appeal at the tribunal on the basis of lack of consideration of the motorist's medical condition and after that Mr Mustard forgot all about the FOI request and he was surprised this week when it arrived, a year after asking. 


 
The Statutory Guidance of the Secretary of State is something to which Hounslow Council should have 'due regard'. They clearly had no regard to it and this means the public don't know if their particular circumstances might be good enough to get a PCN cancelled.


Councils 'should' publish their policies so it isn't mandatory but it would be useful to have an Ombudsman with the power to decide that the 'should' is in fact a 'must' publish so there is 100% transparency and a fairer system.

2 November 2026

Why we need a parking ombudsman - #2

 

It was 7:20am in Islington when the plumber, from the edge of London, reached the site. He must have been out of bed at sparrow's fart, it was dark, he paid for his parking but selected zone B instead of E. The council happily accepted his £44.65 the same charge as zone E would have been.

At 9:01 he received a PCN which confused him as he had paid for all day. Mr Mustard spotted the zone problem. This is the sort of error for which all councils should exercise discretion and cancel. Mr Mustard made the informal challenge (the one in response to the PCN on the windscreen)

The second argument was a makeweight / just in case one but you never know.

A miserable rejection followed and ignored the bits that Islington Council didn't like:


Next came the Notice to Owner and the formal representation made was a repeat of the informal challenge.

A second rejection arrived.


The empathy faded when it came to the yes / no decision. Following a recent trend the discount was not offered again, it didn't have to be but it guarantees Mr Mustard will proceed to the tribunal as there is nothing to lose.

It was in April that Mr Mustard started the tribunal Appeal. As is currently common there was a 6 month delay as the number of tribunal Appeals has shot up and the number of adjudicators cannot be increased overnight.

It is usual for the council to lay out its arguments in a case summary. 

Mr Mustard regarded the RingGo excuse as a feeble one. Islington Council could negotiate a contract with RingGo that says they should refund for all payment errors such as wrong registration, wrong date or wrong bay number / type. They helpfully exhibited the RingGo terms, terms which the motorist has no choice except to accept because only one payment provider exists, this looks like an unfair contract term to Mr Mustard. Mr Mustard went to the RingGo website and clearly they will do whatever the council agrees with them as policy, that was doublespeak from Islington Council


Mr Mustard then looked at the rules of Islington Council as set out in the Traffic Management Order 2023/001 as contained in Regulation 19, you can go straight to (3)


More misleading information in the response. The council has a discretion to refund but it wrote instead that it was not obliged, did they even consider it for a second.

This is why we need an Ombudsman, to get unfair terms taken out of traffic orders, to make councils think more sensibly about the exercise of discretion and to not mislead the public.

The tribunal hearing arrived, the adjudicator had looked in advance at the paperwork and wasn't with Mr Mustard on the B or E argument but Mr Mustard pulled an ace out of his sleeve and identified a failure by the council to prove their case which the adjudicator instantly accepted and ordered the council to cancel the PCN. Justice was done but to some people that £44 could have really stung.

The end.